Live data from Hacker News

Show HN: I made an open-source Loom alternative

cap.so

71–80 of 184 posts

Re: Show HN: I made an open-source Loom alternative

#71

Some feedback on your site's UX - on desktop, I don't expect hovering on a menu item to open a new context, so by habit I click on it. You're opening on hover, though, and my click is closing the context immediately.

thanks for this! agreed, will fix.

Re: Show HN: I made an open-source Loom alternative

#72

Reasons I use Loom: - Social features, users can comment & engage with my video to provide feedback - Analytics, I get notifications when a user views a video (useful for demos/sales) - Post-capture editing - Set 1.X speed by default on videos (significantly reduces video length) I don't find the capturing element of loom very good. Their chrome integration is pretty bad, seems to not handle clicking/changing pages w…

I've found some of Loom's auto-descriptions (including previews in Slack) to be pretty solid use case for AI.

Re: Show HN: I made an open-source Loom alternative

#73

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I have no idea what Loom is, I also have the same issue I didn't tell me what the product is and just got confuse and didn't explore further.

Same. I’ve never heard of Loom and (therefore?) I’m honestly not sure how this would be different on a Mac than a QuickTime screen recording. And since the promo images are from a Mac, my first thought is Quicktime is probably safer.

Just to address this comment chain: loom does make it easier to do screen recordings and demos, and additionally has features like timestamped comments and notes and sharing functionality.

The target customer is a business who is making demo videos and needs these kinds of tracking/collaboration/commenting features.

Folks interested in open source maybe want a better offering, don’t want to be locked in, want more favorable pricing, or want a self hosted version.

As someone who has used loom, the value proposition is clear from the title without even going to the website.

Re: Show HN: I made an open-source Loom alternative

#74
post #67

Some honest feedback: describe your product/tool without using a competitor’s name. I’m on mobile and the landing page only tells me “recording software” and “Loom” before it drops into Twitter like 3rd party comments. I honestly have never used Loom. I don’t know what it is. Do you really want me to have to go look up “the competition” just to know who you are?

I disagree - the fact you don’t know what Loom is probably means you’re not in the market for this kind of software. Better, at this stage, to focus on users who will immediately get it rather than explain to folks who don’t currently have a need.

People may well use Loom-like functionality that’s integrated into other tools they use without knowing the name “Loom”.

Loom had a head-start, but other companies (e.g. Vimeo) copied the feature pretty quickly.

And also, more importantly, this is a “Show HN” post, so reasonable for people here to question the comparison.

Re: Show HN: I made an open-source Loom alternative

#75
Feedback: can there be a big “loom” on the homepage showing how it works or what differentiates it? Right now we only see tweets but nothing that gives me the “aha” moment to want to try it out.

Make me remember the pain, and show me really clearly how your software will fix it right now. Screen studio does a good job of this.

Re: Show HN: I made an open-source Loom alternative

#77

How does it compare to using either of the following on macOS - OBS - The built in screen recording functionality in macOS itself - ffmpeg (see http://trac.ffmpeg.org/wiki/Capture/Desktop for details on doing screen capture with it)

Windows also has built-in screen recording.

Re: Show HN: I made an open-source Loom alternative

#79
post #70

Some honest feedback: describe your product/tool without using a competitor’s name. I’m on mobile and the landing page only tells me “recording software” and “Loom” before it drops into Twitter like 3rd party comments. I honestly have never used Loom. I don’t know what it is. Do you really want me to have to go look up “the competition” just to know who you are?

Definitely agree with what you're saying. It's easier for us at the start to get some attention from Loom specific users by mentioning Loom directly, but it's not a sustainable strategy going forward. Will update the marketing copy etc over the coming weeks/months to be more about the problem we're solving specifically.

Yeah. I get that. And I’m sure there’s some SEO-style positive feedback you get for it. But also being able to pitch it to me in a simple way and then using Loom as an example I think would be more helpful.

“Screen recording software that emphasizes simple sharing. An open source alternative to Loom”. Still super simple but is more useful to people less exposed to your world.

Re: Show HN: I made an open-source Loom alternative

#80
post #35

If there’s one way to turn off a good portion of people from using your project, it’s by locking down the community into a discord.

Highly disagree! Though I would like the community to not be on discord, every other competitor has lost to discord.
Post reply on HN