Live data from Hacker News

Show HN: MuscleWiki Workout Generator – Generate unique workouts

musclewiki.com

21–30 of 44 posts

Re: Show HN: MuscleWiki Workout Generator – Generate unique workouts

#21
This is awesome.

After wanting to build up my shoulders, I went to YouTube and looked for exercises. The utter madness I've been served searching for this was staggering. Overhyped bodybuilders promoting pills, fitness influencers, equipment I didn't have, but they knew the best shop for it, etc...

This is clean, straight, I love it.

Starting my workout NOW.

Re: Show HN: MuscleWiki Workout Generator – Generate unique workouts

#22
The muscle group importance weighting seems off. I created a barbell workout for "Chest, Lats, Traps (mid-back), Traps, Forearms, Calves" on beginner and it includes no lifts for pecs, just accessory work like wrist curls and calf raises. Is this because bench press is considered an intermediate lift?

Re: Show HN: MuscleWiki Workout Generator – Generate unique workouts

#23
After inputting your information, why is there a countdown before the results are shown? Surely filtering through a few hundred exercises (being generous here) by muscle group doesn't take 5 seconds? Is a delay being artificially added (eg. [1])?

[1] https://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2017/02/why-s...

Re: Show HN: MuscleWiki Workout Generator – Generate unique workouts

#24
post #23

After inputting your information, why is there a countdown before the results are shown? Surely filtering through a few hundred exercises (being generous here) by muscle group doesn't take 5 seconds? Is a delay being artificially added (eg. [1])? [1] https://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2017/02/why-s...

We have a few reasons. But mostly so if we get hit by reddit again, the site doesn't go down from load.

Re: Show HN: MuscleWiki Workout Generator – Generate unique workouts

#25
post #23

After inputting your information, why is there a countdown before the results are shown? Surely filtering through a few hundred exercises (being generous here) by muscle group doesn't take 5 seconds? Is a delay being artificially added (eg. [1])? [1] https://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2017/02/why-s...

This is always a red flag for me

Re: Show HN: MuscleWiki Workout Generator – Generate unique workouts

#28
In what sense is your workout collection a wiki and how complete is it meant to be?

The bodyweight workouts, for instance, are sparse and rudimentary and the generator comes up with a pretty disjoint and insufficient program at all intensity levels.

That's not to say that you're obliged to replicate Overcoming Gravity or TRX or something, but it's unclear why bodyweight even appears as an option in the genrator at this point, let alone at levels beyond beginner.

If it's not really an expansive wiki and is instead just a collection of your own high-production-value workout descriptions (which seem well made) for contemporary weight training, it makes sense that there's only a narrow "happy path" through the generator -- maybe the presentation should be more focused on that happy path and less overbroad?

Re: Show HN: MuscleWiki Workout Generator – Generate unique workouts

#29
Really awesome and well executed. I'll be using this for sure.

One thing I don't get is that you click a muscle group and sometimes it turns red and sometimes pink. What is the difference? And then I click on the opposite muscle on the back of the body and the front disappears. A bit of twiddling to get it right. Maybe a small animated intro with how to would help here.

Re: Show HN: MuscleWiki Workout Generator – Generate unique workouts

#30

In what sense is your workout collection a wiki and how complete is it meant to be? The bodyweight workouts, for instance, are sparse and rudimentary and the generator comes up with a pretty disjoint and insufficient program at all intensity levels. That's not to say that you're obliged to replicate Overcoming Gravity or TRX or something, but it's unclear why bodyweight even appears as an option in the genrator at th…

What are you trying to say, genuine question.
Post reply on HN