Live data from Hacker News

Show HN: Sail a historical full-rigged ship in real global weather

thapen.itch.io

51–60 of 72 posts

Re: Show HN: Sail a historical full-rigged ship in real global weather

#51
post #9

This is really cool! I'm a few books into the Aubry/Maturin novels by Patrick O'Brien (highly recommended! The movie Master & Commander is based on them). This should help to get a better feel for the ships and the battles!

I'm wondering if the game requires you to know all the sail names. That could be a big impediment to doing things in it! It certainly adds some difficulty in even reading those books.

It does! But having the simulation right there helps you learn them.

I had two main questions to answer when making this. First, how does ship physics work anyway; second, what is an appropriate UI that feels like being an officer ordering a couple of hundred people around? I previously worked on a flight sim, where it's appropriate to move a joystick, or a mouse, and have the plane respond straight away. I think that would feel wrong here - it would make the ship feel like a toy.

A benefit of the technical language is that it helps convey the idea that the ship is a big, complicated machine, with all the parts worked by people. It's also fun to see the strange words. So I decided to lean in to technical language and verbal commands. I was starting to work with git, and thought about using a command-line UI for the game; but I went with something inspired by the menus and hotkeys of old roguelikes.

Re: Show HN: Sail a historical full-rigged ship in real global weather

#52
post #9

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'm wondering if the game requires you to know all the sail names. That could be a big impediment to doing things in it! It certainly adds some difficulty in even reading those books.

I'm reading the Aubrey-Maturin books and found this sail diagram quite helpful: https://www.reddit.com/r/AubreyMaturinSeries/comments/j3vn05...

For reading this 21 book series it's worth investing into one more book with background information.

I can recommend

Patrick O'Brian's Navy: The Illustrated Companion to Jack Aubrey's World (Hardcover)

Lots of valuable information, lots of illustrations and schematics and photos.

https://www.goodreads.com/en/book/show/24519

Re: Show HN: Sail a historical full-rigged ship in real global weather

#53
post #3

I've always been interested in sailing. I'm from Illinois. I once went to Jamaica and sailed a small catamaran for several hours on a protected bay and had great fun. For years afterwards I was reading sailing textbooks and dreaming about it, but given my location, I don't want to put money into it I've played some sailing games and had fun, but they weren't simulations. I've never tried a sailing simulator. This one…

> but given my location, I don't want to put money into it

You made me a bit curious, why not? Illinois seems to have sailing opportunities in many places, and with a good drysuit or wetsuit even dinghy sailing in colder climates is fine. And if you still do not fancy swimming, there are small keelboats you can handle on your own relatively easily. (Take your time to learn in easy winds and preferably a teacher of some sort, though)

Re: Show HN: Sail a historical full-rigged ship in real global weather

#54
post #3

I've always been interested in sailing. I'm from Illinois. I once went to Jamaica and sailed a small catamaran for several hours on a protected bay and had great fun. For years afterwards I was reading sailing textbooks and dreaming about it, but given my location, I don't want to put money into it I've played some sailing games and had fun, but they weren't simulations. I've never tried a sailing simulator. This one…

> I notice you say that it's Windows-only, I take that as a challenge

It runs under WINE with no issues

Re: Show HN: Sail a historical full-rigged ship in real global weather

#55
post #3

I've always been interested in sailing. I'm from Illinois. I once went to Jamaica and sailed a small catamaran for several hours on a protected bay and had great fun. For years afterwards I was reading sailing textbooks and dreaming about it, but given my location, I don't want to put money into it I've played some sailing games and had fun, but they weren't simulations. I've never tried a sailing simulator. This one…

The wind off Chicago is some of the best in the US for sailing. its cold, but its great. In fact, we have produced some of the most competitive small boat sailors in the world, and have even hosted big boat stuff like the americas cup.

I used to be a race coach for small boat sailing - happy to give lessons

If you want to go sailing this summer, Id be more than happy to show you how!

Re: Show HN: Sail a historical full-rigged ship in real global weather

#56

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'm reading the Aubrey-Maturin books and found this sail diagram quite helpful: https://www.reddit.com/r/AubreyMaturinSeries/comments/j3vn05...

I’m on book three and this is incredibly useful. The level of detail in the books is insane. I also reallllly liked the Russell Crowe movie, and wish they had made more. It wasn’t perfect, but it was fun as hell, and the napoleonic wars provide so much material for sequels.

they are making another one!

Re: Show HN: Sail a historical full-rigged ship in real global weather

#58
For anyone interested in a sailing adventure on a real tall ship in real "real global weather", I can heartily recommend booking a journey on the Oosterschelde (https://www.dutchtallship.com/oosterschelde/). I did a 5 day trip last summer and it was a unique, fun, physical, and educational experience.

Re: Show HN: Sail a historical full-rigged ship in real global weather

#59
post #3

I've always been interested in sailing. I'm from Illinois. I once went to Jamaica and sailed a small catamaran for several hours on a protected bay and had great fun. For years afterwards I was reading sailing textbooks and dreaming about it, but given my location, I don't want to put money into it I've played some sailing games and had fun, but they weren't simulations. I've never tried a sailing simulator. This one…

You might be interested in sailing on such a ship irl then: https://www.gotheborg.se/

So tempting! Advise anyone considering this not to skip the “who should apply” info. Not the love boat!
Post reply on HN