Live data from Hacker News

Show HN: I mapped HN's favorite books with GPT-4o

hnbooks.pieterma.es

31–40 of 65 posts

Re: Show HN: I mapped HN's favorite books with GPT-4o

#31

Interesting but the visualization is useless. How about a standard tabular format maybe grouped by genre?

The 'genres' emerge out of the clusters. The fact that you can pick out 'genres' from this plot is an example of semi-supervised learning.

OK but there's no clue what they are until you start poking around. It's not something that's useful without some substantial investment of time and exploration. If that's the goal, fine but it's not how I would present a "favorite books" list.

Re: Show HN: I mapped HN's favorite books with GPT-4o

#33

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The 'genres' emerge out of the clusters. The fact that you can pick out 'genres' from this plot is an example of semi-supervised learning.

OK but there's no clue what they are until you start poking around. It's not something that's useful without some substantial investment of time and exploration. If that's the goal, fine but it's not how I would present a "favorite books" list.

Making 'genres' and classifying things is imprecise and requires experts in subject matter and library science to get it right. The "genre" labels here emerge out of the data itself.

Re: Show HN: I mapped HN's favorite books with GPT-4o

#34

Niiice! I really like it. The spatial approach is cool, though labelling/annotations/axes would help. I share the frustraion with getting book covers for my project ablf.io. Amazon used to make this much easier, but they've locked it down recently, so you have to jump through affiliate hoops. I ended up implementing my own thing and storing thousands of images myself on S3. If you have the goodreads IDs, feel free to…

That’s a great website. I’ve been looking for alternative book recommendation websites for a while and it really has nailed it down.

It even recommended me a somewhat eclectic book I’ve recently been meaning to read.

Is there a reason you limit to only 6 favorite books? Is it due to computational restraints?

Re: Show HN: I mapped HN's favorite books with GPT-4o

#36

Interesting but the visualization is useless. How about a standard tabular format maybe grouped by genre?

I think it's useful as a tool for browsing a getting a general gist of what people are into and seeing if your favorites are there, too. As for a tool to maximize one's reading list, certainly not as useful, but I appreciate that it didn't make me feel like I had to create action items on things to read.

Re: Show HN: I mapped HN's favorite books with GPT-4o

#37
Lovely work, thank you for sharing

Probably a comment on my subconscious desire for familiarity/patterns, but the left side of the map instantly made me think of NW Europe: long skinny Norway dangling between the UK and Denmark (not correctly spaced, but sizes are reasonably correct!). A few other candidates at a stretch - maybe some Baltic states off to the east, for example - but after that it breaks down unfortunately.

Cool project sir

Re: Show HN: I mapped HN's favorite books with GPT-4o

#38

Really cool to see my favs show up, but I honestly don't understand what we're actually looking at; the groupings seem very opaque beyond very general themes like sci-fi, startups, biographies, math, physics. In other words, what are the clustering shapes telling us? Can we dig in based on geography, publishing date, key terms or themes? Either way, I can't keep the site open for more than 30-40 seconds before it cra…

> Either way, I can't keep the site open for more than 30-40 seconds before it crashes.

Yup, probably was about to happen to me too, had I not closed it.

CPU fan almost launched off the troposphere about 30 seconds in.

Probably a cluttered bunch of heavily unoptimized ReactJS modules in there (no offense to OP, I know it probably sped up development by 10x at least)

Post reply on HN