Live data from Hacker News

Show HN: Tara – A free Jira alternative, now with Gitlab

tara.ai

41–50 of 140 posts

Re: Show HN: Tara – A free Jira alternative, now with Gitlab

#42
post #26

Is self-hosted on the roadmap?

One would hope, that's one of Jiras best features, even if Atlassian clearly doesn't agree.

I get why they want to compare Tara to Jira, but when you look at what companies actually do with Jira, then you'll hit a wall rather quickly with pretty much everything else.

Like them or not, Atlassians product integrate rather well, and you can "easily" customize them to integrate into pretty much everything else. We have Jira integrated into pretty much everything from monitoring to invoicing.

You can also customize the snot of internal workflows in Jira, per project basis. Even to the point where nothing makes sense any more.

Finding a replacement is hard, but relevant given the latest pricing changes from Atlassian. That and their idiotic prioritisation of their cloud offering. Oh yeah, and no Atlassian product has a functional search feature.

Re: Show HN: Tara – A free Jira alternative, now with Gitlab

#43
post #37

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It is free now, they never say it will be free forever.

How do you interpret this in the "Pricing" modal: > Our free forever plan has unlimited tasks, sprints and workspaces, with no user limits.

I interpret it as "we will somehow monetize your data and train our AI model on your activities"

Re: Show HN: Tara – A free Jira alternative, now with Gitlab

#44
post #19

This thing is in absolutely no way a Jira alternative. (YouTrack is the Jira alternative, but it's not free.)

For us, the key was to build a simple Jira alternative. A good PM tool should do the basics, and get out of the way. Personal opinion, so many PM tools tend to be bloated and each view ends up causing more mental overload for the team, EM and PM. We've tried to focus on speed with performance and keeping things simple.

Jira is a project management tool? I think that one of the only things we don't use it for.

Re: Show HN: Tara – A free Jira alternative, now with Gitlab

#46
post #32
post #28

Does it have something like JIRA-1330? Because that’s what makes everything else in Jira a sorry kludge

What's your take on changing the status quo around unique task/issue ID's?

Can't say anything more than: it depends.

To its essence, an ID allows interested parties to track something over time.

If you add additional meanings to an ID - e.g. the parent project as Jira does, or the kind as in ServiceNow - these can become outdated over time, and deceiving.

I'd say it's ok to change the "external name" as this other metadata changes over time (project name, bug, task, story, whatever...) but make the obsolete synonyms redirect to the currently active name.

Re: Show HN: Tara – A free Jira alternative, now with Gitlab

#48
post #40

"Free" is the worst pricing of all. Open-source is great. One time purchase price is great for products that don't require maintenance. Subscription pricing is perfectly valid for online services that are not open-source. Free? Free is the worst. I don't get any trust that the service will stay around, it can completely change along the way to "paid", and I don't get to keep anything in that case.

FWIW, they explain exactly how they'll make money in the website (under Pricing) and in this thread.

we hope to get you dependent upon our product, and in the meantime come up with something we hope you'll be willing to pay for is not the most confidence inducing of business plans. Also, if the current plans are "free forever" have no caps on users or much of anything else and are good enough to use until they actually finish off the things worth paying for then how many folks are actually going to be inclined to pay for them?

if it's NOT good enough as-is then why bother using it in the first place?

Re: Show HN: Tara – A free Jira alternative, now with Gitlab

#49

I don't see anything on the website about Gitlab integration

Gitlab CE free edition has many plan features https://about.gitlab.com/features/#plan including Milestones, Issue Board, etc. What features is gitlab ce lacking, that makes you want to use a 3rd party planning product?

Re: Show HN: Tara – A free Jira alternative, now with Gitlab

#50
post #2

Hi HN! We last crossed paths 6 months ago, when we shared Tara 1.0, a simple Jira alternative. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23033387 I'm one of the creators of Tara, and with support and feedback from the community, we've been hard at work building this v1.5 release over 24 sprints and 500+ pull requests. Several of you asked for an improved Github sync, PRs and commits tracked in tasks, alongside a Gitlab in…

Any plans to accommodate privately-hosted git servers?
Post reply on HN