Live data from Hacker News

Show HN: Percy.io, a continuous visual integration tool

percy.io

51–57 of 57 posts

Re: Show HN: Percy.io, a continuous visual integration tool

#52
This looks like a great project! It looks pretty similar to PhantomCSS, but you're taking the pain out of hosting, which I appreciate: https://github.com/Huddle/PhantomCSS

One of my biggest struggles is introducing development practices like regression testing to traditional designers, a problem which is compounded by a lack of good tooling. Hopefuly Percy (and other tools like it) can help to alleviate this Problem.

I wonder if we could eventually even have TDD for designs. So once a component is designed in Photoshop, the first step would be to submit an image into Percy and then subsequent commits would check if the CSS had evolved to the point where it matched the original static design.

Re: Show HN: Percy.io, a continuous visual integration tool

#54
Doesn't say what it does. I can deduce from the title and landing page that it has something to do with UIs and CI. From the FAQ it seems it is web only, as it mentions "the page" (assume that is an html page).

Is this an appropriate summary?

"It can help you visually review changes made to a web front end as part of CI/QA"

Would be neat if you could plug any kind of front end screenshot rendering and not just web.

Re: Show HN: Percy.io, a continuous visual integration tool

#56
My favorite in this space is Applitools eyes (https://applitools.com/).

Eyes has really advances image processing capabilities, which meant two huge advantages over everything else I looked at:

1. It's not prone to rendering differences. I can set a baseline in one browser/OS combo, run it on other combinations and set it to only consider real regressions as a failure.

2. It can validate the layout of the page even with dynamic content.

Re: Show HN: Percy.io, a continuous visual integration tool

#57
post #27

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'm a member of organisations that may not be comfortable with me giving permission by proxy. I couldn't find a way to sign up and exclude private repos or organizations.

That's weird, because I'm a member of an org that Github explicitly requires you approve this access for apps like this.

is this tool any good? anyone used percy and can give a brief review of how they thought it was / what worked well? thank you.
Post reply on HN