Show HN: LeanReviews - quick reviews for almost anything • Hacker News Board

Re: Show HN: LeanReviews - quick reviews for almost anything

#21

Post by aaronz8 » Sun, Apr 28, 2013, 4:41 PM UTC

aaronz8 wrote: post #20

Hey, great idea! I found a couple bugs: 1. There is not much user input validation, if any. For example, I submitted Broken to the San Francisco page, and it broke the "Explore Review Frequencies" section. 2. There is no checking for repeating submissions. Using a while loop on "send_review('stuff')" repeated my submission until I refreshed the page. A way to fix this would be to save an array of user ids per topic,…

By the way... feel free to delete all the "broken" tags in the San Francisco page...

Re: Show HN: LeanReviews - quick reviews for almost anything

#22

Post by udayj » Sun, Apr 28, 2013, 4:57 PM UTC

aaronz8 wrote: post #21

aaronz8 wrote: post #20

Hey, great idea! I found a couple bugs: 1. There is not much user input validation, if any. For example, I submitted Broken to the San Francisco page, and it broke the "Explore Review Frequencies" section. 2. There is no checking for repeating submissions. Using a while loop on "send_review('stuff')" repeated my submission until I refreshed the page. A way to fix this would be to save an array of user ids per topic,…

By the way... feel free to delete all the "broken" tags in the San Francisco page...

Hey thanks for letting me know of the bugs. Presently I am not disallowing repeated submissions. Earlier submitting a review required you to be logged in. However, I thought that might put off users who didnt want to go to the hassle of signing up with an account. But yes that is something I need to solve. Also, you are correct - there is not much user input validation. So lots of work that needs to be done.

Re: Show HN: LeanReviews - quick reviews for almost anything

#23

Post by sycren » Sun, Apr 28, 2013, 6:23 PM UTC

udayj wrote: post #15

sycren wrote: post #14

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What kind of analysis are you doing so far with it?

Not much presently. Its just restricted to the bar chart. Infact that is mostly another form of visualisation of the content. There isnt much content presently for doing sentiment analysis where you could show a goodness meter for something based on the words being submitted as reviews. I am not finding much time to work on new features between collecting seed content, finding users, getting feedback, etc. Of course,…

I don't really know where you want to go with this project whether its a company or just an interesting side project but I work as a Data Analyst.

Would you like some help analysing the data further? I think it's an interesting project with potential.

Re: Show HN: LeanReviews - quick reviews for almost anything

#24

Post by udayj » Mon, Apr 29, 2013, 5:54 AM UTC

sycren wrote: post #23

udayj wrote: post #15

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Not much presently. Its just restricted to the bar chart. Infact that is mostly another form of visualisation of the content. There isnt much content presently for doing sentiment analysis where you could show a goodness meter for something based on the words being submitted as reviews. I am not finding much time to work on new features between collecting seed content, finding users, getting feedback, etc. Of course,…

I don't really know where you want to go with this project whether its a company or just an interesting side project but I work as a Data Analyst. Would you like some help analysing the data further? I think it's an interesting project with potential.

Its mostly a side project as of now, although I do want to turn it into a venture if possible. I couldnt find your email in your profile. Send me an email and lets discuss what we can do. My email is in my profile. I would be glad to collaborate.