Live data from Hacker News

Show HN: DoNotNotify – Log and intelligently block notifications on Android

donotnotify.com

31–40 of 171 posts

Re: Show HN: DoNotNotify – Log and intelligently block notifications on Android

#31

This is really great. I chuckled seeing MyGate. I hate that app. My society uses it and I'd need this exactly for it. I hate that Android doesn't force devs to use the right notification category. Apps need to be penalized for not adhering to that.

I agree, this is an excellent idea and I am excited to try it.

Re: Show HN: DoNotNotify – Log and intelligently block notifications on Android

#32
Imho there are 3 separate classes of notifications

1) Ads - these should not exist, really, or at worst should be flagged in the app store as an anti-feature isolateable from other notifications.

2) "Recommendations" - that is, stuff you didn't subscribe to but are things the app offers that they "think you would like". These are defensible but should never ever be mixed with...

3) Stuff I actually explicitly subscribed to.

Breaking these rules should be rejection from the app store. Especially now that Google is legally required to allow 3rd-party app stores, they have much greater grounds to properly curate the Play Store. Let the filth live on 3rd-party stores.

Re: Show HN: DoNotNotify – Log and intelligently block notifications on Android

#33
post #5

The play store should reject apps that use audible notifications other than those controlled by Android platform notification permissions. Making a user dig through an obscure multiple layer settings jungle to track down and kill annoying notifications is a dark pattern and deserves de-platforming. I'm looking at you, Facebook.

You long press the notification and block the app. Pretty straightforward.

Re: Show HN: DoNotNotify – Log and intelligently block notifications on Android

#34
This looks nice! I had no idea you could actually control notifications as an app.

One thing I've always wanted is the ability to "group" notifications.

Apps like WhatsApp can be really bad for pinging lots of times within a minute for individual messages. I really don't need my phone to buzz more than once every five minutes, and wish I could set rules like "don't buzz for x minutes after a notification".

Re: Show HN: DoNotNotify – Log and intelligently block notifications on Android

#35

I have an Android phone and it's constantly set to 'Do not disturb'. I only have a couple of people that are exempt (you can do that in the settings). Because of this I am not too fussed about even occasional extra notification, because I deal with all of them when I have time.

Personally it just grates me when my notifications stack up (even if I wasn't disturbed when the notifications came in). My philosophy is - I should be able to control what I see, hence this app.

Re: Show HN: DoNotNotify – Log and intelligently block notifications on Android

#36
post #22

I use an app called BuzzKill on Android for achieving this and many more things. I usually keep my notification bar at an absolute minimum when it comes to the number of notifications, but this app allows me to set rules for notifications based on their content. By default, all apps that I use have notifications turned off by default and they also get into deep sleep mode. So I'm sure they are not even running after…

I second Buzzkill. My comment was going to be "What does this do that Buzzkill doesn't?"

Honestly I did not know about Buzzkill. I suppose the big differentiator is that DoNotNotify is absolutely free.

Re: Show HN: DoNotNotify – Log and intelligently block notifications on Android

#37
post #18

Wow, I had no idea Android allowed a third party app to take over absolute control of all notifications. I assume you have to allow it somehow? It’s actually very cool that this is possible. Apple would never even consider allowing this.

Yes, it requires a special permission, which the app asks for when it is first launched. Thankfully no other permissions are required.

Re: Show HN: DoNotNotify – Log and intelligently block notifications on Android

#38
post #6

I’m now an iOS user but the problem is actually the same here : apps not respecting communication channels to push ads (mostly to their own app or service). I usually fully block notifications from most apps but for some apps the notifications are really convenient (carpooling, transport or delivery app). Yes I want to know if the train I booked is delayed. No I don’t want to be notified that you are now partnering w…

Worse even because iOS doesn't offer notification groups/channels like Android does (ignoring the fact that market leaders like Uber, DoorDash, etc. eschew them in favor of "General" channels they can pump both delivery/ride info and ads through.)

IMO this needs to be an app guideline enforced by the iOS App Store and Play Store. I remember back in the day, iOS used to be known for having less spammy notifications.

Re: Show HN: DoNotNotify – Log and intelligently block notifications on Android

#39
post #4

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Can you share a screenshot of the notification, and the rule that you created for it at aj@donotnotify.com please? Also, do note that if it is a persistent notification[1] then the Android OS does not allow it to be dismissed. In such a case, you will see the notification in the blocked history with a warning icon next to it. [1] https://developer.android.com/develop/ui/views/notifications...

AutoNotification app can block persistent notifications if I understand correctly what it is. Hides things like "Wifi Calling" that you can't normally disable, swipe. Doesn't require root. So there might be the way. It became less reliable on latest samsung phones, but works on pixels afaik.

Thanks for the heads up! Will take a look at it.

Re: Show HN: DoNotNotify – Log and intelligently block notifications on Android

#40
post #5

The play store should reject apps that use audible notifications other than those controlled by Android platform notification permissions. Making a user dig through an obscure multiple layer settings jungle to track down and kill annoying notifications is a dark pattern and deserves de-platforming. I'm looking at you, Facebook.

You long press the notification and block the app. Pretty straightforward.

Step 1: Within the Facebook App (Most Important) Open the Facebook app. Tap the Menu icon (three lines/your profile picture) > Settings & Privacy > Settings. Scroll to Notifications (under "Notifications and Permissions"). Tap Notifications, then select Push notifications. Toggle off all notification types (Comments, Likes, Tags, Birthdays, etc.) and turn off the main Push Notifications toggle. Check Email & SMS Notifications and Mobile Push Notifications to disable any lingering alerts there. Step 2: In Android System Settings Open your phone's Settings app. Go to Apps, Apps & notifications, or Applications (depending on your Android version). Find and tap on Facebook. Tap Notifications. Turn the main All Facebook notifications toggle OFF (it should turn gray). Step 3: For Browser-Based Notifications (Pop-ups) Open your browser (Chrome, Firefox, etc.) on your phone. Go to Settings > Site Settings > Notifications. Find Facebook in the allowed list and block it, or remove it entirely. If They Still Persist (Advanced) Check for app updates: Sometimes updates reset settings; re-apply Step 1 and 2. Use a third-party blocker: Apps like Freedom or similar tools can block the app or its notifications at a system level. Restrict Background Data: In Android Settings > Apps > Facebook > Mobile data & Wi-Fi, you can restrict background data usage.
Post reply on HN