Live data from Hacker News

Show HN: Pigsty – Free RDS Alternative

github.com

51–53 of 53 posts

Re: Show HN: Pigsty – Free RDS Alternative

#51

> Free RDS Alternative RDS is a managed service. This is a code repo. It is useless until you deploy it at which point... it's no longer free. Then you have to manage it yourself and deal with the overhead yourself. This is like saying I can fire my gardener because you have a free gardener alternative, and then handing me a pair of scissors. I now have all the problems that I paid the Gardener to solve. Likewise, we…

The scale of operation is the crux here. For a modest number of cores, RDS is a congenial choice. However, when you're going to hundreds or, as in our scenario, tens of thousands of cores with PostgreSQL, clinging to RDS is sheer lunacy.

I was the designated gardener to tackle this: architecting and managing a PostgreSQL deployment with 25K cores and 3M TPS. We've been shelling out a cool $1M annually, covering the whole thing - hardware, software, and DBAs. Meanwhile, the toll for RDS is an astronomical tenfold of our current expenditure, yet it comes with a lesser degree of availability and a starkly crippled observability and other stuff.

Re: Show HN: Pigsty – Free RDS Alternative

#53

Interesting, but unless you understand every piece of software running and how they interact and are deployed, running this sounds like a devops and security nightmare.

That’s my thing. I closed the docs as soon as I opened them because I already couldn’t imagine convincing anyone this was a good idea enough to convince me it was a good idea. If that made any sense

You need a lot of clout to get something like this out. Kubernetes is an example of something in this category, for example. That baby needed to come out of Google to be both fully formed and in the "didn't get fired for choosing" bucket :-).

Speaking of which, why isn't this project delivered as a Helm chart?

Post reply on HN