Live data from Hacker News

Show HN: Whittle – A shrinking word game

playwhittle.com

31–40 of 64 posts

Re: Show HN: Whittle – A shrinking word game

#31
post #6

Is it always possible to go all the way down to a single letter? I'm working on August 4, and it's proving challenging

Yes, 1 August and 4 August have me stumped. Interestingly it says I have discovered 100% of words on 1 August, but I wasn't able to whittle it down to 0. I'm not sure if that just means I missed an opportunity to remove the space somewhere.

August 4 is not solvable with the given wordlist. There is no way to get to a word below 3 letters ("set")

Re: Show HN: Whittle – A shrinking word game

#33
Feedback: I wasn’t sure what to do in the initial game state. It wasn’t obvious that the letters could be “clicked” directly. In a similar word game [0] (also posted on HN recently; perhaps your inspiration?), the letters are in boxes that make them seem more like buttons you can press. The unlabeled tabs at the bottom were also mysterious; many other games like Wordle have their inputs (e.g. a keyboard) at the bottom, so that was initially a bit confusing.

It’s also easy to accidentally spoil the game by clicking the unlabeled right tab. EDIT: Oops, didn't realize that was the words discovered list, not the complete wordlist. This should have a label to make it clearer.

Also, in the help screen, the dots in the UI made me expect to swipe (on mobile) to navigate between screens, so that was a bit confusing at first.

0: https://www.shrinkle.org/

Re: Show HN: Whittle – A shrinking word game

#34

Feedback: I wasn’t sure what to do in the initial game state. It wasn’t obvious that the letters could be “clicked” directly. In a similar word game [0] (also posted on HN recently; perhaps your inspiration?), the letters are in boxes that make them seem more like buttons you can press. The unlabeled tabs at the bottom were also mysterious; many other games like Wordle have their inputs (e.g. a keyboard) at the botto…

Yes, a week ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44714167

Re: Show HN: Whittle – A shrinking word game

#36

I ended at: rat he I remove "h" but it doesn't accept "rate" as a correct word. Am I missing something?

You need to remove a single letter while keeping the remaining letters in the same order - removing "h" from "rat he" leaves "rat e" not "rate".

Re: Show HN: Whittle – A shrinking word game

#38
post #6

Is it always possible to go all the way down to a single letter? I'm working on August 4, and it's proving challenging

Hi, this is OP! Thank you to everyone for pointing this out, you are not crazy-- these puzzles were impossible after I removed some invalid words from the dictionary. I had previously replaced the puzzles, but my branch state seems to have gotten out of sync. Please restart Aug 1 and 4 if you'd like, there should be new puzzles to try now!

Re: Show HN: Whittle – A shrinking word game

#40
post #13

Nice! You definitely have something there. I would love a dictionary lookup. I'd expect a big part of the strategy to be working backwards from the possible 1/2 letter words, but there's no way to tell how reasonable the dictionary is without testing, and getting the game into the proper state to test would be just as hard as solving the puzzle in the first place. Having two separate goals (eliminate all letters, fin…

Thank you so much for the feedback! The dictionary look up feature is a great idea-- I had never thought of it before, but it does solve a pain point with the game you've articulated well.

The desktop UI suggestions are also very helpful. I've updated the desktop version with some minor hover effects and cursor styling. I've mostly been focused on mobile, so it was good hear some feedback for desktop.

Post reply on HN