Hacker News Board Hacker News, browsed like a classic message board
Live data from Hacker News

Show HN: WhyBot, making GPT-4 question itself

whybot-khaki.vercel.app

Post reply on HN
Print view View original

21–30 of 34 posts

Re: Show HN: WhyBot, making GPT-4 question itself

#21

Post by ShamelessC »

jiggawatts wrote: post #13
ranguna wrote: post #5

This is incredibly! I've been benchmarking several LLMs to identify a possible bug in a snippet of code given no context on what is expected from the code. Neither chatgpt, vacuna, open assistant or mpt where able to identify the bug. When I fed the same prompt into this app, the initial reply said there were no bugs, but the first branch immenditly questioned itself with the expected line of thought to identify the…

No need for complicated multi-step apps, GPT 4 can find the bug straight-up: The code snippet you provided is syntactically correct TypeScript code. However, there might be a logical issue depending on the intended use case. The code is set up to iterate over the queuePositions array and slice it into pairs, but if the queuePositions array contains an odd number of elements, the final pair will contain only a single…

ChatGPT (3.5-turbo) also provides a similar response:

"As an AI language model, I cannot guarantee the correctness of the code, but I could not find any obvious bugs in the given code snippet. However, here are a few observations:

- The queuePositions array must contain an even number of elements for this code to work correctly. - pairs is initialized as an empty array of arrays, where each inner array will contain exactly two numbers. - The for loop iterates through queuePositions array in steps of 2, taking two consecutive elements from the array each time starting from index i. - The slice method extracts a portion of the original queuePositions array starting at index i and ending at i + 2, but not including i + 2. - The extracted portion is pushed to the pairs array. - The resulting pairs array will contain pairs of numbers from queuePositions."

Re: Show HN: WhyBot, making GPT-4 question itself

#22

Post by gremlinsinc »

pmoriarty wrote: post #11

Interesting, but I've found the questions it asks are all pretty conventional and run-of-the-mill, and I wish it would stay on topic for follow-up questions, rather than veering off on barely related tangents.

I think adding some sort of ability to alter the way it forms follow up questions would 10x the outputs.

Re: Show HN: WhyBot, making GPT-4 question itself

#25

Post by vishrajiv »

apineda wrote: post #23

Would be cool if you could nix ( delete ) nodes that you don't wish to pursue. Very nice execution!

Vish here — you can! It’s easier on desktop but if you hover over edges, they turn red and the pointer turns into a scissor so you can prune that entire downstream branch.

Re: Show HN: WhyBot, making GPT-4 question itself

#27

Post by ranguna »

ShamelessC wrote: post #21
jiggawatts wrote: post #13

Earlier quoted context omitted.

No need for complicated multi-step apps, GPT 4 can find the bug straight-up: The code snippet you provided is syntactically correct TypeScript code. However, there might be a logical issue depending on the intended use case. The code is set up to iterate over the queuePositions array and slice it into pairs, but if the queuePositions array contains an odd number of elements, the final pair will contain only a single…

ChatGPT (3.5-turbo) also provides a similar response: "As an AI language model, I cannot guarantee the correctness of the code, but I could not find any obvious bugs in the given code snippet. However, here are a few observations: - The queuePositions array must contain an even number of elements for this code to work correctly. - pairs is initialized as an empty array of arrays, where each inner array will contain e…

Every single time chatgpt 3.5 told me there were no issues. So even if you got a good response out of it, it might have been just luck.

Re: Show HN: WhyBot, making GPT-4 question itself

#28

Post by ranguna »

jiggawatts wrote: post #13
ranguna wrote: post #5

This is incredibly! I've been benchmarking several LLMs to identify a possible bug in a snippet of code given no context on what is expected from the code. Neither chatgpt, vacuna, open assistant or mpt where able to identify the bug. When I fed the same prompt into this app, the initial reply said there were no bugs, but the first branch immenditly questioned itself with the expected line of thought to identify the…

No need for complicated multi-step apps, GPT 4 can find the bug straight-up: The code snippet you provided is syntactically correct TypeScript code. However, there might be a logical issue depending on the intended use case. The code is set up to iterate over the queuePositions array and slice it into pairs, but if the queuePositions array contains an odd number of elements, the final pair will contain only a single…

Shame it's not publicly available.

Re: Show HN: WhyBot, making GPT-4 question itself

#29

Post by ranguna »

ranguna wrote: post #27
ShamelessC wrote: post #21

Earlier quoted context omitted.

ChatGPT (3.5-turbo) also provides a similar response: "As an AI language model, I cannot guarantee the correctness of the code, but I could not find any obvious bugs in the given code snippet. However, here are a few observations: - The queuePositions array must contain an even number of elements for this code to work correctly. - pairs is initialized as an empty array of arrays, where each inner array will contain e…

Every single time chatgpt 3.5 told me there were no issues. So even if you got a good response out of it, it might have been just luck.

And I just got a good result off of gpt 3.5 and 4.

3.5 turbo:

The code snippet seems to be correct and there are no obvious bugs. It initializes an array of queue positions, and then creates pairs of adjacent positions using a for loop and slice method. The resulting pairs are pushed into a 2D array. However, it is worth noting that the last pair may only contain one element if the length of the array is odd.

4:

The given TypeScript code snippet seems to be correct and has no syntax errors. It initializes an array queuePositions with three elements (1, 2, and 3) and an empty array pairs. The for loop iterates through queuePositions with a step of 2, slices the array from the current index to the next index, and pushes the sliced subarray into the pairs array. After running the code, the pairs array will be [[1, 2], [3]].

However, it's important to note that the last element of queuePositions will be in an array by itself in pairs array since the loop has a step of 2. If this is the intended behavior, then the code is correct. If you want all elements in pairs to have the same length, you may need to handle the case where the length of queuePositions is odd.

Maybe the tool proposed by the OP just improves the probability of getting a good result. Which is quite good IMHO.

Re: Show HN: WhyBot, making GPT-4 question itself

#30

Post by flangola7 »

IndigoIncognito wrote: post #20
flangola7 wrote: post #16

Earlier quoted context omitted.

My firewall does not enjoy this link.

Sorry guys I didn't realise it did this, I have Firefox with a bunch of privacy extensions which block popup's, time to look for a new image hoster

The DNS request was blocked well before ad pop-ups, just look at any domain checking sore. The final destination was cognitohazards, a hotel
Post reply on HN