Live data from Hacker News

Show HN: ChatGDB – GPT-Powered GDB Assistant

github.com

51–57 of 57 posts

Re: Show HN: ChatGDB – GPT-Powered GDB Assistant

#51
post #46
post #45

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's called "conversational programming" and it was all the rage in the '60s or '70s. Maybe it's time for a resurgence?

SQL grew out of that trend btw :)

Oh my god, if SQL is the “conversational” option what other design did they consider? Binary?

Re: Show HN: ChatGDB – GPT-Powered GDB Assistant

#52
post #51
post #46

Earlier quoted context omitted.

SQL grew out of that trend btw :)

Oh my god, if SQL is the “conversational” option what other design did they consider? Binary?

It's been 50+ years and still nobody has invented anything better that people actually use.

Re: Show HN: ChatGDB – GPT-Powered GDB Assistant

#53
post #51

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Oh my god, if SQL is the “conversational” option what other design did they consider? Binary?

It's been 50+ years and still nobody has invented anything better that people actually use.

I mean, I’m using ChatGPT to render natural language down to executable SQL for a project right now.

It’s not a universal solution, as it’s specific to my data architecture, but if I were to devote a month to it I’m fairly sure I’d make a big dent in a generalized solution. And I’m VERY sure somebody else already 90% done we’ll see it on GitHub soon!

Re: Show HN: ChatGDB – GPT-Powered GDB Assistant

#54
post #53

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's been 50+ years and still nobody has invented anything better that people actually use.

I mean, I’m using ChatGPT to render natural language down to executable SQL for a project right now. It’s not a universal solution, as it’s specific to my data architecture, but if I were to devote a month to it I’m fairly sure I’d make a big dent in a generalized solution. And I’m VERY sure somebody else already 90% done we’ll see it on GitHub soon!

True, and I'm a fan of that as well. But I'm not sure it counts as dethroning SQL :) Unless you're also counting it as dethroning every other programming language it knows how to code in... although...

Re: Show HN: ChatGDB – GPT-Powered GDB Assistant

#56
post #31

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I’m sorry, but these arguments are terrible. I see them boiling down to this: “Use GPT to do this thing!” “But GPT is notorious for confidently getting things wrong” “That’s ok! Because you’ll know it’s wrong!” Maybe I’m a little sore right now because I literally just finished trying to have GPT write code for me and it gave me code with all kinds of syntax errors and mistakes. Yes, I know not to trust it because th…

It gets it wrong maybe as often as I do on my first shot, but it does it much faster -- MUCH MUCH faster if any of the tech involved is something I'm not familiar with. And no matter who writes the code, me or the machine, I still quickly read it right after it's written. Look, I've been doing this for 25 years, both as a career and continuously on the side for fun, and I am definitely an expert in a lot of things at…

Exactly. I used to dread the 20+ times a day I would have to go to Stack Overflow and wade through a mountain of horse shit in the hopes of finding an answer. Now I can clearly describe the problem as a programmer would and ChatGPT frequently gets the solution on the first or second try.

I had one bad experience last week where I burned 20 minutes as ChatGPT gave me one invalid approach after another. Then I consulted the docs and learned that waht I wanted to do explicitly couldn't be done with that library. Tens steps forward and one step back. Totally worth it.

Post reply on HN