Live data from Hacker News

Show HN: Pvsh - A reverse Kickstarter (make feature requests for any product)

pvshapp.com

41–49 of 49 posts

Re: Show HN: Pvsh - A reverse Kickstarter (make feature requests for any product)

#41

This could be really powerful if users could put up actual $$$ for feature requests so the site actually performs more like kickstarter. This would also help the quality of requests. Once the company completes the feature satisfactorily they get the cash. Or perhaps even a situation where they can grab the cash to start the feature- but this is obviously higher risk- like kickstarter- but the risk could be managed an…

> if users could put up actual $$$ for feature requests so the site actually performs more like kickstarter. This would also help the quality of requests.

Agreed, but I'd expect few people would put in money up front to fund something that no one's promising to make. It's hard to give it a hard date like Kickstarter since it's not the people doing who create the posts.

The best way I can think of going about it is having people say how much they're willing to pay (but no money changes hands), allowing someone to say they're going to implement and idea, and then it turns into a kickstarter project and emails all of the people who said they'd pay so they can enter their credit card details.

That way there's no risk for the backers (until they know someone wants to fulfill their dreams) or creator's (functions just like kickstarter for them -- except someone is giving them an initial list of interested parties). The websites whole purpose becomes facilitating new ideas.

To cut down on spam, you could charge people a dollar per vote (or microtransactions) and then promise creators a cut of that if they successfully "kickstart" a project (or convert a sufficient number of voting backers).

* To be clear: I'm not talking about using kickstarter -- then you'd lose all your revenue.

Edit: I expected pvsh to be about "I want this thing" instead of feature requests for specific products. It seems weird to me for Corporations to request bounties on features, but I still like the idea as a way to connect user's wants with entrepreneurs.

Re: Show HN: Pvsh - A reverse Kickstarter (make feature requests for any product)

#43
post #19

For everyone criticizing the app name, you are aware that domain names are a finite resource that cost very little to sit on forever, right? Often naming your company comes down to what memorable domain name you can snag, even if you have to commit a spelling/grammar crime to get it.

Indeed, tumblr is a good example

The e doesn’t really contribute in most accents, anyway.

Re: Show HN: Pvsh - A reverse Kickstarter (make feature requests for any product)

#44
This seems to have a huge chicken-or-the-egg problem: the site is only valuable to consumers if they know their requests could have some influence, but companies will only listen to requests from Pvsh users if there's a critical mass (say, thousands or millions of votes for one feature).

Is there some way to re-jig the concept to get around this? Perhaps by focusing more directly on one particular product category and expanding outwards? Or by working with particular companies that are actively soliciting feature requests (in which case I'd know I'd be listened to)?

Re: Show HN: Pvsh - A reverse Kickstarter (make feature requests for any product)

#45

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Finding a startup name is hard... I went through a list of hundreds of names for my project, and all the ones I liked were already taken (the .com domain name at least). I'm not sold yet on using something other than .com for a consumer-facing startup, unless it's not web-focused (maybe mobile apps can get away with non .com tlds).

Why is the domain name so important? Dropbox didn't have dropbox.com until they could afford to buy it.

I'm making a service targeted to seniors. My very limited testing shows that they always assume it's a .com .

Re: Show HN: Pvsh - A reverse Kickstarter (make feature requests for any product)

#48

ahhh ffs, I drafted out my own vision of this concept just yesterday. Nice work none the less :)

That's cool, post it! I'd love to hear your angle on it

oh, really? Okay...

There are many projects that the wider web community want to fund but are not able to.

Example: There's a demand for the adobe creative suites on Linux, but this wont be happening any time soon.

Adobe wont create a kickstarter campaign as they just wont.

Instead, people should be able to make their deposits to a third party that will release the payments when conditions are met.

Example: groups of people submit their demands and each person submits their micro payment. The conditions on the payment being released to the company of concern must be measurable... otherwise the intended reciepient will recieve their cash payments prematurely.

This would mean that you're acting as an Escrow... something I've only just learnt about.

Re: Show HN: Pvsh - A reverse Kickstarter (make feature requests for any product)

#49

I like how startups ran out of regular words, so now they use V instead of U and we have a whole new set of words to go through.

I'd like to claim the invention of the use of V in the software domain. I have a pet project called Bvckup that dates back to 2009 and I am pretty sure I was the first one to mangle a software product name that way. Otherwise the medal goes to the Italians for Bvlgari. It was a half-joke, but the name stuck and now I wish I picked something else. The problem, obviously, that it's unpronounceable. As "online" as the l…

Actually Bvlgari is the brand/logo (or better the way they design it using the V latin letter for U) but the name of the firm (and the family behind) is Bulgari: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bulgari
Post reply on HN