Live data from Hacker News

Show HN: textlog – A quiet, text-only microblogging platform, open-source, no JS

textlog.cc

41–50 of 81 posts

Re: Show HN: textlog – A quiet, text-only microblogging platform, open-source, no JS

#42
post #4

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Hi, I'm sorry you don't like the limitation :( this is for short thoughts you want to share, not really huge conversations, there are better places for that IMO.

well, you may consider rewarding known quality users with an extended limit, say double. the others can pay ;)

haha, yeah good idea. Also customize the theme as others wanted. So many opportunities here. :P

Re: Show HN: textlog – A quiet, text-only microblogging platform, open-source, no JS

#43

The 280 char limit seems arbitrary, given you cant even keep the about page within that limit: https://textlog.cc/about If you are going to limit it to short posts, maybe the length of a short post is the length to limit it to, rather than emulating the 2xSMS of every twitter clone? Other than that, it looks really clean and neat - I just dont think being 280 chars adds anything other than resulting in people posting…

I like the idea of a shorter character limit as it nudges users to a specific mode of interaction: short thoughts/updates and not long-winded soliloquies. It's signalling that interaction with this platform doesn't demand much of your time or attention. I don't know what the about page has to do with it, but you have to draw the line somewhere. That said, I'm not a social media user besides HN I guess.

For perspective: you just commented 404 chars. Your first paragraph alone was 346.

My comment on the about page was that it needed more than 280 chars to communicate what the app is about - even the title + intro exceeds the limit.

If it is truly believed that 280 chars is enough to communicate an idea, then the about page should follow that philosophy.

Re: Show HN: textlog – A quiet, text-only microblogging platform, open-source, no JS

#44

The 280 char limit seems arbitrary, given you cant even keep the about page within that limit: https://textlog.cc/about If you are going to limit it to short posts, maybe the length of a short post is the length to limit it to, rather than emulating the 2xSMS of every twitter clone? Other than that, it looks really clean and neat - I just dont think being 280 chars adds anything other than resulting in people posting…

You could fork and do whatever no?

Sure, but I don't care that much. It is a Show HN, so I was giving feedback.

Re: Show HN: textlog – A quiet, text-only microblogging platform, open-source, no JS

#45

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I like the idea of a shorter character limit as it nudges users to a specific mode of interaction: short thoughts/updates and not long-winded soliloquies. It's signalling that interaction with this platform doesn't demand much of your time or attention. I don't know what the about page has to do with it, but you have to draw the line somewhere. That said, I'm not a social media user besides HN I guess.

For perspective: you just commented 404 chars. Your first paragraph alone was 346. My comment on the about page was that it needed more than 280 chars to communicate what the app is about - even the title + intro exceeds the limit. If it is truly believed that 280 chars is enough to communicate an idea, then the about page should follow that philosophy.

I'm considering raising to 500. Care enough to open an issue[0] so that maybe there is a discussion we can track?

[0]: https://github.com/stagas/textlog/issues

Re: Show HN: textlog – A quiet, text-only microblogging platform, open-source, no JS

#46
post #4

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Hi, I'm sorry you don't like the limitation :( this is for short thoughts you want to share, not really huge conversations, there are better places for that IMO.

well, you may consider rewarding known quality users with an extended limit, say double. the others can pay ;)

That's how enshittification begins. Next thing you know and there are blue badges next to profiles.

Re: Show HN: textlog – A quiet, text-only microblogging platform, open-source, no JS

#47

Earlier quoted context omitted.

well, you may consider rewarding known quality users with an extended limit, say double. the others can pay ;)

That's how enshittification begins. Next thing you know and there are blue badges next to profiles.

lol Yes enshittification is the thing I want to avoid, so hard decisions need to be made that will not make everybody happy. Still, this is open-source[0], so we can open a discussion (ideally alongside a PR) and evolve it.

[0]: https://github.com/stagas/textlog

Re: Show HN: textlog – A quiet, text-only microblogging platform, open-source, no JS

#48
post #3

Reminds me of org-social ( https://github.com/tanrax/org-social ) > Notes are limited to 280 characters. The constraint keeps them quick to write and read, making room for one thought at a time. No thanks.

[flagged]

Re: Show HN: textlog – A quiet, text-only microblogging platform, open-source, no JS

#49

I built something for a similar goal, make it easy for someone to start their blog. But instead it's a static website, clone the repo, adjust the config.ts, write the posts in markdown, host anywhere: https://starter.bryanhogan.com/

Please don't use !important at scale https://github.com/BryanHogan/astro-starter-template/commit/...
Post reply on HN