Live data from Hacker News

Show HN: WebCatalog – turn websites into desktop apps

webcatalog.app

21–30 of 42 posts

Re: Show HN: WebCatalog – turn websites into desktop apps

#21
post #7

1. Open any site. 2. Click on menu option at the top right of your browser. 3. Add to home screen (select open as window)

Am I missing something? My desktop computer doesn't have a "home screen" and I don't see anything like this option in Chrome or Firefox.

Re: Show HN: WebCatalog – turn websites into desktop apps

#22
post #15

Earlier quoted context omitted.

"Install as app" works for any page.

Is the wording 'Install as app' on all pages on edge? Other browsers show 'Install as app' only for PWA and 'add to home screen' for normal websites.

Edge doesn't show 'Install as app' in address bar but if you go to menu > apps there will be 'Install this site as an app'. I'm using apps for Duolingo, Ventusky, Airly, Livescore, Plaza One, Poolside FM. I even tried to make an app for this website and it worked.

https://imgur.com/a/2OcJOfp

Re: Show HN: WebCatalog – turn websites into desktop apps

#24
post #21
post #7

1. Open any site. 2. Click on menu option at the top right of your browser. 3. Add to home screen (select open as window)

Am I missing something? My desktop computer doesn't have a "home screen" and I don't see anything like this option in Chrome or Firefox.

I think it only shows for pages with a manifest file (pwa) and I've only seen it in chrome as well.

Re: Show HN: WebCatalog – turn websites into desktop apps

#27

How does this compare to the below? google-chrome --app= https://example.com firefox --ssb= https://example.com

Hi everyone, it's Quang from WebCatalog, Certainly, if the built-in "install-as-app" of major browsers work well for you, then it's great. WebCatalog tries to make the concept simpler and more accessible to average users. Most people are familiar with the concepts of apps and app stores so our vision is to build an app store for web apps that gives users easy access to desktop apps (many not available elsewhere). A u…

Looking at the size of your catalog I'm going to guess that you didn't work with all those sites to distribute their apps through your site. Maybe I'm not understanding how this works, but wouldn't you need some sort of license to do this? If someone downloads the Gmail app from your catalog, but it doesn't work the same as the plain web client, they would probably blame Google and not you. I can't imagine Google would like that.

Re: Show HN: WebCatalog – turn websites into desktop apps

#28
post #21
post #7

1. Open any site. 2. Click on menu option at the top right of your browser. 3. Add to home screen (select open as window)

Am I missing something? My desktop computer doesn't have a "home screen" and I don't see anything like this option in Chrome or Firefox.

Firefox currently only has it as an experimental feature which you have to enable manually in about:config. I would have to say it still lacks a bit of polish. You can find it by searching for firefox ssb.

https://www.maketecheasier.com/enable-site-specific-browser-...

Re: Show HN: WebCatalog – turn websites into desktop apps

#29
post #6

This is trying to sell the concept of a chrome-less browser-window ("install as app"), a feature your browser already has.

Do we need to link to that famous Dropbox comment again? Sometimes convenience can be enough.

I think one big problem with this approach is that if the people behind this find a niche good enough its very easy for browsers to just implement the new ideas and completely kill the competition giving everyone has a deployed browser already.

Im doing something that is based on browsers for instance, but the end product diverge quite a bit from traditional browsers and if they try to play the catchup game, i have at least a 2-year window of opportunity.

Remember PhantomJS? And Phantom was actually providing something browsers were not doing at the time.

It has no real distinct features from what browsers already do right now, and whatever way they make it easy to use, if the product by some change get traction, it will be easy for them to just ship with that feature built it.

It may provide some value on convenience, but its easily copiable by a competitor that is deployed everywhere, which is a big threat to their bussiness model.

Re: Show HN: WebCatalog – turn websites into desktop apps

#30
post #6

This is trying to sell the concept of a chrome-less browser-window ("install as app"), a feature your browser already has.

Do we need to link to that famous Dropbox comment again? Sometimes convenience can be enough.

Unrelated to the parent comment, but what is this Dropbox comment?
Post reply on HN