Live data from Hacker News

Show HN: Markdeck – author cool slides, text-only, offline-ready, collaborative

github.com

21–30 of 94 posts

Re: Show HN: Markdeck – author cool slides, text-only, offline-ready, collaborative

#21
post #18

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Can it really not include images in the output though? I didn't see an example in the showcase.

The word cloud and the stick figure are taken from the `assets/img` folder; you can reference ANY file you want, as long as it is located somewhere within the `assets` folder.

That sounds great, thanks! I'll try it right away.

Re: Show HN: Markdeck – author cool slides, text-only, offline-ready, collaborative

#24

Extremely low-quality project. The only things I care about in presentation software are: a) How do I export the presentation to some other computer? b) Will it even work on their ad-hoc configuration of hardware and software? Everything else is a distant second consideration. The JS framework used under the hood is like #100 on the list of things I care about.

This is a classic HN comment. Contempt which turns out to be grounded in "I have an esoteric priority which is different from that of the author."

Anyway, it exports pdf.

Re: Show HN: Markdeck – author cool slides, text-only, offline-ready, collaborative

#25
post #23

"text-only" is a good description of bad slides to me. Why do people do that? The are plenty of Markdown slides tools so there seems to be a need.

Text heavy slide creation tools (such as LaTeX and Markdown based ones) are aimed to make slide creation easier, not actually watching the resulting presentation. It's not to say that you cannot make nice slides with those tools, but using systems that make it much easier to write text than to visualize really promotes the wrong thing for presentations.

People don't tend to notice this as much though, and they are more concerned with familiarity or speed-of-production of the slides rather than make the slides effective for the audience. But hey, that same issue can be raised for most PowerPoint presentations, too. People just don't know how to make good slides and just take whatever is easiest for them.

Re: Show HN: Markdeck – author cool slides, text-only, offline-ready, collaborative

#26
post #23

"text-only" is a good description of bad slides to me. Why do people do that? The are plenty of Markdown slides tools so there seems to be a need.

This does allow you to embed images and diagrams. I think they rather mean the slide description language is text-only.

But even embedded images implies uninspiring slides to me.

For example they have a system that allows you to add source code to a slide, but then don't you want to be annotating that code? Adding arrows, lines, highlighting bits, breaking it apart, etc?

Re: Show HN: Markdeck – author cool slides, text-only, offline-ready, collaborative

#28
post #23

"text-only" is a good description of bad slides to me. Why do people do that? The are plenty of Markdown slides tools so there seems to be a need.

"text-only" here means, that the _source_ of the slides is text-based (in contrast to the classic graphical tools like powerpoint or pages).

the resulting slides can be as colourful (and text-less) as you want...

Re: Show HN: Markdeck – author cool slides, text-only, offline-ready, collaborative

#29
post #23

"text-only" is a good description of bad slides to me. Why do people do that? The are plenty of Markdown slides tools so there seems to be a need.

This is something that I've been intrigued about too. Most of the cli/text based creation tools out there focus on text based content as well. But, for many people myself included, the desire is really for a text based creation tool that focuses on image or diagram based output. Features like auto tiling (with priority) of images on a slide would be useful.

So many people end up writing what should be their presentation notes as their slide content. Personally I think you're better off with a holding image and move your content to the presenter notes section.

I've used revealjs.com and hovercraft [1] in the past but usually end up on GSuite Slides to throw things together quickly. Slides (like PowerPoint) can't do branching presentation paths though :(

[1] https://github.com/regebro/hovercraft

Re: Show HN: Markdeck – author cool slides, text-only, offline-ready, collaborative

#30
post #24

Extremely low-quality project. The only things I care about in presentation software are: a) How do I export the presentation to some other computer? b) Will it even work on their ad-hoc configuration of hardware and software? Everything else is a distant second consideration. The JS framework used under the hood is like #100 on the list of things I care about.

This is a classic HN comment. Contempt which turns out to be grounded in "I have an esoteric priority which is different from that of the author." Anyway, it exports pdf.

> Contempt which turns out to be grounded in "I have an esoteric priority which is different from that of the author."

Not contempt. Instead of a lukewarm indifference-couched-in-praise, I'm giving you real feedback. People should cherish that. (I know I do.)

My priority isn't esoteric, it's the priority of 99.9% of those doing slide presentations. For the vast majority of people the problem they need solved is "will this work on their junk setup I first saw five minutes ago", not graphviz integration.

> Anyway, it exports pdf.

If so, this should be point #1 on your README, in big bold letters. In reality, of course, there's caveats, and the exported PDF will mostly fail in real-world conditions.

This is not surprising: the priorities are off, the features tested aren't the ones that need testing, and so the tool isn't solving the problem that really needs to be solved.

Again, please don't take this as contempt. Best wishes and I hope you set your priorities in order.

Post reply on HN