I'm guessing you vibe-coded this and let the model hallucinate the decibel thresholds? I randomly googled a couple (Philly and Fort Worth) and the limits shown in the UI don't match up with any law I could find. Philly doesn't have a specific decibel threshold (the law is based on decibels above standard background noise) and Fort Worth's is 70 / 60, not 60 / 55, with higher limits in non-residential areas. So it's s…
Show HN: Free noise evidence generator for tenant complaints
21–29 of 29 posts
Re: Show HN: Free noise evidence generator for tenant complaints
#22Congratulations on building a nice-looking app that addresses a legitimate need. I'd like to see some proof that this is able to accurately measure noise level across a range of devices. The CDC have a sound meter app [1] which has been tested to 2db accuracy, and they only make that available on specific Apple devices because calculating noise level depends on the hardware. I'm sorry to ask, but I'm seeing many case…
Re: Show HN: Free noise evidence generator for tenant complaints
#23How do you calibrate? I mean, the sensitivity of the microphones varies a lot. Legal proof needs a metrological chain of trust.
Re: Show HN: Free noise evidence generator for tenant complaints
#24I'm guessing you vibe-coded this and let the model hallucinate the decibel thresholds? I randomly googled a couple (Philly and Fort Worth) and the limits shown in the UI don't match up with any law I could find. Philly doesn't have a specific decibel threshold (the law is based on decibels above standard background noise) and Fort Worth's is 70 / 60, not 60 / 55, with higher limits in non-residential areas. So it's s…
Re: Show HN: Free noise evidence generator for tenant complaints
#25Congratulations on building a nice-looking app that addresses a legitimate need. I'd like to see some proof that this is able to accurately measure noise level across a range of devices. The CDC have a sound meter app [1] which has been tested to 2db accuracy, and they only make that available on specific Apple devices because calculating noise level depends on the hardware. I'm sorry to ask, but I'm seeing many case…
In my own reasonableness spot check, what measures as 37dB on my phone is showing as 49dB on my laptop
Re: Show HN: Free noise evidence generator for tenant complaints
#26If I may give constructing feedback then, "noise evidence generator" sounds like you're creating fake noise proof to fool courts. The name needs to be revised. "recorder" might feel less like it's inventing things.
Re: Show HN: Free noise evidence generator for tenant complaints
#27How do we know microphones on different devices are calibrated to record the same power readings? Do you have court-ready documents to show this?
Re: Show HN: Free noise evidence generator for tenant complaints
#28The NIOSH app on my iPhone matches the calibrated meter I have so it’s feasible. However the app has the appearance of vibecoding. The proof of the pudding is in the eating so that doesn’t matter if it works. Have you tried using it?
Re: Show HN: Free noise evidence generator for tenant complaints
#29How do we know microphones on different devices are calibrated to record the same power readings? Do you have court-ready documents to show this?
I've added a calibration feature, hoping it will improve and help.