Live data from Hacker News

Show HN: Use Their ID – Use your local UK MP’s ID for the Online Safety Act

use-their-id.com

41–50 of 297 posts

Re: Show HN: Use Their ID – Use your local UK MP’s ID for the Online Safety Act

#41
post #38
post #14

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Seems like open AI is rate limiting me for a minute, I didn't expect to get top of HN this quickly. Use Starmer's for now - WC2B6NH

Why didn't you just create the images for all 650 MPs ahead of time?

Because that's expensive as hell and I didn't know if anyone would visit the site..

Re: Show HN: Use Their ID – Use your local UK MP’s ID for the Online Safety Act

#42

I think this is a fun project, but I'm not sure I'd leave this up for much longer. MPs can be litigious. Especially if this is seen to be enabling things like ID fraud. Also, there are only 650 constituencies. I would pre-populate the list so when entering a new postcode, it doesn't stall waiting for AI.

The generated images are very obviously AI fakes. I don't think anyone is going to be seriously fooled by this.

> I would pre-populate the list so when entering a new postcode, it doesn't stall waiting for AI.

It looks like it already works like this? It was slow the first time I searched for my postcode, subsequent times have been very fast.

Re: Show HN: Use Their ID – Use your local UK MP’s ID for the Online Safety Act

#44
post #39

Are the generated images supposed to look like the MP? they look nothing like it as far as I can see.

I think so, Keir Starmer and several others show plausible faces.

On the otherhand Ashfield (NG178DA) fails spectacularly.

Re: Show HN: Use Their ID – Use your local UK MP’s ID for the Online Safety Act

#45
post #24

I think this is a fun project, but I'm not sure I'd leave this up for much longer. MPs can be litigious. Especially if this is seen to be enabling things like ID fraud. Also, there are only 650 constituencies. I would pre-populate the list so when entering a new postcode, it doesn't stall waiting for AI.

You want a different photo each time to avoid easy filter lists.

Sure, if you offer to pay the bill for the Image generation, I'm sure they would love to implement this feature

Re: Show HN: Use Their ID – Use your local UK MP’s ID for the Online Safety Act

#47

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Even if they weren't, most MPs will be old enough that their top level Birth Records are available, so if they don't have a common name or you know enough biographical details you can find them anyway. If they've got a weird name like Elon Musk you just go name -> DOB in one step, if they're a Sarah Black maybe you need to know approximate age, birth name, rough part of the country where they were born. For super com…

where are these public birth records?

https://www.freebmd.org.uk/

Re: Show HN: Use Their ID – Use your local UK MP’s ID for the Online Safety Act

#48
post #3

I like the spirit but wouldn't this run afoul of one or two laws? Identity fraud or some such? I'm not in the UK, so I don't have any idea about their laws, but I'd be shocked to find this was above board. Your FAQ claims it's a parody site and claims " The ID number isn't valid and you can't use the card for anything real. " but you've just confirmed here it can indeed be used for real things (discord, reddit). Your…

I agree, the UK Police wouldn't typically let you get away with "it's just a joke". This would constitute a mixture of identity theft, fake ID and misuse of computers.

It's not just a joke, it's parody and political commentary right?

Re: Show HN: Use Their ID – Use your local UK MP’s ID for the Online Safety Act

#49
post #22

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I agree, the UK Police wouldn't typically let you get away with "it's just a joke". This would constitute a mixture of identity theft, fake ID and misuse of computers.

It's literally just sticking the MPs name into an AI and asking for it to generate a mock ID for them. None of their real data is being used (e.g. their face, their DoB, the address) and the mock IDs wouldn't fool anyone for a second. I'd love if someone who understands the law would weigh in though

[deleted]

Re: Show HN: Use Their ID – Use your local UK MP’s ID for the Online Safety Act

#50
post #10
post #4

>It's a small, silly protest at the stupidity of the Online Safety Act that just came into force. The IDs actually work (for Reddit, Discord etc.) which highlights how terrible this implementation is. Could you give a short TL;DR of how ids are constructed so we can all laugh here in comments?

it's literally just the MPs name. It's a fake DoB (because their DoB's aren't public knowledge anymore) all the numbers and such are nonsense, the images wouldn't fool a human for one second. The AI tools don't let you generate an ID for any real human being (because that sounds like all sorts of fraud) so you can't upload a picture of the MP or anything like that - so I just let the model fill in whatever face it th…

I'm a bit out of the loop and not familiar with the whole thing. Do you just submit a plausibly real name and any DOB that is older than 18 and a picture? Does the thing crosscheck the name + dob with a demographic database (does UK has any)?
Post reply on HN