Live data from Hacker News

Show HN: Obsidian for Mobile – Plain-text knowledge base on the go

obsidian.md

181–190 of 329 posts

Re: Show HN: Obsidian for Mobile – Plain-text knowledge base on the go

#182

Obsidian has really delivered in a crowded note-taking space by focusing on the fundamentals: 1. Privacy. You can roll your own syncing (or use iCloud, Dropbox, etc.), without the notes being stored on the note editors' servers, which is a huge win over Roam, Notion, Evernote, etc. After the Evernote fiasco from a few years ago (where they considered reading your notes for ML model training and got massive pushback),…

> Speaking of future-proofing, Markdown is as close as it gets to having interoperability with the notes. Obsidian is at its core just a Markdown file editor, which means your notes are stored as plaintext and easy to export. There is a bit of Obsidian-flavored syntax (e.g. bi-directional links [[...]]), but these are becoming standard in note-taking. Many note-taking apps claim export functionality, but at the end of the day they're not incentivized to give you your data in a format that will work with other editors.

This is actually the reason I don't use Obsidian. It's built on markdown, but it is not markdown. Things may be different now, but when I gave up on Obsidian, there was no general purpose exporter - you either use their editor or you lose much of the useful information in your notes. This would not by itself be a big problem except for the fact that Obsidian is a standard piece of proprietary software. It genuinely solves nothing in regard to future proofing.

Re: Show HN: Obsidian for Mobile – Plain-text knowledge base on the go

#183
post #178

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Confirming: Working Copy is _itself_ amazing, and solves the syncing-obsidian-to-github-on-ios problem.

That sounds very intriguing. How does syncing work in practice, though? Do you have to remember to manually trigger commits/syncing or can you set it to commit/sync automatically (e.g., after a short period of inactivity)?

I haven't looked into any automation options, but I doubt it. Seems like Working Copy takes a specified folder in the "Files" app and treats it as a git repo (in this case, the Obsidian/YourVaultHere folder). When you launch Working Copy you're basically sitting at a (very nice) git UI, so all the standard git workflows are present.

I'm used to using a variety of editing software and then manually pushing my notes repo, so the lack of automatic syncing doesn't bother me. In fact, I prefer it. I've been burned by auto-syncing before and it makes me nervous.

Re: Show HN: Obsidian for Mobile – Plain-text knowledge base on the go

#185

Obsidian is the closest thing I've found to the Pensive from Harry Potter. It's a data recording format good enough for me to extract thoughts from my mind, represent them with enough fidelity to reconstruct later, connect them to the concepts that they are related to in my head, and then forget the thought completely so I can move on and process it later. I was only willing to try it out because I had heard it menti…

You’re right it was on Cortex, clarification though: Grey loves Obsidian, Mike doesn’t really get it though. Neither like Notion, even though it has a massive fan base. There is a whole episode (maybe the one in question) where it comes to light that Grey has spent most of his life NOT making notes like most people do and instead just highlighting areas in source material and referring back to it. Very funny episode…

I think this is the episode you are reffering to? https://www.relay.fm/cortex/105

Re: Show HN: Obsidian for Mobile – Plain-text knowledge base on the go

#186

Has anyone used Joplin ( https://joplinapp.org/ )? How does it compare to Obsidian? I've used Joplin for a while. It's Markdown so I like it. The UI is dry (compared to Evernote).

I've been using Joplin heavily for a few months. That is likely to come to an end, though, as it hasn't been syncing to OneDrive properly. Some notes simply will not sync even if I click the button manually. Then there's the web clipper that has stopped working. And a variety of other small issues. I was really happy with it for a while.

Re: Show HN: Obsidian for Mobile – Plain-text knowledge base on the go

#187
I originally switched to Obsidian for the vim bindings, and it's been solid. My only major issue with it was a lack of ability to edit things on mobile (using drop box app to edit markdown files was OK but def. not great).

I generally need simple things on the go, like checking off an item on a to-do list. Almost built my own mini-markdown viewer/editor to do this myself but glad I didn't as now this mobile app totally solves my issue. Great update, thanks!

Re: Show HN: Obsidian for Mobile – Plain-text knowledge base on the go

#188
post #33

I've picked up studying math. Right now I'm using "plain" markdown, but I'm starting to struggle with writing down formulas. Is this something that Obsidian (or something related) support well?

My notes are pretty math-heavy, and for that reason I really prefer WYSIWYG rather than a split view or staring at the LaTeX source most of the time. Something like the Typora editor on top of Obsidian would be great. If only both were open source! I've been hacking on my own clone [1] for the past year with a WYSIWYG editor based on ProseMirror. Here's the demo page [2] for the math editor! [1] https://github.com/be…

Typora UI emulation is one of the devs' top to-dos, and I've found they move remarkably fast on these things, so stay tuned... (EDIT: Fair point re: open source, though I find the use of Markdown and easy exportability mitigating.)

Re: Show HN: Obsidian for Mobile – Plain-text knowledge base on the go

#189
post #78

Joplin and you will not look father. https://joplinapp.org/

I would agree father, but I was using Joplin and then switched to Obsidian.

Joplin is no slouch and no shade on anyone who uses it, but here's why I am happy I made the switch.

- Backlinks (Linked and Unlinked Mentions) are the super power of Obsidian. (Roam and others can do what I will describe, but I'm not aware that Joplin can.)

  - Being able to see everywhere I linked to my current note in my 1500+ other notes is  super helpful.   Having used Obsidian for over a year,  I couldn't count the amount of helpful connections this has created and news trains of thought this has led me down. 

  - Unlinked mentions takes this to the next level since I can take a note that is where I have developed a core idea that I want to propagate throughout my thinking.  By taking that core note and naming it properly or giving it an alias, in Unlinked mentions I often find dozens and dozens of places where I interact with this idea as a tangent before I developed this core note.  (And sometimes after, too.)  So when I return to ideas that are still in the sandbox and trying to be figured out, Unlinked Mentions sometimes lets me connect the new intellectual "key" to a "lock" that I had been frustrated with in the past.      

 - Obsidian's links and files work are consistent with Markdown spec, so they're more portable than with Joplin.  I can easily move from Obsidian to most other platforms, but when leaving Joplin, tags don't always migrate very well.  
- YMMV on Obsidian's plug-ins, but the community has built tools that really are super helpful.

- The Table Editor is fantastic for creating and manipulating tables in Markdown.

- The Dataview plugin that allows you to dynamically generate tables based on metadata fields you create for each note. I find this particularly useful for notes on other works.

- You can Tweet directly from Obsidian and also draw within Obsidian using plugins. Maybe it's been too long since I used Joplin, but those weren't options that I was aware of. And the list of plugins is more than 200.

- The search is the best I've used on any *note-taking* platform. I'm sure there are better options in code editors, but for someone on the less technical side of things, it's usable for them, but it allows regex, expanding context surrounding matches, and a host of other options.

Re: Show HN: Obsidian for Mobile – Plain-text knowledge base on the go

#190

Strong recommendation for both Obsidian and Dynalist, the other product of this crazy productive duo. I really appreciate their understanding that users want to be able customize their note-taking/life-organizing system. Is there a plugin or something that enables list folding in a markdown file? I'm wondering whether it's time to migrate the Dynalist parts of my system to Obsidian and that's the big thing I'd miss.

Yup. It's called Outliner.

Link to outline https://github.com/vslinko/obsidian-outliner
Post reply on HN