Live data from Hacker News

Show HN: If YouTube had actual channels

ytch.xyz

481–490 of 544 posts

Re: Show HN: If YouTube had actual channels

#481
post #405

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I had youtube TV for a while and the most annoying thing is that there were no channel numbers.

That and the 50 other terrible design choices they made. What a hot mess youtube tv is.

The worst part is that it’s the best UI for its product segment by far, and I don’t think it’s even close.

The bar is incredibly low.

Re: Show HN: If YouTube had actual channels

#482

Funny, how we are slowly attracted towards the thing that we were planning to revolutionize away from. 1. Cable is expensive, pretty much majority of streamming services bumped up their $$$, if you add 3-4 of them, the cost will be the same as cable. 2. When i used this, cant lie. I missed the nostalgia.

[dead]

Re: Show HN: If YouTube had actual channels

#483

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That and the 50 other terrible design choices they made. What a hot mess youtube tv is.

Compared to what? It's easily the best Internet cable TV product on the market IMHO.

It’s an odd “in between” between classic TV and YouTube itself.

If you want to watch “the most likely thing you would want to watch” (NFL, Olympics main feed), YouTubeTV is great.

But as soon as you want to find something off the top few recommendations, it gets much harder. Compare that to regular TV, when I could just remember 27 is Discovery Channel and get there instantly.

Re: Show HN: If YouTube had actual channels

#484
post #376

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Can you give any insight into why these projects were canceled at Disney or Netflix?

I can't speak to Netflix. At Disney the willingness to experiment with streaming UX was thin on the ground six years ago. It was about making something that felt like a direct Netflix competitor. Other experiments have shipped since then, like co-viewing. I actually believe TikTok is more of the spiritual inheritor of this kind of project more than any other platform.

I guess what I am trying to ask is why was UX research "thin on the ground" (lovely expression, never heard it before). Was it a profit loss thing or more like the progress wasn't fast enough

Re: Show HN: If YouTube had actual channels

#485
post #318
post #302

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> since a lot of channels are annoying to me using headphones, they pan the audio sources too hard left/right and it's super distracting I find this interesting. Are you oversensitive? I've never even considered that this could be an issue. Do you experience the same problem with other things like music and games?

Not the parent, but with similar view on panned audio. If it's music where it's done on purpose, no problem. But talking with audio in one ear? I'm out. Not sure why exactly, but it's very jarring. For me, it's one of the worst audio quality issues a video can have.

There's a small YouTube creator who has uploaded videos with the narration hard panned. I told him about it in the comments, he went "hmm that's weird", then uploaded more videos with the same issue.

I don't watch that channel any more.

Re: Show HN: If YouTube had actual channels

#486
Am I the only child of the 80s that hates this? A bunch of stuff I'm not interested in, and then I switched off. The moment TiVo was available we had it in our house and it was great. I still like the occasional shared experience of big sporting events or Eurovision or something on broadcast TV, but outside that it's just the equivalent of doomscrolling. If you look at your plethora of streaming options today and can't find anything to watch, just do something else. The wonder of the modern age is the sheer volume of stuff you can ignore entirely and never care about.

Re: Show HN: If YouTube had actual channels

#487
post #405
post #72

I'd echo the sentiment that this is amazing, and that a TV guide would be awesome. I'd also suggest maybe adding the channel names (like the comment you posted here) to the app itself (although i think it's cool when it's unnamed and you get the old-school feeling of channels just being numbers). Also, I'd love to have permalinks for the channels. Not for the individual videos themselves, but just a link that when sh…

I had youtube TV for a while and the most annoying thing is that there were no channel numbers.

YouTube TV was equal parts awesome and horrifying for the Olympics. It had plenty of great content, including a solid amount of 4k

It also had the worst search UX I have ever experienced.

Most importantly, recording an event did not guarantee you got the whole thing! There were numerous events I was watching from my ‘library’ that did not include the final 10-30 min of action. WTH? Did you really record based on time stamps alone? What year is this?!

Re: Show HN: If YouTube had actual channels

#488

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The author was replying to everyone, even me, but didn’t respond to my question about how the list is made. This makes me assume that it’s hand-made. If so, it’ll probably get 1 or 2 updates (if even that many) and then remain static as the creator loses interest. Wouldn’t be the first time. EDIT: list has changed. Trying to track it, we'll see what happens. I really hope the author has some way to search Youtube for…

Again, if I am allowed to dream, we can have a community around the exchange of these list files.

That would be an amazing addition!

Well, this website is completely cloneable, the JS is non-minified, so adding in community lists is certainly possible. Maybe just a tool to create those lists collaboratively. Good idea!

Re: Show HN: If YouTube had actual channels

#489
post #259

Also works on localhost, run these commands: `wget -r -np -k https://ytch.xyz ` - downloads the website recursively `wget https://ytch.xyz/list.json ` - download the list of what every channel plays and will play (I'm not sure if this ever really changes. The real website adds ?t= ) Then for instance run `python3 -m http.server` and visit localhost:8000 :)

JSON looks like tinydb

Or a PHP application returning an array as a JSON object
Post reply on HN