Live data from Hacker News

Show HN: I completed shipping my desktop app

pimosa.app

251–260 of 304 posts

Re: Show HN: I completed shipping my desktop app

#251
post #245
post #135

I’ll try to not be dismissive of the labour, though it’s kind of funny (or actually natural) that the heavy lifting libraries that only a few can actually write are open and free, while the shallow wrappers that everyone can write are paid and closed. Decades ago we were calling out these software and now it’s the norm. Another example along the line: I wanted to extract a frame from a video on iOS, it’s impossible w…

The authors and maintainers of foundational code/utilities like ffmpeg/curl/etc. should definitely be the ones who have all the riches they could ever want. Thousands have made fortunes off of their work. That said, what's the free and open source version of this tool? There are some great open source video editors like Shotcut, Openshot, KDENLive, Blender, etc., but I think this tool is more like CyberChef for video…

>what's the free and open source version of this tool?

PowerToys is Free and Open Source, and has at minimum an image resizer utility. It's a good starting point for adding on richer functionality like a preview GUI, and I'm sure that the basic video and audio manipulation would be appreciated as additions. Also since it's a Microsoft sponsored project, I imagine that the signing process is drastically different than what OP has experienced.

I know that's really not satisfying to say that "someday we could have this in the FOSS space", but everything starts somewhere.

Though editors like Shotcut and KDENLive are considered non linear since you can layer on different effects, while OP's utility is definitely not that.

Re: Show HN: I completed shipping my desktop app

#253

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That comment above was a call out to the (in)famous comment when Dropbox was introduced on HN back in 2007 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9224 It’s the HN version of “less space than the Nomad. No wireless. Lame” https://m.slashdot.org/story/21026

Note that this is only Part I of the original comment. Parts II and III are more interesting (but everybody forgets them).

Where is part II and III?

Re: Show HN: I completed shipping my desktop app

#255
post #127

While you are not too far into selling - a word of advice. Switch to offering a year of free updates and charge a small fee after that. Trust me. You will coverge to this scheme sooner or later, so do it now. - Standalone Windows installer is a must. Windows Store is still a deserted wasteland and is not a default choice for the vast majority of Windows users. You are losing a ton of users over this. - ffmpeg and oth…

Can you elaborate on the ethical reasons? I should mention that I'm not very smart.

Re: Show HN: I completed shipping my desktop app

#256

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Well I think Amazon and many other huge companies are having many unethical activities, and I think we should not think that if big companies do certain things, that it should be ok for us to do it too. HN is a community of hackers, not business people that are only commercially interested. But Hackers need money too, so we also need to be a little bit commercial. But it would be ideal if we could be commercial witho…

> HN is a community of hackers, not business people From what I read here daily, it is becoming an anti-hacker, anti-worker, anti-individual and pro-big business community. One of the proofs is this theread. You can see People defending AWS... BUT my point is not AWS is wrong, but supporting AWS and criticizing individuals is what is wrong. And no one noticed this, and has already started defending AWS. This is somet…

>And no one noticed this

people did, it's just that you get attacked or reported if you do so, not this thread specifically but in general

Re: Show HN: I completed shipping my desktop app

#257

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I think you are underestimating how difficult making a great UI is (although I haven’t used this application so I can’t say if it’s great or not).

And you might be underestimating the work that went into those libraries. We are talking decades of work, dealing with platform issues, performance, loads of security considerations and then there is the whole licensing+patent topic. Sure UI work is hard, but of the whole package, it's only the visible part of the iceberg and now I'm expected to give $30 to the person who only contributed that last piece? Of course i…

> and now I'm expected to give $30 to the person who only contributed that last piece?

No, you are not expected to pay $30 to anybody.

If the distribution of the money make you unhappy, just pay $30 to this guy and $30 to the other project (or $150 using a x5 ratio sugested in other comment).

Or you can use the free CLI, or a free alternative.

Even better, you can write a free clone of this app and distribute it for free. Just remember to choose the licence carefuly. You'd probably like AGPL that makes comercial use very difficult.

Re: Show HN: I completed shipping my desktop app

#258

Earlier quoted context omitted.

As far as I understand, windows store is no longer available on enterprise windows. So if you want to sell a business app, it is not even an option.

It's still there on the version of Windows 11 I use at my office.

It’s gone on win10 at my office. With a «closed permanently» message.

Re: Show HN: I completed shipping my desktop app

#260
Great-looking cross-platform app, was curious how this was possible.

Looks like Flutter has third-party libraries for macOS and Windows. I found a damper to the excitement of being able to make great-looking cross-platform apps though, seems Flutter has a big battery drain issue related to rendering blinking cursors that doesn't seem to have been resolved.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29175109

Post reply on HN