Live data from Hacker News

Show HN: Windows 7 GUI for the web

khang-nd.github.io

21–30 of 65 posts

Re: Show HN: Windows 7 GUI for the web

#21

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Older people feel exactly the same way about windows2000... or sometimes 98... or 3.1...

more about xp than 2000

For me more about 2000 than XP. 2000 still felt like a Workstation OS and it was very responsive. XP themeing was the first thing I removed once I could not continue on 2000.

Re: Show HN: Windows 7 GUI for the web

#22
post #14

Every time I see something about windows7 coming up, I feel a little sad. 7 imo was the last good windows ms came up with. I remember upgrading to it was something worth bragging to your friends in school. There was so much excitement around it. After 7, something felt, broken, new features felt unnecessary, things got more user hostile, the magic, it was just gone!

Older people feel exactly the same way about windows2000... or sometimes 98... or 3.1...

I used all of those versions but I'd still agree that Win7 was the last good one. I still love the 95/98 aesthetic the most and it's what I try to replicate with my systems now, but the dropoff after Win7 is still much greater.

Re: Show HN: Windows 7 GUI for the web

#23

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Older people feel exactly the same way about windows2000... or sometimes 98... or 3.1...

more about xp than 2000

Yeah, most people wouldn't say that about Win2000, but XP, definitely. XP Service Pack 2 was excellent.

Re: Show HN: Windows 7 GUI for the web

#25
post #4

These visual elements have to be protected by intellectual property somehow. Has Microsoft ever legally persecuted these types of projects before? Or projects built upon such libraries? I'd be wary to build on top of these clones only to receive a cease and desist, but that's a fear of mine, I don't know if it's founded.

It can be more difficult to claim copyright over shapes and patterns than you think.

And somehow Tetris Company succeeded it..

Re: Show HN: Windows 7 GUI for the web

#27

Very nice. Does anybody else find it a bit striking how gracefully this look has aged? With a little bit of tuning it could feel pretty modern. Modern UI design could stand to take not just a few pages but the majority of the book from both the Windows 7 variant of Aero and the OS X 10.9 variant of Aqua, in my opinion. Legibility, information density, and communication of interactability and widget function have all…

I concur, I think the successor flat design trend has nailed on reducing the styling visual clutter and keeping the user just focused on the "substance" from the app UI whilst keeping the UI itself minimal with no distractions.

Re: Show HN: Windows 7 GUI for the web

#28

Very nice. Does anybody else find it a bit striking how gracefully this look has aged? With a little bit of tuning it could feel pretty modern. Modern UI design could stand to take not just a few pages but the majority of the book from both the Windows 7 variant of Aero and the OS X 10.9 variant of Aqua, in my opinion. Legibility, information density, and communication of interactability and widget function have all…

I concur, I think the successor flat design trend has nailed on reducing the styling visual clutter and keeping the user just focused on the "substance" from the app UI whilst keeping the UI itself minimal with no distractions.

The problem is that minimalism and maximalism in UI design exist on a kind of horseshoe curve. Extremely maximalist UI is indeed distracting, but past a certain point of pruning so is minimalism, just in a different way. Instead of having your eyes drawn away from the content by flashy widgets, you’re poking and swiping to find the function you’re looking for, like someone feeling around trying to find the exit in a pitch dark room.

Re: Show HN: Windows 7 GUI for the web

#29
post #14

Every time I see something about windows7 coming up, I feel a little sad. 7 imo was the last good windows ms came up with. I remember upgrading to it was something worth bragging to your friends in school. There was so much excitement around it. After 7, something felt, broken, new features felt unnecessary, things got more user hostile, the magic, it was just gone!

Did you have a Windows 7 Launch Party?

https://gizmodo.com/this-incredible-windows-7-launch-party-v...

Re: Show HN: Windows 7 GUI for the web

#30

Very nice. Does anybody else find it a bit striking how gracefully this look has aged? With a little bit of tuning it could feel pretty modern. Modern UI design could stand to take not just a few pages but the majority of the book from both the Windows 7 variant of Aero and the OS X 10.9 variant of Aqua, in my opinion. Legibility, information density, and communication of interactability and widget function have all…

I used Windows 7 in my formative years, so I'll always have a fond spot in my heart for it.

That said, I really do think the Windows NT era had the best UI in terms of brute usability.

Again, I love Aero's faux glass, cyan highlights, high gloss, etc... but it is indeed a lot of noise and I think it's a bit distracting.

Post reply on HN