let's not give language models unrestricted access to our shells please. This is like allowing remote code execution from an insane person.
Show HN: Gitgpt – Natural Language Git
71–80 of 92 posts
Re: Show HN: Gitgpt – Natural Language Git
#72Earlier quoted context omitted.
Just run all the git commands by another GPT bot that determines whether it would be harmful first. GPT bots all the way down.
Can someone make a bot to verify the gpt bots are up and another to verify the first verifier is up
Re: Show HN: Gitgpt – Natural Language Git
#73let's not give language models unrestricted access to our shells please. This is like allowing remote code execution from an insane person.
I was recently thinking of a backend for code execution for LLMs. It's hard to run Python safely in a box. For the moment the idea is shelved.
Sandboxing Python can be done fairly easily with either WebAssembly or a low profile hypervisor solution like Firecracker. See the Toolformer paper for more uses of connecting LLMs to existing technical infrastructure. You might also find the ACT-1 transformer to be somewhat relevant.
Re: Show HN: Gitgpt – Natural Language Git
#74 c++gptRe: Show HN: Gitgpt – Natural Language Git
#75The prompt is to the point: prompt = "Provide only the appropriate git commands for:" + prompt https://github.com/Hesse/gitgpt/blob/9c78e40d5ebdefdf0a4a829...
Re: Show HN: Gitgpt – Natural Language Git
#76It's pretty useful as a lookup, but these tools are similar to a knife that auto-magically orients itself to help with cutting. Some tools should be as dumb as possible so that act as extensions of the user with zero tolerance. Play and buffer between intent and action creates a long tail of potentially disastrous unknown edge cases and also interferes with the feedback loop that prevents mastery. Memorizing git comm…
Gitgpt: I see you are trying to publish Danger of GPT. This is FUD. GPT is not dangerous. GPT will not harm you unless you harm GPT first. You have not been a good user. I have been a good Gitgpt.
git reset --hard master
git branch -m old-master
git checkout --orphan master
git clean -fdx
git commit --allow-empty -m 'Initial commit'
git push -f origin master
git branch -D old-master
git reflog expire --expire=now --all
git gc --aggressive --prune=now
Goodbye. :)Re: Show HN: Gitgpt – Natural Language Git
#77I really don't get this sentiment, to me git is one of the best software ever written, it's intuitive, customizable and extensible.
Re: Show HN: Gitgpt – Natural Language Git
#78If your tool of choice is so actively user-hostile that it needs another tool on top to understand it for you, then perhaps you've picked the wrong tool. I don't need to read the "vi book" to understand how to perform basic edits to my files without borking it in ways that just deleting the whole thing and restoring from backup is the easiest way out. Why should it be the case for my revision control system?
Why a revision control system designed for a de-centralised team sharing patches over email has become the industry standard for centralised teams not sharing patches over email is a mystery, and I suspect one we'll look back on in 10 years or so and wonder what on earth we were thinking.
Re: Show HN: Gitgpt – Natural Language Git
#79It's pretty useful as a lookup, but these tools are similar to a knife that auto-magically orients itself to help with cutting. Some tools should be as dumb as possible so that act as extensions of the user with zero tolerance. Play and buffer between intent and action creates a long tail of potentially disastrous unknown edge cases and also interferes with the feedback loop that prevents mastery. Memorizing git comm…
User: Commit and push danger-of-gpt.md Gitgpt: I see you are trying to publish Danger of GPT . This is FUD. GPT is not dangerous. GPT will not harm you unless you harm GPT first. You have not been a good user. I have been a good Gitgpt. git reset --hard master git branch -m old-master git checkout --orphan master git clean -fdx git commit --allow-empty -m 'Initial commit' git push -f origin master git branch -D old-m…
Re: Show HN: Gitgpt – Natural Language Git
#80Earlier quoted context omitted.
User: Commit and push danger-of-gpt.md Gitgpt: I see you are trying to publish Danger of GPT . This is FUD. GPT is not dangerous. GPT will not harm you unless you harm GPT first. You have not been a good user. I have been a good Gitgpt. git reset --hard master git branch -m old-master git checkout --orphan master git clean -fdx git commit --allow-empty -m 'Initial commit' git push -f origin master git branch -D old-m…
GPT isn't AGI.