Live data from Hacker News

Show HN: Material Files – Open Source Material Design File Manager for Android

github.com

21–30 of 73 posts

Re: Show HN: Material Files – Open Source Material Design File Manager for Android

#21
Used this for years, but after some repressive change to Android I can't access files in the Android/ dir where most apps save their files. Apparently it needs to be rooted for that to work.

So, sadly pointless now. I'm stuck with the default file manager.

Re: Show HN: Material Files – Open Source Material Design File Manager for Android

#23
post #21

Used this for years, but after some repressive change to Android I can't access files in the Android/ dir where most apps save their files. Apparently it needs to be rooted for that to work. So, sadly pointless now. I'm stuck with the default file manager.

I have the same issues. Use Total Commander, it can still access these folders.

Re: Show HN: Material Files – Open Source Material Design File Manager for Android

#24
post #4

I've been using Material Files for a couple years now. I use SMB and SFTP access every day. I also use the FTP server to backup my devices once a month. It's a bit slow but still faster and more reliable than using USB! (I don't know why USB support is so bad on Android, transferring thousands of small files is unbearable. Maybe some devices have better support? Maybe it would work better if I used ADB?) I used to ge…

    I don't know why USB support is so bad on Android, transferring thousands of small files is unbearable. Maybe some devices have better support? Maybe it would work better if I used ADB?
Android abstracts the phone's filesystem as an MTP device, which is terrible when moving a large amount of small files, at least on Windows.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Media_Transfer_Protocol

Re: Show HN: Material Files – Open Source Material Design File Manager for Android

#25
post #12

Supporting Android 5.0+ is impressive, though there was another file manager supporting Android 1.0+ discussed recently https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38789958 (I'm impressed by both, not an Android developer, curious how one ensures compatibility with ancient versions; actual testing, a compatibility linter, other?) I also enjoy Material Files' README, particularly https://github.com/zhanghai/MaterialFiles#why…

> curious how one ensures compatibility with ancient versions; actual testing, a compatibility linter, other? Android linter does check that access to APIs added in newer versions is gated behind a version check, for example. But frankly I feel like compatibility with any Android version less than 4 (or even 5) is in practice a non-issue, simply because there are no users with such ancient Android. And the few that w…

My Samsung Galaxy Tab 2 7.0" runs Android 4.2, and I use it to watch videos and play music when practicing piano or exercising

Re: Show HN: Material Files – Open Source Material Design File Manager for Android

#26

Switched to this when Simple File Manager went bust. It's wayy better, in terms of design, features, and user experience. I love the file move flow being presented as cut&paste, and other unique tidbits.

What happened to Simple File Manager? I'm using it currently and I don't see a problem with it.

Re: Show HN: Material Files – Open Source Material Design File Manager for Android

#27
post #3

This has been my go to file manager for years. It is the first thing I install on a new phone. It can even mount network file systems like ftp, sftp, and smb. I use the sftp and it works really well all things considered. edit: double bonus points because it is available on the privacy centric/open source app store Fdroid.

I second this

Re: Show HN: Material Files – Open Source Material Design File Manager for Android

#28
post #21

Used this for years, but after some repressive change to Android I can't access files in the Android/ dir where most apps save their files. Apparently it needs to be rooted for that to work. So, sadly pointless now. I'm stuck with the default file manager.

Idk why but android just does that for some reason

Re: Show HN: Material Files – Open Source Material Design File Manager for Android

#29

Switched to this when Simple File Manager went bust. It's wayy better, in terms of design, features, and user experience. I love the file move flow being presented as cut&paste, and other unique tidbits.

What happened to Simple File Manager? I'm using it currently and I don't see a problem with it.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38505229

Re: Show HN: Material Files – Open Source Material Design File Manager for Android

#30
post #25
post #12

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> curious how one ensures compatibility with ancient versions; actual testing, a compatibility linter, other? Android linter does check that access to APIs added in newer versions is gated behind a version check, for example. But frankly I feel like compatibility with any Android version less than 4 (or even 5) is in practice a non-issue, simply because there are no users with such ancient Android. And the few that w…

My Samsung Galaxy Tab 2 7.0" runs Android 4.2, and I use it to watch videos and play music when practicing piano or exercising

I'm not saying _nobody_ uses those devices, I'm just saying they're sufficiently old that saying _my app supports Android 3.x_ is moot, because the usage on that API will be near 0 anyway, so you never really know if you _support_ that version outside of any testing that you might be doing. Android 4 and lower have estimated share of 0.3%-0.7% depending on a source ([1], [2]). Of course HN users will be more likely to have those devices too. And then of 0.5% users that maybe will install the app some will have no issues, some will have issues but not notice, some will notice but not bother reporting.

[1] https://apilevels.com/ [2] https://www.composables.com/tools/distribution-chart

Post reply on HN