Live data from Hacker News

Show HN: StackOverflow.gg – AI-generated answers to every coding question

stackoverflow.gg

91–100 of 161 posts

Re: Show HN: StackOverflow.gg – AI-generated answers to every coding question

#91
post #21
post #3

I hope no one actually trusts that for real answers, just based on what we've seen it try to do already.

Lol just yesterday I saw an eight year old answer on SO neatly solving my problem, except the API was hallucinated. Humans have been hallucinating APIs for far longer.

Could you post the link here, thats really curious.

Re: Show HN: StackOverflow.gg – AI-generated answers to every coding question

#92

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's a gargantuan task to clean up low quality post and fight back low quality copy paste blog spam from a community that has become resume padding for the masses. The community has spoken, to the extent whether the majority of usage becomes the defacto standard, and basically filtered out all but the most basic coding issues that are just one peg above homework assignments.

Well, I wouldn’t say it was the community speaking. This is what the operators wanted because the old way was not “welcoming” enough and didn’t contribute enough to growth. Hey, it’s a business. I get it.

No, it wasn’t “not ‘welcoming’”, it was just “not welcoming”. Sure it’s the owners who forced this, but it’s not a bad thing to be more welcoming and thinking otherwise because “it’s better” is problematic. You should also blame the owners for not giving a shit about moderation for the low quality of things now, if you want to blame them for the push for being “welcoming”.

Re: Show HN: StackOverflow.gg – AI-generated answers to every coding question

#93

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> They're the one saying people at SO aren't nice. They never said that. They said that stupid comments get posted.

I quote it in my parent post directly. So yes, they said that.

wokwokwok did not say that. wokwokwok replied to a comment that said that, but did not say it themself.

Re: Show HN: StackOverflow.gg – AI-generated answers to every coding question

#95

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Here's an experiment: Visit new questions: https://stackoverflow.com/questions?tab=Newest Scroll until you find an upvoted question. Count how many downvotes you see on the way. You can often get to page 2 with dozens of downvotes before the first upvote. Hard mode: Scroll until the net upvotes are more than the net downvotes.

What should that prove? If anything, it backs up my point: the amount of noise is huge. But I tried: scrolled two pages. Most questions were at 0 votes. But I checked every down voted question, and they were all useless. No code, just a vague statement of trying to do something.

"But I checked every down voted question, and they were all useless. No code, just a vague statement of trying to do something."

That's exactly it. Someone out there is asking for help. They don't know how to ask or where to start. Then they get shut down by the community for being useless and vague instead of guided on the right questions to ask.

This is the first downvoted question I see: https://stackoverflow.com/questions/75396340/java-17-switch-...

It's someone who does not understand switch and wants to know why their code doesn't match with their understanding of switch. There's no given reason for the downvote.

ChatGPT at least takes the effort to make sense of the question and verifies that this is what the asker intended.

Re: Show HN: StackOverflow.gg – AI-generated answers to every coding question

#96

It won’t truly match the experience, unless it can inject veiled insults into the answers. /s

I don't get this hate-boner HN has for SO. Have you tried being active there? It's super easy to not have your question closed, just do the minimum amount of effort. And if you're active, you'll see the thousands of similar questions arrive every day. If you're active in the review queues, you will see all the spam, broken answers, non-SO fitting questions etc. people churn out. I see people complain about how their…

It very much depends on the tags you use. Swift and iOS is absolutely abysmal and questions will be closed as duplicates of questions that have been irrelevant for years. Go and Haskell are great though.

Re: Show HN: StackOverflow.gg – AI-generated answers to every coding question

#97
post #71

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Tell him what? It is annoying that they don't return the output instantly. This does throttle usage, so I can see why they do it, but it is annoying.

The chatgpt output comes in chunks from openai's servers themselves, it can't get computed instantly. There's no way for this plugin to do what you want it to do.

OpenAI could return it instantly if they wanted.

Re: Show HN: StackOverflow.gg – AI-generated answers to every coding question

#98
post #95

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What should that prove? If anything, it backs up my point: the amount of noise is huge. But I tried: scrolled two pages. Most questions were at 0 votes. But I checked every down voted question, and they were all useless. No code, just a vague statement of trying to do something.

"But I checked every down voted question, and they were all useless. No code, just a vague statement of trying to do something." That's exactly it. Someone out there is asking for help. They don't know how to ask or where to start. Then they get shut down by the community for being useless and vague instead of guided on the right questions to ask. This is the first downvoted question I see: https://stackoverflow.com/…

Do you see stack overflow as a resource for total beginners? Such a question has no place on SO from my perspective. A chat with a more experienced person would be much more helpful and chatgpt could be the next best thing in this context.

Re: Show HN: StackOverflow.gg – AI-generated answers to every coding question

#100
This just feels like the wrong way around, I go to stackoverflow for stuff chatgpt can't answer. If anything, the right tool would be something which turns chatgpt threads into a stackoverflow question. (I don't actually think that is a good idea, just that it would make more sense)
Post reply on HN