Live data from Hacker News

Show HN: Free and open-source illustrations for your projects

iradesign.io

41–50 of 135 posts

Re: Show HN: Free and open-source illustrations for your projects

#41
post #38
post #8

Why someone should go to such lengths in order to make someone money for free? Have companies just become a leech on public with tax evasion and discount and private?

As someone who built a free educational platform - I do it because I want my students to have quality learning without feeding into the $300 textbook industry. I'm funded through my career, so it is a passion project. I wanted to build the thing, so I did. I'm not interested in taking on the responsibilities for making it a profitable company.

So yeah my point was not about private to help other people or kids, it's the freebies toward companies who do stuff for a profit and are paid, and take free stuff, it's a bit less disgusting than restaurants who expect people to tip their staff for wage

Re: Show HN: Free and open-source illustrations for your projects

#43
Sorry to be a Scrooge, but I wish people would stop doing this. It's hard enough to make a living as an illustrator in the age of digital photography and photobashing without having to compete with generic (which I mean both descriptively and—sorry—pejoratively) illustration libraries. This stuff undermines the discipline and suggests that its skills are easily acquired and the work is easily done, so there's no reason to compensate people for it.

There's a lot of talk on HN about the importance of paying for things, and while I know that most of that is in opposition to 'paying' with your privacy, which is very different from what I'm addressing here, I think the basic idea of value still applies. It's important to pay for shit sometimes. Forget the ethics of supporting your peers and just think about how it'll get you better quality, custom work.

Open-source is awesome, and I totally support anyone fighting that fight, but this kind of work is pretty clearly aimed at startups trying to penny-pinch their way into the brand signaling and associations afforded by adopting the corporate memphis look. Maybe that's an unfair read, but I can't remember the last time I saw an unfunded open-source project trying to look like every VC-backed lifestyle app that launched over the last six years.

On a particularly bad day, I can't help but feel like this kind of project is leading toward the centralization of art as a whole. It's undeniably stagnating commercial artistry.

Sincerely,

Someone who is still butthurt about Squarespace, et al. killing off small and solo web design/dev shops.

Re: Show HN: Free and open-source illustrations for your projects

#44

The licensing terms don't seem compatible with open source. They're just free (gratis) for many uses though.

You can use the illustrations as you want. The paragraph from our license which says that you can't use products to create templates, and so on, applies to our templates (containing code), not illustrations.

I appreciate the response. As others have noted though, the licensing terms are very hard to parse. Have you considered using one of the Creative Commons licenses for the artwork, with commonly used software licenses for the software pieces?

Re: Show HN: Free and open-source illustrations for your projects

#45
post #36

The more and more UI and Illustration are "accessible" and "cheap/free" the more people like me who can produce quality illustrations will have big bucks. So keep it rolling with Corporate Memphisication.

Free illustrations are the new ‘business_person_pointing_at_computer.jpg’.

Re: Show HN: Free and open-source illustrations for your projects

#46

Sorry to be a Scrooge, but I wish people would stop doing this. It's hard enough to make a living as an illustrator in the age of digital photography and photobashing without having to compete with generic (which I mean both descriptively and—sorry—pejoratively) illustration libraries. This stuff undermines the discipline and suggests that its skills are easily acquired and the work is easily done, so there's no reas…

I'm curious, do you feel this way about open source software as well? Does it cheapen the value of being a developer? If not, why do you think art is different and why is open source art a bad thing?

Re: Show HN: Free and open-source illustrations for your projects

#47

Sorry to be a Scrooge, but I wish people would stop doing this. It's hard enough to make a living as an illustrator in the age of digital photography and photobashing without having to compete with generic (which I mean both descriptively and—sorry—pejoratively) illustration libraries. This stuff undermines the discipline and suggests that its skills are easily acquired and the work is easily done, so there's no reas…

this comes up every single time someone shares their work for free. look, i have some sympathy for you, and yes it leads to devaluing some work by people who don't value your work, but people are going to keep doing it for exposure, you don't have the power to stop them, so accept that this is a thing and find the people who DO value your work. you have a powerful, awesome skill that I'd kill to have. I hope you realize how prized you are by the people that can't do what you do.

Re: Show HN: Free and open-source illustrations for your projects

#49
post #6

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I think paragraph (5) of https://www.creative-tim.com/license?ref=iradesign-footer applies here "There can be different components in some of our Items that can have a separate License from this one, and other license terms may apply to that specific component. Usually, those components come with a Free and Open Source MIT License."

No worries! You can use the illustrations as you want. You can just give credits if you want. The paragraph from our license which says that you can't use products to create templates, and so on, applies to our templates (containing code), not illustrations.

I'd recommend looking into known licenses like the Creative Commons license set for the artwork. For the software part of your product check the most used open source licenses, including the copyleft ones if you want to keep the option to negotiate commercial deals.

Re: Show HN: Free and open-source illustrations for your projects

#50

This is great! Thank you for sharing. But... is anyone else growing tired of the sales-pitch we're all using? And do any of us find it valuable for ourselves when we read them? We've trained ourselves (collectively, as an industry) to expect a specific type of one-page: hero image, call-out-message with CTA, then abstract illustrations combined with text about how great something is. I don't know what I want in it's…

I hate it without realizing how much I hate it, and now that you've pointed it out in such simple, concrete terms I'm not going to be able to stop seeing it everywhere.
Post reply on HN