Live data from Hacker News

Show HN: Maskmail – anonymous email address service

maskmail.net

61–70 of 78 posts

Re: Show HN: Maskmail – anonymous email address service

#61
post #22

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Will you add support for Bring-Your-Own-Domain? This HN commenter is definitely interested.

We hadn't considered it, but it's an interesting idea. We'd have to think through how to make it work, there'd be some interesting interplay with routing and mail servers.

[deleted]

Re: Show HN: Maskmail – anonymous email address service

#62
post #14
post #2

Nice idea, but I suspect if it gets any traction, many services will just block maskmail addresses. That's why mailinator uses 100s of different domains and makes it really hard to get a list of all of them.

Which also means users can't use them either. Sometimes I want to use a different mailinator domain, but loading the homepage usually only shows the known domains.

You could always point your own domain at it instead.

Re: Show HN: Maskmail – anonymous email address service

#63
post #27
post #13

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That works great if you control your own mail server, but most people don't these days. :)

The reason for this is of course that it's a complete pain to work with the large email providers (say, you want to send an email to gmail) if you have your own service. Email has been far from truly decentralised for a while now.

It's not that bad really. Been doing it since more than a decade.

Re: Show HN: Maskmail – anonymous email address service

#65
post #52

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I imagine they're worried about their service being used to send spam, which would trash their reputation as a sender.

You can’t spam using either of those protocols.

1. Sign up for an account to comment, using a free email account

2. POP3/IMAP your email to your bot, clicking any links

3. Write spammy comments

Re: Show HN: Maskmail – anonymous email address service

#66
post #33

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Note it says "anonymous", not "disposable". > the whole point of a disposable e-mail address it's that you just can use it instantly and never reveal your real e-mail addresses to anyone For you maybe. For others the point might be "never reveal my real e-mail address to the sites I give disposable addresses to, be able to keep receiving e-mails for some of them long-term and not having them publicly exposed to every…

Why not create a Gmail account for that purpose then? (Or Yahoo/Outlook if you're concerned with data collection.) The amount of hassle is the same. With Mailinator I just type khdgfkasjdhfg in the register field, then then type Ctrl+L "maili" [Enter], paste khdgfkasjdhfg in the (already active) "Check Any Inbox" field and bang! - I'm already there, always. Maybe there's something I don't see here.

If you create a new Gmail account, as many people do, you can still be tracked with that. Using the same email address on multiple sites allows data aggregators to match your profiles from each site to build a very comprehensive picture of you. Of course, you could create hundreds of Gmail accounts, but then you have to manage hundreds of inboxes, which you won't do well leading to you missing lots of emails.

Maskmail essentially does this for you with extreme convenience.

Re: Show HN: Maskmail – anonymous email address service

#67
post #32

A bit off topic but does anyone know of an email service that doesn't require a pre-existing email account, doesn't require ID, is TOR friendly and accepts cryptocurrency as payment? It seems like this should be an obvious service but I have a hard time finding one.

https://cock.li

tor friendly. free (runs of donations). no email or id required.

also has tons of cool domain names to choose from. some of my favorites: horsefucker.org, cumallover.me, nigge.rs, rape.lol, nuke.africa

Re: Show HN: Maskmail – anonymous email address service

#68
post #63
post #27

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The reason for this is of course that it's a complete pain to work with the large email providers (say, you want to send an email to gmail) if you have your own service. Email has been far from truly decentralised for a while now.

It's not that bad really. Been doing it since more than a decade.

If you enjoy the administrative work that comes with it (removing yourself from "you exist and you are therefore banned" blocklists, trying to convince gmail/hotmail/etc that you're really a real person, etc) then yes, it's not hard. If you use email, want it to work and don't enjoy extra administrative duties on top of your day job, I'd say it is that bad.

Re: Show HN: Maskmail – anonymous email address service

#70
post #2

Nice idea, but I suspect if it gets any traction, many services will just block maskmail addresses. That's why mailinator uses 100s of different domains and makes it really hard to get a list of all of them.

Many services block all mailinator domains by simply doing a live MX record lookup and noting the domain is pointed at mailinator (there are SaaS companies that offer this via an API). Another thing I've noticed is blocking email addresses on domains that do catch-all receiving. It's really frustrating.

I've used sneakemail for a very long time, but I've found that it's actually been resulting in worse things than simply having my registration blocked.

* Credit Karma banned my account (that I'd had for eight years)

* HP canceled my order for a laptop AFTER IT SHIPPED, recalling the package

I've had to switch to sneakemail only for things that I wouldn't provide my name to anyway.

Post reply on HN