Live data from Hacker News

Show HN: Klaus – OpenClaw on a VM, batteries included

klausai.com

51–60 of 104 posts

Re: Show HN: Klaus – OpenClaw on a VM, batteries included

#51
post #37

I don't get it. The point of OpenClaw is it's supposed to be an assistant, helping you with whatever random tasks you happen to have, in natural language. But for that to work, it has to have access to your personal data, your calendar, your emails, your credit card, etc., no? Are there other tasks that people commonly want to run, that don't require this, that I'm not aware of? If so I'd love to hear about them. The…

I don't follow your argument about getting pwned.

A user could leave malicious instructions in their instance, but Clawbert only has access to that user's info in the database, so you only pwned yourself.

A user could leave malicious instructions in someone else's instance and then rely on Clawbert to execute them. But Clawbert seems like a worse attack vector than just getting OpenClaw itself to execute the malicious instructions. OpenClaw already has root access.

Re other use cases that don't rely on personal data: we have users doing research and sending reports from an AgentMail account to the personal account, maintaining sandboxing. Another user set up this diving conditions website, which requires no personal data: https://www.diveprosd.com/

Re: Show HN: Klaus – OpenClaw on a VM, batteries included

#52
post #7

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The cost of ownership for an OpenClaw, and how many credits you'll use, is really hard to estimate since it depends so wildly on what you do. I can give you an openclaw instruction that will burn over $20k worth of credits in a matter of hours. You could also not talk to your claw at all for the entire month, setup no crons / reoccurring activities / webhooks / etc, and get a bill of under $1 for token usage. My usag…

Would having a locally-hosted model offset any of these costs?

Our starter plan gives you a machine with 2GB of RAM. You will not be able to run a local LLM. OpenRouter has free models (eg Z.ai: GLM 4.5 Air), I recommend those.

Re: Show HN: Klaus – OpenClaw on a VM, batteries included

#53
post #46

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Our average user spends $50 a month all-in (tokens and subscription). If you're budget conscious you can use a cheap model (eg Gemini Flash) or even a free one. I confess I am a snob and only use Claude Opus, but even using OpenClaw all day every day I only spend about $500 a month on tokens. Orthogonal credits are used more frequently by power users. For everyday tasks they'll last a very long time, I don't think an…

Your average user spends £50 a month? How long have you been running, just wondering since OpenClaw was only released (as openclaw) a month ago.

We have been live since Feb 7.

Maybe $50 a month is an underestimate because our average user has been live for less than a month.

Re: Show HN: Klaus – OpenClaw on a VM, batteries included

#55
I tried this service a few weeks ago, and I commend the goal - but there were a few issues I ran into:

1. There are many interactions I just could not get to work. I may have done something wrong, but in general, I have the perspective that most products should "just work" if it's as simple as clicking a button or directing something. In this case, I'm tangibly talking about the Browser feature, and the Canvas feature. In my account, I tried many times to have OpenClaw use the Browser to access a website and send me a screenshot, and it regularly reported the Browser was inaccessible, even though I had enabled it via Klaus UI. Secondly, I asked it to write certain reports to the Canvas as HTML pages that I could review - the entries would show up as files I could click on, but the files themselves were always empty. 2. OpenClaw with tokens is insanely expensive - I blew through the $15 tokens in a matter of a day.

For the first, my guess is I misconfigured something, but it's really difficult to identify what is wrong. My expectation was that I could prompt via Telegram to configure anything and everything, but some link was missing. Although I am a technical person, my expectation was that I would not need to muck around via `ssh` to figure out where my files ended up.

For the latter - and more broadly - OpenClaw is not well understood for most, and I think they will be caught off guard just how expensive it is. $15 in tokens is not a lot with how inefficient OpenClaw can be. My suggestion would be:

1. Pre-configure OpenClaw with already extremely memory-efficient rules and skills. 2. Provide clear guidance/documentation on ideal agent setup with different models as necessary. I think OpenRouter attempts to achieve this pretty well, but you are providing a layer on top of OpenRouter that may not be obvious to less-well-versed people. 3. Batteries-included options should "just work" - I felt I wasted a lot of tokens just figuring out how to get the thing to do simple tasks for me.

---

A lot of the notes I made are less about your product and what you've achieved, and more to do with OpenClaw. However, you've achieved one major milestone - which is the one-click setup of OpenClaw. But if your target demographic is the less technically inclined folks that want to be able to play with the bleeding edge of AI practices, I think your platform needs to guide users to how to actually use this thing, and become useful right away.

It may even be beneficial to showcase extremely clear workflows for users to get started and sell why they even want OpenClaw.

---

Anyway, kudos on the release! It is not easy to ship and you've done that hard bit! I bid you good luck on the next phase!

Re: Show HN: Klaus – OpenClaw on a VM, batteries included

#56
post #22

What's the best "docker with openclaw" currently available? I have my own computers to run it on (I don't need a server). I want to play around, but containerized to avoid the security risk of MacOS app. There seem to be about 20 options, and new ones every day. Any consensus on the best few are, and their tradeoffs?

I am still searching for a compose up -d to this day, but without success. And the other poster want me to create a k8s cluster for a bot?!?!

Try mine:

https://github.com/skorokithakis/stavrobot

It does indeed only need compose up -d.

Re: Show HN: Klaus – OpenClaw on a VM, batteries included

#57
> Connecting your email is still a risk.

> If you’ve built something agents want, please let us know. Comments welcome!

I'll bite! I've built a self-hosted open source tool that's intended to solve this problem specifically. It allows you to approve an agent purpose rather than specific scopes. An LLM then makes sure that all requests fit that purpose, and only inject the credentials if they're in line with the approved purpose. I (and my early users) have found substantially reduces the likelihood of agent drift or injection attacks.

https://github.com/clawvisor/clawvisor

Re: Show HN: Klaus – OpenClaw on a VM, batteries included

#59
post #37

I don't get it. The point of OpenClaw is it's supposed to be an assistant, helping you with whatever random tasks you happen to have, in natural language. But for that to work, it has to have access to your personal data, your calendar, your emails, your credit card, etc., no? Are there other tasks that people commonly want to run, that don't require this, that I'm not aware of? If so I'd love to hear about them. The…

I don't follow your argument about getting pwned. A user could leave malicious instructions in their instance, but Clawbert only has access to that user's info in the database, so you only pwned yourself. A user could leave malicious instructions in someone else's instance and then rely on Clawbert to execute them. But Clawbert seems like a worse attack vector than just getting OpenClaw itself to execute the maliciou…

> But Clawbert seems like a worse attack vector than just getting OpenClaw itself to execute the malicious instructions. OpenClaw already has root access.

Well the assumption was that you could secure OpenClaw or at least limit the damage it can do. I was also thinking more about the general usecase of a AI SRE, so not necessarily tied to OpenClaw, but for general self hosting. But yeah probably doesn't make much of a different in your case then.

Re: Show HN: Klaus – OpenClaw on a VM, batteries included

#60
post #55

I tried this service a few weeks ago, and I commend the goal - but there were a few issues I ran into: 1. There are many interactions I just could not get to work. I may have done something wrong, but in general, I have the perspective that most products should "just work" if it's as simple as clicking a button or directing something. In this case, I'm tangibly talking about the Browser feature, and the Canvas featur…

Thanks for the feedback here, this matches a bunch of patterns we have seen.

One of the fundamental problems is OpenClaw is tech for nerds. It's hard to use, it breaks all the time, it's built on LLMs, etc. We'd like to be the one to bridge the gap but that will take a ton of work. It's something we spend all day thinking about. Some issues like the one you hit with canvas are likely some mix of our problem and the model doing something unexpected like putting the file in the wrong directory which is constantly a problem.

Also agree on the cost being a huge issue. We give $15 up front and it just disappears so quickly for many users. Some users switch to smaller models but often this just ends up with people being more unhappy because the performance is bad. Opus is the least likely to make mistakes but also the most expensive.

Thanks for the advice, it's great to hear you believe in it too! At a personal level, it means a ton to me. Just got to keep writing code.

Post reply on HN