Live data from Hacker News

Show HN: Oh Yah – Routine management app I built for my sons

ohyahapp.com

51–60 of 88 posts

Re: Show HN: Oh Yah – Routine management app I built for my sons

#51
I think this concept could be adapted to a wider audience. Personally I struggle with routine. Body Doubling (doing something with another human holding you accountable) helps me a ton.

I would definitely use this if instead of the parents as the reviewer it was possible to have a friend/multiple friends approve, rate and comment on tasks and vice versa. Like a sort of social media for mundane routines.

Re: Show HN: Oh Yah – Routine management app I built for my sons

#52
post #51

I think this concept could be adapted to a wider audience. Personally I struggle with routine. Body Doubling (doing something with another human holding you accountable) helps me a ton. I would definitely use this if instead of the parents as the reviewer it was possible to have a friend/multiple friends approve, rate and comment on tasks and vice versa. Like a sort of social media for mundane routines.

Yeah, I think this would work well generally, not just for kids. And ADHD folks in particular.

Re: Show HN: Oh Yah – Routine management app I built for my sons

#53

Earlier quoted context omitted.

For Android w/Playstore you can set up a child's account through Google and then use Google Family Link app to control app downloads, block specific apps, and set content restrictions for apps, movies, and games. You can set down times for the whole phone and lock it remotely which is of huge benefit for bedtimes!

That's parental control, that's not the same. I want to hand my phone to my kids and let them access only one or two apps that I have listed as allowed. I don't want (yet, but it will come) for them to have their own device that I control as you explained.

That's app pinning.

https://support.google.com/android/answer/9455138?hl=en

Re: Show HN: Oh Yah – Routine management app I built for my sons

#54

The app itself is a great idea, but looking through the demo video I see lots of bad "tiger parent" memes. I don't think that I would want to force a child to do these sorts of tasks in a regimen, or be forced as a child to perform them. The demo video (which does showcase the app well), includes things like chess and piano and homework. Does the child like doing any of these? Have you vetted the homework as worth th…

Fair points, and I appreciate the candid feedback. The demo tasks were chosen to showcase different task types (timed, photo-proof, etc) rather than being prescriptive about what kids should do. But I can see how it reads as "tiger parent starter pack" For context: my older son genuinely enjoys chess and piano, and this structured schedule approach was recommended by their child psychologist. We tried paper-based sch…

I would study what you're apparently intent on ignoring: that kids and screens do not mix well and reduces their ability to engage with the more complex aspects of reality. Do you want automatons or fundamentally happy beings?

“A growing body of evidence has found that children’s brains can structurally and functionally change due to prolonged media multitasking, such as diminished gray matter in the prefrontal cortex, where attentional control and complex decision making abilities reside, among other really important skills, like the development of empathy and understanding nonverbal social communication,”

There are over 300 studies detailing how early screen use damages children's brains and impairs their ability to reason and relate to others. How engineers ignore this is incredible.

https://www.childrenandscreens.org/learn-explore/research/?t...

Re: Show HN: Oh Yah – Routine management app I built for my sons

#55
post #53

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That's parental control, that's not the same. I want to hand my phone to my kids and let them access only one or two apps that I have listed as allowed. I don't want (yet, but it will come) for them to have their own device that I control as you explained.

That's app pinning. https://support.google.com/android/answer/9455138?hl=en

It only let's you pin single app though, as far as I understand.

Re: Show HN: Oh Yah – Routine management app I built for my sons

#56

Earlier quoted context omitted.

For Android w/Playstore you can set up a child's account through Google and then use Google Family Link app to control app downloads, block specific apps, and set content restrictions for apps, movies, and games. You can set down times for the whole phone and lock it remotely which is of huge benefit for bedtimes!

That's parental control, that's not the same. I want to hand my phone to my kids and let them access only one or two apps that I have listed as allowed. I don't want (yet, but it will come) for them to have their own device that I control as you explained.

Depends on your device then. Some Android Devices allow multiple-user accounts, one of which can be a specially locked-down child account. I think Samsung Galaxy have a proprietary flavour as well.

https://support.google.com/kidsspace/answer/10065701?hl=en

Re: Show HN: Oh Yah – Routine management app I built for my sons

#57
post #51

I think this concept could be adapted to a wider audience. Personally I struggle with routine. Body Doubling (doing something with another human holding you accountable) helps me a ton. I would definitely use this if instead of the parents as the reviewer it was possible to have a friend/multiple friends approve, rate and comment on tasks and vice versa. Like a sort of social media for mundane routines.

Maybe Beeminder.com or one of the peer pressure equivalents?

Re: Show HN: Oh Yah – Routine management app I built for my sons

#58
post #3

Slightly off-topic, but as this will require kids to have access to an unlocked phone... I remember Windows Phone had the feature of "unlocked apps", which you could run without having to unlock the phone: think calculator, browser, games. It was called Kids Corner[1]. Have any other OS (iOS/Androind) copied anything similar to that? This app will (or at least in my case) live in a place like that, where they do not…

iOS lets you do something very similar with Guided Access: https://support.apple.com/en-us/111795

Re: Show HN: Oh Yah – Routine management app I built for my sons

#59

Earlier quoted context omitted.

For Android w/Playstore you can set up a child's account through Google and then use Google Family Link app to control app downloads, block specific apps, and set content restrictions for apps, movies, and games. You can set down times for the whole phone and lock it remotely which is of huge benefit for bedtimes!

That's parental control, that's not the same. I want to hand my phone to my kids and let them access only one or two apps that I have listed as allowed. I don't want (yet, but it will come) for them to have their own device that I control as you explained.

Android should have a Kiosk mode that's available sometimes that locks it to one app full screen.

Android may have alternate launchers you can install (they are just apps) which you can customize how you need. One of the best features of Android imho.

I tried helping a friend with their kids Amazon tablet and left the experience wanting to wipe it clean and just define what 4 buttons parents can put on the screen.

Other tech:

Apple has a guided access feature which locks it to one app (except it's handed to them).

We're holding off on personal screens for now until the information diet can be tamed and managed. Looking for a smartwatch with a phone with physical buttons and no screen. Seem to be some options.

Re: Show HN: Oh Yah – Routine management app I built for my sons

#60
I'd rather not include additional screen time for my kids. We have a printed sheet of paper on the fridge. If they don't do what they need to then they have a consequence (no TV, no screen, no desert, no playing w friends).

Not everything needs to be fun and games in life.

Post reply on HN