Live data from Hacker News

Show HN: Container Desktop – Podman Desktop Companion

container-desktop.com

41–50 of 207 posts

Re: Show HN: Container Desktop – Podman Desktop Companion

#41
post #37

Honest question, what’s wrong with docker desktop? Looking at all the alternatives suggested it’s not clear to me why any other tools are better? I’m not using k8s locally, just docker compose. To connect to our remote k8s cluster, I use IntelliJ k8s extension (I just need to do some basic dev tasks, I’m not administrating the cluster)

it's not free

Re: Show HN: Container Desktop – Podman Desktop Companion

#42

I've been using Rancher Desktop as an alternative to Docker Desktop, https://rancherdesktop.io/ on macOS and Windows, it's pretty solid. It has some kinks to work out but I got it working with IDEs too (e.g. the Intellij IDEA Docker Compose integration to work with it). What I also like is that existing scripts and etc that use the docker-compose cli work with Rancher Desktop too, as it uses nerdctl https://github.co…

Currently it is the best alternative I have used, in what concerns the same experience as Docker Desktop on Windows.

Re: Show HN: Container Desktop – Podman Desktop Companion

#43
post #39
post #37

Honest question, what’s wrong with docker desktop? Looking at all the alternatives suggested it’s not clear to me why any other tools are better? I’m not using k8s locally, just docker compose. To connect to our remote k8s cluster, I use IntelliJ k8s extension (I just need to do some basic dev tasks, I’m not administrating the cluster)

For me, it was consuming so much memory. Switching to OrbStack helped fix that

FreeBSD jails? :p

Re: Show HN: Container Desktop – Podman Desktop Companion

#44

Personally I just build all my software so it includes its dependencies and then you don't need docker or any complex image manager. Don't rely on a bunch of crap being installed in the system path! Much much simpler this way imho.

On some projects and teams, more than usually expected, this is more than fine.

Re: Show HN: Container Desktop – Podman Desktop Companion

#45
Kubernetes is planned - my devops wants me to add it badly!

Author note - Most of you guys here are power users, for whom UI is a visual poem that you need or not. This is not a commercial project, it is not following any business goals. But this does not mean concessions to quality, it does try to offer minimal resource usage everywhere, easy experience, good UI/UX.

It explains all it does behind the scenes if you enable the developer console. It can help one learn so at a certain moment one understands and automates with scripts and specs.

But everyone these days is either seen as too smart or too dumb, I don't consider users like this. I know everyone started somewhere and a gradual learning experience is the best.

I broke so many radios and toys when I was a kid and I learned so much, by looking at what was is inside.

It is a project done by one dude, after work and when it rains outside (In Belgium it rains a lot).

Re: Show HN: Container Desktop – Podman Desktop Companion

#46
post #37

Honest question, what’s wrong with docker desktop? Looking at all the alternatives suggested it’s not clear to me why any other tools are better? I’m not using k8s locally, just docker compose. To connect to our remote k8s cluster, I use IntelliJ k8s extension (I just need to do some basic dev tasks, I’m not administrating the cluster)

One big difference is the licensing. Docker Engine itself is apache licensed (and hence free to use at a company of any scale), but Docker Desktop requires a paid plan if your company has more than 250 employees or more than $10 million in annual revenue [0].

[0]: https://docs.docker.com/engine/#licensing

Re: Show HN: Container Desktop – Podman Desktop Companion

#47
post #37

Honest question, what’s wrong with docker desktop? Looking at all the alternatives suggested it’s not clear to me why any other tools are better? I’m not using k8s locally, just docker compose. To connect to our remote k8s cluster, I use IntelliJ k8s extension (I just need to do some basic dev tasks, I’m not administrating the cluster)

Docker Desktop requires a paid licence for companies with over 250 employees. While that's totally fair, it can add red tape if you want to use it in a project.

I'm not completely sure about licensing for Container Desktop but the footer suggests MIT license.

Re: Show HN: Container Desktop – Podman Desktop Companion

#49
post #5
post #3

what does this offer that podman desktop does not? https://podman-desktop.io/

Last I checked podman's support of docker-compose.yml was very limited to say the least. Has it changed?

Yeah, I'm using it and it's nearly everything I need.

Re: Show HN: Container Desktop – Podman Desktop Companion

#50
post #45

Kubernetes is planned - my devops wants me to add it badly! Author note - Most of you guys here are power users, for whom UI is a visual poem that you need or not. This is not a commercial project, it is not following any business goals. But this does not mean concessions to quality, it does try to offer minimal resource usage everywhere, easy experience, good UI/UX. It explains all it does behind the scenes if you e…

> But everyone these days is either seen as too smart or too dumb

Vert succinct and poetic way to describe so much these days in this space.

Post reply on HN