Live data from Hacker News

Show HN: A roguelike game that runs inside Notepad++

github.com

21–26 of 26 posts

Re: Show HN: A roguelike game that runs inside Notepad++

#21
post #17

It's funny that this roguelike is advertised as a roguelite and most roguelites are advertised as roguelikes.

Yeah, the word "roguelike" seems to have rapidly lost its meaning these past couple of years.

The term for OG roguelikes is the "Berlin interpretation" of roguelikes.

Re: Show HN: A roguelike game that runs inside Notepad++

#22
post #20
post #17

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yeah, the word "roguelike" seems to have rapidly lost its meaning these past couple of years.

Nowadays, roguelike = permadeath + procedural generation, roguelite = roguelike with some elements that carry over the next game. The actual roguelikes that look like Rogue: text based, turn-by-turn dungeon crawlers are often now called "traditional roguelikes". At first glance, it looks like a traditional roguelike, but maybe some elements carry over, putting it in the "roguelite" territory.

What do you mean by "carry over"? Even in Nethack, you can find the graves of previous characters.

Re: Show HN: A roguelike game that runs inside Notepad++

#23
post #19
post #17

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yeah, the word "roguelike" seems to have rapidly lost its meaning these past couple of years.

I played a *lot* of rogue in the early 80s. I can't remember a single game marketed as a "roguelike" that I've played that reminded me of playing rogue.

I haven't played Rogue, but I've played a lot of Moria, Nethack, and AdoM. Those are what I think of when I hear "Roguelike", although even AdoM might be stretching it a bit with its massive non-random outdoor area.

Re: Show HN: A roguelike game that runs inside Notepad++

#24
post #17

It's funny that this roguelike is advertised as a roguelite and most roguelites are advertised as roguelikes.

Yeah, the word "roguelike" seems to have rapidly lost its meaning these past couple of years.

The meaning degraded much earlier than just a couple years ago. People thought it was cool so they latched onto it. It seems like that process started 7-8 years ago, maybe even a bit further back.

Re: Show HN: A roguelike game that runs inside Notepad++

#25
post #17

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yeah, the word "roguelike" seems to have rapidly lost its meaning these past couple of years.

It was always pretty nebulous, relevant video by DoshDoshington https://youtu.be/FT6XfaHgyh0?si=xayqzhkkmYjB4_UC

No, it wasn't always nebulous. Roguelike was a well-established genre for decades before it got hijacked and now means nothing.

Like all genres, games within the roguelike genre (or what some people call "traditional roguelikes") have some variance. But if you played two games in the "traditional roguelike" genre, you'd definitely feel the similarities.

These days if you pick two random games on Steam with the "roguelike" tag, you're going to get two experiences which are not even reminiscent of the other.

Re: Show HN: A roguelike game that runs inside Notepad++

#26
post #17

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yeah, the word "roguelike" seems to have rapidly lost its meaning these past couple of years.

It was always pretty nebulous, relevant video by DoshDoshington https://youtu.be/FT6XfaHgyh0?si=xayqzhkkmYjB4_UC

Great video
Post reply on HN