101–110 of 226 posts
If I file a bug I get either:
1) nothing
2) a reasonable response that may or may not include resolution
3) a shared debugging journey that takes three hours of my life
Number 3 devs mean well and have admirable commitment…but I’d rather not sign up for an epic trek to throw a ring into mountain doom. I just want to point out an issue and provide some basic info.
So these days the only thing I do for the most part is send crash logs.
Some of this is because one of the worst bug-related metrics is “customer found bugs.” This means that your developers missed it during unit testing and your test team missed it during system and final testing. Nobody actually wants customers to be able to file bug reports because they make the team look bad.
Doing decent bug reports as a user most of the time it feels like following the turnip truck to town picking up turnips that fell off the truck, giving them to the farmer, but knowing they will likely be thrown in the trash because they didn't care about them to start with. If they did they would have made sure to not overload the truck to start with and not be obviously dropping so many turnips on the side of the road and leaving them there.
The problem with bug reporting is that they rarely seem to get fixed. I used to do a lot more bug reports. But you often hear back nothing, and then the bug is never fixed, even if it would be an easy fix. These days, I don't often report bugs.
The devs for the game factorio encourage players to post bugs on the forums. The devs use forums as a issue tracker and respond to bugs with fixes. I have no idea if that makes it more satisfying to report bugs or not, but I always thought it was cool.
The UI has the best productivity-focused design I've ever seen in any GUI application. And its a game. Absolutely incredible.
I use to report bugs all the time with details of the bug and what I was doing and if possible how to cause it. But then when you encounter the same bugs years later doing some very common task that you momentarily forgot to do your work around for, it made me wonder why I was wasting my time reporting it. These days I rarely report bugs unless it is brand new software released a few weeks ago at most, or a brand new…
Yep. That has always been the general industry sentiment [1]:
> Here’s another bug that’s not worth fixing: if you have a bug that totally crashes your program when you open gigantic files, but it only happens to your single user who has OS/2 and who, for all you know, doesn’t even use large files. Well, don’t fix it. Worse things have happened at sea. Similarly I’ve generally given up caring about people with 16 color screens or people running off-the-shelf Windows 95 with no upgrades in 7 years. People like that don’t spend much money on packaged software products.
[1] https://www.joelonsoftware.com/2001/07/31/hard-assed-bug-fix...
The problem with bug reporting is that they rarely seem to get fixed. I used to do a lot more bug reports. But you often hear back nothing, and then the bug is never fixed, even if it would be an easy fix. These days, I don't often report bugs.
The devs for the game factorio encourage players to post bugs on the forums. The devs use forums as a issue tracker and respond to bugs with fixes. I have no idea if that makes it more satisfying to report bugs or not, but I always thought it was cool.
Earlier quoted context omitted.
Some teams have a frickin' bad attitude and couldn't care less. Try submitting a bug about how menus are displayed 5px from where they are supposed to be in a GTK app rendered on a X11-server that runs on the Windows desktop and see if the GTK developers care. Or try telling the react-testing-framework folks that they're asking me to put handrails in my bathroom when my house is burning down. Have experiences like th…
Don't forget all major OSS repositories using a stale bot to close any issue regardless of how many people reported it or how serious it is. Close and lock at times. Yikes.
The stale bot approach does help in cases where a bug does not have merit. For example, not that long ago, a user opened a bug asking us to rename the ZFS Event Daemon so a text editor could adopt the daemon’s name. The consensus among contributors on the discussion is that we will not do it, but no one has volunteered to be the one to close the bug. The stale bot will be closing that one for us.
The difficulty in reporting a bug comes from the friction required to filter the "page doesn't work" with no further explanation reports, or the "my neighbour is a spy for the government and I have proof" reports (real types of reports for a browser company, for example, which surely exist for other places users think that "is" the internet like Facebook). I agree that reporting bugs can be hard, but the amount of sp…
> The difficulty in reporting a bug comes from the friction required to filter the "page doesn't work" with no further explanation reports This so much. I can't tell you how often I've seen someone trying to get tech support on something say "When I load the program, I get an error" but don't even say what the error says. I understand that most people have never worked a QA job and so don't know how to write a good b…
If you're talking about non-technical users, they (a) don't even think of copying the error message, (b) don't know how to copy the error message, and (if the error message isn't directly copyable) (c) have no idea how to do a screenshot.