Live data from Hacker News

Show HN: Dark Reader extension – Dark mode for every website

darkreader.org

161–170 of 180 posts

Re: Show HN: Dark Reader extension – Dark mode for every website

#161
post #89

Does anyone actually prefer reading text on a bright background? If so, what are your reasons? For me, the choice is obvious to the point that I'm often annoyed at the lengths I need to go to in order to browse the web comfortably. I feel like we should have moved to the sane default of dark-themed UI ages ago.

In dark environments, dark UIs are easy on the eyes.

In light environments, dark UIs get washed out and are illegible.

Re: Show HN: Dark Reader extension – Dark mode for every website

#162
post #136

I’ve also written a similar addon, although much simpler, using static css filters: https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/dark-mode-night-re... https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/dark-mode-nig... https://gitlab.com/o9000/darken It has 4 presets that can be configured per domain. I’ve added by hand rules to fix inverted images on some popular websites. YouTube is a pain to maintain, they keep changing…

This actually seems better (more lightweight and easier to read dark colors schemes) then the Dark Reader extension.

Thanks. I use it myself so I tried hard to make it work well.

Re: Show HN: Dark Reader extension – Dark mode for every website

#164
This is really neat! Have left it going all day and it’s quite an improvement.

That said, what it’s really done for me is remind me of how much I miss Nocturne: https://github.com/strider72/blacktree-nocturne (but originally from Blacktree, the original publisher of Quicksilver). Even the Github version linked there is long abandoned, so hard to try on for yourself—but the monochrome inverted night mode was far and away the best late night coding environment I’ve tested my eyes on.

Re: Show HN: Dark Reader extension – Dark mode for every website

#165
post #163

I like it, but in permissions it says: "This add-on can: Access your data for all websites" This doesn't sound good, I wouldn't like to allow an extension to access my data in bank websites.

I've developed a few Chrome extensions myself - it needs that to work. The only way to make it work is to injecting a script into your current webpage, which changes the appearance. Unfortunately there is no way to also disable the network connections of that script so it could hypothetically contact another website and leak your data - note it cannot leak cookies if they are HTTP only, but this depends on your sensitive website's web developer being competent.

You must also trust the dependencies of the application as well - refreshingly there is only one called malevic [0], which itself has no dependencies.

My impression is that the author of this extension is genuinely just trying to make something good for the benefit of the community but it's not as though Chrome extensions haven't been purchased before. Also we must trust that the published extension is the same as the extension in the Github repository, I don't know of a way to verify this.

The only way to probably be safe is to audit the source code yourself and install it in development mode. Or just use a different profile for truly sensitive stuff vs just casual browsing.

[0] https://github.com/alexanderby/malevic

Re: Show HN: Dark Reader extension – Dark mode for every website

#166
post #89

Does anyone actually prefer reading text on a bright background? If so, what are your reasons? For me, the choice is obvious to the point that I'm often annoyed at the lengths I need to go to in order to browse the web comfortably. I feel like we should have moved to the sane default of dark-themed UI ages ago.

I still remember when I went from using MS-DOS to Windows 3.1. The black background of MS-DOS was pleasing, whereas Windows was too bright on the eyes.

Re: Show HN: Dark Reader extension – Dark mode for every website

#167

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Firefox add-ons pass full source code review before the submission after the Stylish incident. Safari extensions also pass manual review, Apple asks developer to send an ID card photo. Not sure about Chrome, you have to simply trust me, the code is not obfuscated and you can always locate the files and see what the extension does in your browser. Google recently announced some security changes https://blog.chromium.o…

Is that really true? I was really alarmed when this extension requested access to all websites and added a ton of obfuscated code with the latest version for no apparent reason: https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/restore-old-t... I've reported it, but nothing seems to happen.

yes. to submit to firefox you’re required to provide them with the source code, but you may transpile it so long as they can verify that it’s the same AFAIK?

Re: Show HN: Dark Reader extension – Dark mode for every website

#168
I seriously just started using this extension a few days ago, after getting tired of toggling my Chromebook's invert colors setting on and off several times a night.

Thanks for building a great extension! I plan on keeping this installed for a long time :)

Re: Show HN: Dark Reader extension – Dark mode for every website

#169
post #115
post #89

Does anyone actually prefer reading text on a bright background? If so, what are your reasons? For me, the choice is obvious to the point that I'm often annoyed at the lengths I need to go to in order to browse the web comfortably. I feel like we should have moved to the sane default of dark-themed UI ages ago.

Honest question: how well-lit is the area you use your computer in, and have you tried turning down your monitor's brightness? I'm as baffled by the popularity of dark themes as you are with light themes, but I'm sitting in a fairly bright room with natural light and a monitor at 35% brightness. In these conditions dark-on-light and light-on-dark text are equally pleasant to read, and I opt for light themes when give…

> have you tried turning down your monitor's brightness?

Not all content is too bright and white. Videos for example playing at full screen, I would not want reduced brightness for. It's the bright 100% white background of websites on a large monitor that is not comfortable.

Also most monitors have annoying UX for adjusting brightness, requiring two presses of tiny unmarked buttons to get to menu then change brightness.

I was very pleased when Youtube added their nightmode feature, which I leave on always.

Re: Show HN: Dark Reader extension – Dark mode for every website

#170
post #115

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Honest question: how well-lit is the area you use your computer in, and have you tried turning down your monitor's brightness? I'm as baffled by the popularity of dark themes as you are with light themes, but I'm sitting in a fairly bright room with natural light and a monitor at 35% brightness. In these conditions dark-on-light and light-on-dark text are equally pleasant to read, and I opt for light themes when give…

It really bugs me for my monitor to not be at or near max brightness because of how terrible the colors look at low brightness, even on high end IPS panels. This isn’t an issue on my OLED phone, which has great colors even at the lowest brightness, but nobody makes 27” OLED monitors and if they did they’d be prohibitively expensive.

Man I would pay a lot for 15-17" MacBook (or properly supported Linux machine) with proper OLED screen (from what I read the already discontinued Lenovo's suck at direct sun).
Post reply on HN