Live data from Hacker News

Show HN: Linenoise NG – GNU Readline Replacement, with UTF8 and Windows (BSD)

github.com

51–53 of 53 posts

Re: Show HN: Linenoise NG – GNU Readline Replacement, with UTF8 and Windows (BSD)

#51
post #20

All of this to get around the GPL. Boo!

This project goal is a bit more about replacing readline, but a big motivation for the original project is minimalism and trivial embeddability. It's all in the README.

@antirez: should the linked "linenoise NG" be considered a replacement for your linenoise?

I did diff on linenoise.c and linenoise.cpp (from NG) and very few lines are identical.

Re: Show HN: Linenoise NG – GNU Readline Replacement, with UTF8 and Windows (BSD)

#52

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> What freedom does a user of a software have if all the open source code is used by some proprietary software? Exactly the same freedom that the user has if that proprietary software did not use the GPL software. It's unchanged. These two worlds do not differ, either the proprietary product doesn't exist, or it reimplemented whatever code was GPLd. The GPL has had no positive impact, there is no more source code ava…

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zxIEDNyZOkA&feature=youtu.be... Martin Fink, EVP & CTO of HP on why we should use the GPL

I'm not seeing a "why" in here, just a "do this". There are no "why"s that are specific to any features of the GPL.

Re: Show HN: Linenoise NG – GNU Readline Replacement, with UTF8 and Windows (BSD)

#53

Earlier quoted context omitted.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zxIEDNyZOkA&feature=youtu.be... Martin Fink, EVP & CTO of HP on why we should use the GPL

I'm not seeing a "why" in here, just a "do this". There are no "why"s that are specific to any features of the GPL.

Well I am clearly seeing a "Use a copyleft license so a community can be created by making other users share their modifications".

That is a feature of the GPL!

Post reply on HN