Live data from Hacker News

Show HN: Slipshow – A presentation tool not based on slides

github.com

21–30 of 47 posts

Re: Show HN: Slipshow – A presentation tool not based on slides

#21
post #15

Reminds me of Prezi, a lot more than it reminds me of Jupyter notebooks. However, as someone who prefers to create PDF slides using LaTeX instead of PowerPoint, I completely prefer a scriptable tool instead of a web-based tool.

This. It's notebooks as presentations and I'll argue there is nothing about slides that explicitly prevents you from taking this visual approach, but for the case where you want less flexibility it could make sense.

Re: Show HN: Slipshow – A presentation tool not based on slides

#22

I worry this model could lead to a "wall of text" rather than forcing the presenter to be concise, speak to the concepts, and rely more heavily on images. The format is good for academic lecture scenarios but I'd probably just use Jupyter, as noted by others.

Yes, clearly this is not for every usecase. I think math lectures often need quite some text support, they are the reason I created Slipshow.

The timing is super important. Writing on a chalk/whiteboard or overhead takes time, which is required to absorb the content. Hitting the right timing and cues with this approach seems like it would take a lot of practice, which isn't a deal breaker, though I believe the 2 biggest problems with most presentations is too much/too fast content, and not enough practice and this approach might make those both harder, not easier.

Re: Show HN: Slipshow – A presentation tool not based on slides

#23

This immediately reminded me of the "infinite" blackboards we had in some university lecture theatres such that you could just revolve the board surface and keep claiming new writing space (you could also write at a consistent level - no bending / stretching). Something like this: https://www.ragandbonebristol.com/curiosities-1/vintage-wils...

When I was in college they would use a transparency projector, but instead of transparency pages, there would be a roll with a crank that you would turn to advanced the roll. You would get the same effect as slipshow.

...and if they went too fast the hand smudges and wrapping would make previous content indecipherable when they rolled it back :)

Re: Show HN: Slipshow – A presentation tool not based on slides

#26

I worry this model could lead to a "wall of text" rather than forcing the presenter to be concise, speak to the concepts, and rely more heavily on images. The format is good for academic lecture scenarios but I'd probably just use Jupyter, as noted by others.

I get that it’s usually seen as bad practice to write down all the points and read from the slides, but honestly, I like that style sometimes. My monkey brain gets distracted easily, and I often lose track. Having detailed agendas displayed on the screen helps me follow along better.

Re: Show HN: Slipshow – A presentation tool not based on slides

#27
post #26

I worry this model could lead to a "wall of text" rather than forcing the presenter to be concise, speak to the concepts, and rely more heavily on images. The format is good for academic lecture scenarios but I'd probably just use Jupyter, as noted by others.

I get that it’s usually seen as bad practice to write down all the points and read from the slides, but honestly, I like that style sometimes. My monkey brain gets distracted easily, and I often lose track. Having detailed agendas displayed on the screen helps me follow along better.

I especially like it for reading the slides without the video. Oftentimes, the slides for a presentation will be available but a video recording will not be, and having all the information on the slides makes it easier to learn from those presentations.

Of course, the "correct" way to do this would be with "speakers notes", but those seem to often be stripped off of archived presentations for whatever reason.

Re: Show HN: Slipshow – A presentation tool not based on slides

#28

The markdown to presentation approach is great. You can manage your slide (or slips) as code giving you history, offline collaboration, pull requests, etc. I don't think you can do that with most other presentation tools. I've used Marp [1] for traditional slides, and wrote a GitHub template repo that outputs the Marp HTML to GitHub Pages [2]. Similar workflows should be possible for Slipshow. [1] https://marp.app/ […

IA Presenter creates slide decks from markdown:

https://ia.net/presenter

Re: Show HN: Slipshow – A presentation tool not based on slides

#29

The markdown to presentation approach is great. You can manage your slide (or slips) as code giving you history, offline collaboration, pull requests, etc. I don't think you can do that with most other presentation tools. I've used Marp [1] for traditional slides, and wrote a GitHub template repo that outputs the Marp HTML to GitHub Pages [2]. Similar workflows should be possible for Slipshow. [1] https://marp.app/ […

I see a huge markdown fan! I'm on the same page! We're building an entire ecosystem for markdown slides for the same reason.

The same design for all slides in the same workspace, a hosted version for non-developers, each slide has its own public url for easy slide playback, and more ...

Try if you are interested in slidepicker.com (beta)

Post reply on HN