Live data from Hacker News

Show HN: A geofence-based social network app 6 years in development

localvideoapp.com

51–60 of 65 posts

Re: Show HN: A geofence-based social network app 6 years in development

#51
post #45
post #40

Very cool idea. My only worry is "Anonymous Mode". Anonymity IME usually results in conversations descending into vitriol, snark or libel.

Places where you have to use your real name, like Facebook, are typically more toxic

hmm. Facebook is a GD cesspool but 4chan?? Anonymity drives that toxicity!

Re: Show HN: A geofence-based social network app 6 years in development

#52
One pattern I’ve noticed with local / geofenced chat is that without a primary task (coordination, trade, alerts, etc.), chat becomes the product... and historically that converges to low-signal or toxicity. The tech here is impressive, but I’d worry the value needs to be anchored to a concrete job-to-be-done rather than chat itself.

Re: Show HN: A geofence-based social network app 6 years in development

#53
post #35

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I am saying for it to succeed as multi-user, it needs to be useful first for a single user.

Twitter was never useful for single users.

It was. Twitter used to send SMS and therefore notify others on what you're doing even without them having anything installed.

Re: Show HN: A geofence-based social network app 6 years in development

#54
post #35

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I am saying for it to succeed as multi-user, it needs to be useful first for a single user.

Twitter was never useful for single users.

Twitter started as an internal service for existing Odeo employees, so an unfair comparison if you're talking about cold, starting a social network. Twitter didn't start cold.

Re: Show HN: A geofence-based social network app 6 years in development

#55

There's so many ways to fake your location data. There's one way that you can't really fake: Send them a secret code on a piece of paper in the US mail to their physical address. NextDoor used to do this at one point.

That seems a little excessive for an app like this. The only way I know of that users can fake their location is with a rooted device. I check for rooted devices in the app though so locations can't be spoofed.

>> I check for rooted devices in the app

Is that possible on iPhone, or only on Android?

Re: Show HN: A geofence-based social network app 6 years in development

#57

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'm not sure if the concept is really for a single user. It's more like you get to connect with people within geographically-defined perimeters.

One obvious feature would be to provide geo fenced Wikipedia or news feed. Like what is the highest rated/longest Wikipedia article in the area. Or maybe what's the 3 top radio stations and a link to them. There is plenty of local content that Google does not surface

I could do that. Have additional information about the area based on the perimeter.

Re: Show HN: A geofence-based social network app 6 years in development

#58
post #49

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What else would you suggest for an app with this concept?

Maybe just trust the users, and rely on human moderation to deal with abuse. It's basically how any community works.

I thought this comment thread was about location spoofing, but if we're talking about abuse on the platform, I do have a "report" button for each chat message. After 2 - 3 reports, the message gets deleted.

Re: Show HN: A geofence-based social network app 6 years in development

#59

There's so many ways to fake your location data. There's one way that you can't really fake: Send them a secret code on a piece of paper in the US mail to their physical address. NextDoor used to do this at one point.

It's hard to fake a reputation score. If someone is providing services in an area, they aren't going to start faking a location, and if they do they won't gain any reputation. But location is already baked into many social media apps anyway, though. https://gemini.google.com/share/68d4fd324d94 ...that'd be the real issue here, perhaps. Locally produced food is the important one, going forward. It can be much cheaper…

This is a completely different idea though.

Re: Show HN: A geofence-based social network app 6 years in development

#60
post #38

Very cool. I developed something in a similar vein as a way to teach myself web programming 15 years ago or so. Https://dirtywalls.com is location-based message boards. You can create or join ones close to your location. Reminds me that I need to try to tell people about it since it’s mostly just me checking in to my local bars and shops.

Nice. It's definitely a similar concept, just no geofences.
Post reply on HN