Live data from Hacker News

Show HN: YouTube Shorts Redirector

github.com

21–30 of 54 posts

Re: Show HN: YouTube Shorts Redirector

#21

If you use uBlock Origin, you can also just hide them: https://github.com/gijsdev/ublock-hide-yt-shorts

Thanks, I manually hide them every thirty days because I didn't know that ublock origin can do that, and I didn't want to install an extra add-on just for that (because I hoped that YouTube would some day realise how bad shorts are, and give up on them; wishful thinking, I know).

I think Shorts are great. What is your issue with them?

Re: Show HN: YouTube Shorts Redirector

#22
post #16

Note that YouTube Shorts are just normal YouTube videos on a different URL. This means you can take a link to a Shorts like " rel="nofollow">https://www.youtube.com/shorts/ and change it to " rel="nofollow">https://www.youtube.com/watch?v= . This way, you won't get the dreaded doomscroll interface, and you can also scrub through the video!

Ludicrous that they made such an openly user-hostile interface. Won't show you runtime, won't show you the clip author, just maximally entice the user to click so they get sucked into the infinite dopamine machine. Absolutely unconscionable.

Re: Show HN: YouTube Shorts Redirector

#23
post #17
post #5

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I wrote a userscript that turns the links into a /v/ link. The whole "shorts" concept is sort of stupid. I mean the videos are fine, let people make whatever sort of video they want. the front page promotion is unwanted. But the thing I actively despise is the scrolling auto play interface. However youtube will play the video with a sane interface when the /short/ link is modified into /v/ Or I should say, I nearly w…

A little nitpick, it's ?v= not /v/

shorts have a link like youtube.com/shorts/XXXXXXX changing that to youtube.com/v/XXXXXXX works. and the video is still stupid, but now you have a sane environment to watch it in.

Re: Show HN: YouTube Shorts Redirector

#24
post #16

Note that YouTube Shorts are just normal YouTube videos on a different URL. This means you can take a link to a Shorts like " rel="nofollow">https://www.youtube.com/shorts/ and change it to " rel="nofollow">https://www.youtube.com/watch?v= . This way, you won't get the dreaded doomscroll interface, and you can also scrub through the video!

Plus adjust the volume! Really speaks to the modern state Google's in that they took out their own functionality to more closely clone TikTok, I assume. Paul Graham's got an old quote about what it indicated about Microsoft when they decided to clone Google's business, and it comes to mind every time I see those terrible and vertical thumbnails.

Wait, TikTok doesn't allow you to change the volume? That sure would explain the increase in blaring phones since they became popular with the idiocracy.

Thanks to others who pointed out that uBlock origin can permanently disable (as opposed to being annoyed every 30 days) shorts on YT, instant quality of life improvement.

Re: Show HN: YouTube Shorts Redirector

#25

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Plus adjust the volume! Really speaks to the modern state Google's in that they took out their own functionality to more closely clone TikTok, I assume. Paul Graham's got an old quote about what it indicated about Microsoft when they decided to clone Google's business, and it comes to mind every time I see those terrible and vertical thumbnails.

Wait, TikTok doesn't allow you to change the volume? That sure would explain the increase in blaring phones since they became popular with the idiocracy. Thanks to others who pointed out that uBlock origin can permanently disable (as opposed to being annoyed every 30 days) shorts on YT, instant quality of life improvement.

>Wait, TikTok doesn't allow you to change the volume?

Just a guess from Youtube's shorts not having it. I've never used it.

Re: Show HN: YouTube Shorts Redirector

#26

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Plus adjust the volume! Really speaks to the modern state Google's in that they took out their own functionality to more closely clone TikTok, I assume. Paul Graham's got an old quote about what it indicated about Microsoft when they decided to clone Google's business, and it comes to mind every time I see those terrible and vertical thumbnails.

Wait, TikTok doesn't allow you to change the volume? That sure would explain the increase in blaring phones since they became popular with the idiocracy. Thanks to others who pointed out that uBlock origin can permanently disable (as opposed to being annoyed every 30 days) shorts on YT, instant quality of life improvement.

Regular YouTube videos on mobile also don't allow you to change the volume separate to the phone's 'master volume'. I don't think this is a TikTok/YouTube specific thing - you just don't see separate volume sliders on mobile like you would on a video playing on desktop.

Re: Show HN: YouTube Shorts Redirector

#27

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Wait, TikTok doesn't allow you to change the volume? That sure would explain the increase in blaring phones since they became popular with the idiocracy. Thanks to others who pointed out that uBlock origin can permanently disable (as opposed to being annoyed every 30 days) shorts on YT, instant quality of life improvement.

>Wait, TikTok doesn't allow you to change the volume? Just a guess from Youtube's shorts not having it. I've never used it.

[deleted]

Re: Show HN: YouTube Shorts Redirector

#30
post #21

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Thanks, I manually hide them every thirty days because I didn't know that ublock origin can do that, and I didn't want to install an extra add-on just for that (because I hoped that YouTube would some day realise how bad shorts are, and give up on them; wishful thinking, I know).

I think Shorts are great. What is your issue with them?

Besides the obvious reason that is even stated in the original submission of this article (they way they are presented is made to hack your brain for the dopamine kick and keep scrolling infinitely), there are also the technical aspects (no scrub bar, no volume control, accidentally touch the mouse wheel and you skip to the next video) - and maybe more subjectively: Shorts are about the worst-quality YouTube content there is.
Post reply on HN