Live data from Hacker News

Show HN: Redirect your customers from your marketing page to your app

news.ycombinator.com

21–30 of 30 posts

Re: Show HN: Redirect your customers from your marketing page to your app

#21
We redirect on login - the login link is available from either domain, and once you login the first time, we prompt to ask where you want to go in the future. Most people choose to be taken to the app, but some stick to the marketing site. And the link to your app is always in the main navigation once logged in.

It is fairly simple code, so I'm not sure this is a problem that needs a productized solution.

Re: Show HN: Redirect your customers from your marketing page to your app

#22

I personally totally hate that idea. I hate it when I can’t open main page for the product to check on pricing, watch for new features or just show it to someone else. I just get redirected to the app and need to find a hacky way to go back. What is the real problem here, in my opinion, is that the home pages of the apps are not even slightly focused on existing customers. Login buttons are small and hidden, or there…

I'm in the same boat. Whenever a page tries to redirect me to some application when I didn't tell it to, I'm sure to just leave and not use the product/page. Its not worth the annoyance to me

Re: Show HN: Redirect your customers from your marketing page to your app

#23

Target the people who use Wordpress for marketing, but otherwise have an app. They might pay $5 for this, especially if they are separate business silos. As long as it is super simple to use, this could be a decent non-technical solution to a technical problem. The challenge is once someone technical is called in, they will realize that this is trivial, so making it possible for non-technicals to easily use (even if…

Great idea. Thanks!

Re: Show HN: Redirect your customers from your marketing page to your app

#27

I personally totally hate that idea. I hate it when I can’t open main page for the product to check on pricing, watch for new features or just show it to someone else. I just get redirected to the app and need to find a hacky way to go back. What is the real problem here, in my opinion, is that the home pages of the apps are not even slightly focused on existing customers. Login buttons are small and hidden, or there…

I think a nice feature of the thing I made is a button that lets users opt in to the redirect. I agree that it would be bad UX to prevent your paying customers from seeing the marketing page if they wanted to.

Re: Show HN: Redirect your customers from your marketing page to your app

#28
post #9

This is useful as a reminder to make it easier for existing users to find your app. Also, the marketing site being outside of reach of the app dev team is a real problem worth addressing with convenient snippets such as the linked solution. That said, I'm still not convinced that an automatic redirect is a good idea. I've had cases where I would like to refer someone to e.g. the pricing page (or a page I remember abo…

Yea I agree. For some reason marketing teams love to make the "log in" link tiny, if they include it at all.

Re: Show HN: Redirect your customers from your marketing page to your app

#29
post #5

I don't understand why you can't type the address of the page you want to go to, or click a link to get there (or provide a link if you're the website owner)? It looks like you're forcing people to go to a page other than the one you select, but that would be really crap, so it can't be that ... so what are you doing? Makes no sense to me, but then I hate websites that want me to install a wrapper around a web render…

The thing I made is an opt-in redirect. If you don't want to be redirected from marketing -> app, then you wouldn't click the "Always go to app" button. No content wrapping, no installations, no change in behavior for anyone who doesn't opt in to the redirect. I made it because I often think "I'd like to see how my CI is doing", and then I type "circleci.com", and land on their marketing page instead of the app dashboard at "app.circleci.com".

Re: Show HN: Redirect your customers from your marketing page to your app

#30
post #10
post #5

I don't understand why you can't type the address of the page you want to go to, or click a link to get there (or provide a link if you're the website owner)? It looks like you're forcing people to go to a page other than the one you select, but that would be really crap, so it can't be that ... so what are you doing? Makes no sense to me, but then I hate websites that want me to install a wrapper around a web render…

Yeah, very good point.. I can no longer view https://elliotplant.com/marketing-redirect/ because I'm instantly forced away every time.

Did you try clicking the "Disable marketing redirect" button? That removes the redirect.
Post reply on HN