Live data from Hacker News

Show HN: My iPad Hacker News Client, Hacker News Paper

hackernewspaper.com

41–50 of 61 posts

Re: Show HN: My iPad Hacker News Client, Hacker News Paper

#41

This is a blatant copy of my web app Hacker Newspaper. http://gilesbowkett.blogspot.com/2011/11/imitation-is-sincer...

How many unique visitors do you get per day?

It's how I generally read HN.

HNP is a popular if niche app.

Meanwhile, it doesn't make a whit of difference to the larger issue.

Re: Show HN: My iPad Hacker News Client, Hacker News Paper

#43
Congrats on the launch. Unfortunately you've chosen to name your app the same thing Giles very similar app from 2009 is named.

I truly believe that the onus is on you to Google the name you want to use before you launch. Heck, just to make sure there isn't competition - much less something with the same name. That isn't good for either of you.

Perhaps you should strongly consider changing the name of your application.

Re: Show HN: My iPad Hacker News Client, Hacker News Paper

#44
post #16

This is a blatant copy of my web app Hacker Newspaper. http://gilesbowkett.blogspot.com/2011/11/imitation-is-sincer...

Feel free to email me at sam@sammcd.com if you would like to discuss this more. I just want to say that I did not use your app as a source at all when designing my app, but I did use newspapers.

If this is the case, why did you not use a gothic, New York Times-y font for your header graphic, such as is much, much more typical for newspapers than the font you did use? Why does your header graphic appear to be nearly identical to mine? Why is your functionality nearly identical to mine? It's just a massive coincidence?

Re: Show HN: My iPad Hacker News Client, Hacker News Paper

#46

This is a blatant copy of my web app Hacker Newspaper. http://gilesbowkett.blogspot.com/2011/11/imitation-is-sincer...

I understand that it is frustrating to you to feel that someone may have been inspired by some aspects of your project. However, I think it's important to consider a few things for perspective:

1. Your web app is close to, if not already, dead: http://gilesbowkett.blogspot.com/2011/03/i-may-let-hacker-ne...

2. So what if this guy was inspired by your app? Who doesn't do research before implementing an idea?

3. Your most persuasive evidence--the header font--appears to be the most unpopular aspect of the app, judging by the comments, and so will probably be changed shortly, anyway.

4. The developer is not in direct competition with your project, as he didn't even code it for the same platform (yes, an iPad can browse the web, but yours was not, specifically, an iPad app).

Re: Show HN: My iPad Hacker News Client, Hacker News Paper

#48
It is truly unfortunate that this app so closely resembles Giles’ work. In hindsight, everything seems obvious: “Hacker News... As a Newspaper.” Yet nobody did it before Giles, and now somebody else has done it after Giles.

It reminds me of the talk about how obvious the iPhone UI is, such that Google wasn’t copying iPhone but just proceeding along “obvious” lines. Yet, it seems that they were busy proceeding along the obvious line of imitating Blackberry until the iPhone became a hit, then they were proceeding along the obvious line of imitating an iPhone.

The author of this work seems to be saying that he did this entirely independently. I am prepared to accept his word for that, which is why I use the word “unfortunate.” There are so many truly new and novel things to invent, it is a great shame that two smart people put work into inventing the same thing instead of giving birth to two different ideas.

Re: Show HN: My iPad Hacker News Client, Hacker News Paper

#49

This is a blatant copy of my web app Hacker Newspaper. http://gilesbowkett.blogspot.com/2011/11/imitation-is-sincer...

I understand that it is frustrating to you to feel that someone may have been inspired by some aspects of your project. However, I think it's important to consider a few things for perspective: 1. Your web app is close to, if not already, dead: http://gilesbowkett.blogspot.com/2011/03/i-may-let-hacker-ne... 2. So what if this guy was inspired by your app? Who doesn't do research before implementing an idea? 3. Your m…

The app is not at all dead, and I use it on the iPad far more often than on my computers. If you're curious enough to search my site for Hacker Newspaper, you must have also noticed the numerous minor tweaks and updates to Hacker Newspaper I've made since that post where I briefly considered dropping it over six months ago.

Re: Show HN: My iPad Hacker News Client, Hacker News Paper

#50

This is a blatant copy of my web app Hacker Newspaper. http://gilesbowkett.blogspot.com/2011/11/imitation-is-sincer...

I understand that it is frustrating to you to feel that someone may have been inspired by some aspects of your project. However, I think it's important to consider a few things for perspective: 1. Your web app is close to, if not already, dead: http://gilesbowkett.blogspot.com/2011/03/i-may-let-hacker-ne... 2. So what if this guy was inspired by your app? Who doesn't do research before implementing an idea? 3. Your m…

Additionally, my most persuasive evidence is not my header graphic, it's just an extremely specific example. My most persuasive evidence is that every single aspect of his app is a direct copy of mine.
Post reply on HN