Live data from Hacker News

Show HN: Hacker News-ish stock news, from 40+ sources

steez.news

31–40 of 72 posts

Re: Show HN: Hacker News-ish stock news, from 40+ sources

#31

FWIW I don't think that you can really do this without moderation. Financial news is one area where curation shines particularly strongly, considering how strong monetary and information gain collide. Benzinga / Motley Fool / Seeking Alpha / Business Wire / Forbes aren't places to find worthwhile information.

It looks like it relies on whatever curation https://stocknewsapi.com/ provides. So "moderation"/curation is being done, but not by steez.

Re: Show HN: Hacker News-ish stock news, from 40+ sources

#32

I strongly suspect that a popular news resource focusing on stocks is liable to be overrun with bots or ‘sponsored content’, either with or without moderators’ blessing/compensation. It’s the niche where information asymmetry and financial gain are so awkwardly close.

Financial news is like a TV channel that plays nothing but commercials. In the sense that every story is trying to get you to do something very specific that enriches the storyteller.

I don't know why anybody would want that.

Re: Show HN: Hacker News-ish stock news, from 40+ sources

#34

FWIW I don't think that you can really do this without moderation. Financial news is one area where curation shines particularly strongly, considering how strong monetary and information gain collide. Benzinga / Motley Fool / Seeking Alpha / Business Wire / Forbes aren't places to find worthwhile information.

where do you expect to find stock analyses that were written and published with no afterthought? All these authors have some sort of hidden agenda, don't they? Sometimes you find a useful hint at the start of some hype though.

Re: Show HN: Hacker News-ish stock news, from 40+ sources

#36

FWIW I don't think that you can really do this without moderation. Financial news is one area where curation shines particularly strongly, considering how strong monetary and information gain collide. Benzinga / Motley Fool / Seeking Alpha / Business Wire / Forbes aren't places to find worthwhile information.

That's why a site like biztoc.com makes sense — curation + aggregation.

Re: Show HN: Hacker News-ish stock news, from 40+ sources

#37
This is still biased. I respect the effort but a bloomberg or Eikon terminal is the only thing that is going to give you a true "pulse" of the market. Otherwise these are all lagging indicators confounded by the biases of the news algorithm writer.

You could try to hook into DTN iQFeed or another source. For example, the reports from futures brokers tend to be up-to-the-minute in my experience. Trying to solve everything at once is just an example of engineers attempting to solve a problem they don't understand.

This is meant as no disrespect to you OP. I am just a small trader and spent a lot of time trading lots of commodities. Thousands of small companies have tried and failed. I remember subscribing briefly to a several hundred dollar per month service that gave me the live feed, undelayed, of the brokers on the floor of corn/soy. It's an extremely hard problem to solve and honestly is rife with deep covenants you won't be able to break without money and/or a seat on the exchange.

Good luck to you. Unfortunately with today's computer powered environments it's harder to get a "market pulse" without bias. If I am going to give you any feedback the fact I don't have to pay money for this feed already indicates to me it's probably not worth looking at. Could you try to work an angle with a squawk service or something and charge a sum to get it?

Traders that are serious, i.e. not anyone on robinhood/major broker, take this very seriously. You could make a lot of money by providing good news in a single niche or perhaps two if you have the motivation. Don't focus on the worthless robinhood traders. With a news feed service you need to focus on the guys who are hooked into clearing houses. Not fly-by-night or payment-for-orderflow exchanges. The pikers trading 10,000 or less will never pay for a service. The guys moving units with deals on certain exchanges will pay an _extremely_ high premium or good information.

Re: Show HN: Hacker News-ish stock news, from 40+ sources

#38

FWIW I don't think that you can really do this without moderation. Financial news is one area where curation shines particularly strongly, considering how strong monetary and information gain collide. Benzinga / Motley Fool / Seeking Alpha / Business Wire / Forbes aren't places to find worthwhile information.

That's why a site like biztoc.com makes sense — curation + aggregation.

Looks good, but the login-mechanism is pure trash. It does not allow you to make account+password, but forces you to click a "magic link" in order to login.

It was written in big letters, "dont worry we wont spam".

3 minutes later: 2 emails in my inbox. One of them "BizToc is made possible by Mark Cuban & Thomas Marban. If you’re enjoying it, please invite your friends & colleagues."

This is pure spam and I do not like it.

Re: Show HN: Hacker News-ish stock news, from 40+ sources

#39

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That's why a site like biztoc.com makes sense — curation + aggregation.

Looks good, but the login-mechanism is pure trash. It does not allow you to make account+password, but forces you to click a "magic link" in order to login. It was written in big letters, "dont worry we wont spam". 3 minutes later: 2 emails in my inbox. One of them "BizToc is made possible by Mark Cuban & Thomas Marban. If you’re enjoying it, please invite your friends & colleagues." This is pure spam and I do not li…

There is a difference between a single onboarding email and actual spam. Magic links — love or hate em, but more and more services use them. Klarna, Vercel, ...

Re: Show HN: Hacker News-ish stock news, from 40+ sources

#40

FWIW I don't think that you can really do this without moderation. Financial news is one area where curation shines particularly strongly, considering how strong monetary and information gain collide. Benzinga / Motley Fool / Seeking Alpha / Business Wire / Forbes aren't places to find worthwhile information.

Was just going to say basically the same thing, though you are wrong about Business Wire (the source of some original press releases with high value).

This site would be better with way fewer sources, paradoxically. Probably 5-7 are all you need.

I pay a small fortune for Bloomberg each year and get notifications of all news on a list of stocks ~200 long. Most of the notifications are spammy lawyer press releases. Bloomberg has made no effort to curate this intelligently. Yes I know I can manually ignore certain keywords, but that's a pain and constantly evolves, it seems.

Curation is indeed paramount in the financial news industry, where much news is automatically regurgitated to generate page views/ad revenue.

Post reply on HN