Many others have said it already, but I'll say it again: 1. You have a fantastic product 2. Many potential users won't accept to have their documents stored "in the cloud" (even though those same users share those same documents by email with zero security, all the time) 3. Offer a stand alone version and sell a licence (or a rent, think the former Google Search Appliance) 4. Charge an arm and a leg for it -- think O…
Show HN: Version Control for Microsoft Word
111–118 of 118 posts
Re: Show HN: Version Control for Microsoft Word
#112Re: Show HN: Version Control for Microsoft Word
#113Many others have said it already, but I'll say it again: 1. You have a fantastic product 2. Many potential users won't accept to have their documents stored "in the cloud" (even though those same users share those same documents by email with zero security, all the time) 3. Offer a stand alone version and sell a licence (or a rent, think the former Google Search Appliance) 4. Charge an arm and a leg for it -- think O…
6. Realise that you've recreated a feature that already exists natively in word... Doh!
Re: Show HN: Version Control for Microsoft Word
#114If all you need is to diff documents (Word, Excel, PPT, or arbitrary PDFs) then I can't recommend https://draftable.com/compare enough. It's an amazing tool. Granted, you need to do merges manually with just a diff tool, but that's not usually the bottleneck.
Re: Show HN: Version Control for Microsoft Word
#115Congratulations on your launch! Other folks have provided a bunch of commentary on the validity of your idea, so I won't address that. BUT: if this is a good idea, your pricing is far too low for a niche product like this. $10 (or 10 quid) is too low a monthly fee for pretty much any product marketed as a business product. 10 per seat per month is probably also too low, but would be a better starting point. Likely ob…
I would be careful with raising pricing. It is a very specialized product that requires changing the way people work with their documents today - meaning you need to educate the users on a) why they need this over the regular document version control in something like Sharepoint b) educate them on how to actually use it and c) define how this product fits into existing document management systems and workflows. It's…
Re: Show HN: Version Control for Microsoft Word
#116Re: Show HN: Version Control for Microsoft Word
#117Earlier quoted context omitted.
Not the OP, but I really don't think it does.
Word has native diff-ing and 3-way merging. version control systems can call this as their diff tool.
Have you tried to use Word's features as part of a mid-size team to manage a complicated document being edited by multiple users? Word's merge is crap.
My old law firm used version control software that appeared to be straight from 1991. So there's plenty of room to solve real problems here.
OP, I wish you the best of luck. But I concur with others, the use case for this product I see is for a team or company to learn to use it internally, not for a bunch of lawyers to use it across firms. So, keep the free tier to attract people who are willing to use it on their own (or in case someone can convince those outside their organization to sign up in order to participate on projects), and then increase pricing to any sort of team.
Also, I'm sure my firm could never have used a cloud-based solution, regardless of security, because we probably had clients who would not allow their information to be stored in the cloud.
Also, because I can speak to lawyers, the diffing needs to be excellent and it needs to be easy to create and share redlines in the ways lawyers are used to (send as a word doc/PDF, etc.). Perhaps this is already there, I'm excited to check it out.
Re: Show HN: Version Control for Microsoft Word
#118Earlier quoted context omitted.
I'll answer some of these questions for the developer, because I'm smack in the middle of their target market: litigation attorney. Anything other than Word is a non-starter for 99% of law firms (and the other 1% is still on WordPerfect). Markdown is awesome and I use it for my notes files and all kinds of things but contracts, settlement docs, pleadings, motions, etc etc all exist strictly and only in Word. And prob…
Another lawyer here (tax, UK) - there are similar products available and they're pretty commonly-used over here (such as Worksite for DKMS/version control and Workshare for comparisons between docs). But the VC tends to be centralised, rather than distributed. I've often hankered after a more git-like experience when working remotely or offline, and I will follow this project with interest. One area that is underserv…
I agree the developer needs to take a look at these if he/she has not already but there's plenty of room to improve on those products; I don't think the existence of some mediocre solutions should put the developer off.