Live data from Hacker News

Show HN: A Chrome extension that will auto-reject non-essential cookies

blog.bymitch.com

101–110 of 175 posts

Re: Show HN: A Chrome extension that will auto-reject non-essential cookies

#101

What's the difference between this and "I still don't care about cookies"[0]? [0] https://github.com/OhMyGuus/I-Still-Dont-Care-About-Cookies

It rejects cookies & reduces how much you are tracked, rather than accepting all tracking & cookies.

I don't care about cookies plus an extension that deletes frequently plus firefox container tabs will make tracking quite misleading.

Re: Show HN: A Chrome extension that will auto-reject non-essential cookies

#102
post #71
post #8

uBlock Origin already has this. Enable the "Cookie notices" and "Annoyances" filters in uBlock Origin's settings. Bonus pro-tip: Firefox for Android supports uBlock Origin, which means you can get rid of these godawful banners on mobile, too. Only iOS users are stuck having to put up with them.

Orion for iOS supports Firefox and Chrome extensions.

I've been using this and it even blocks YouTube ads. But do note that it often reduces video quality and in shorts there seems to be an off-by-one error where if it's "hide toolbar" then if you click the like it'll click the dislike and if you click dislike it'll click comments.

Worth it IMO but I really wish there was a better way to submit bug reports than creating an account on their site. Fuck that dark pattern

Re: Show HN: A Chrome extension that will auto-reject non-essential cookies

#104

I don’t get it. All browsers have a “do not track” toggle implemented. And still, we get consent banners. Wasn’t I clear when i said don’t track?

when you say 'dont track', it seems like you could really mean 'dont not track', which would make more sense. since thats the safer option, maybe i should assume that. or maybe bring up a dialog that asks 'do you fail to consent to the lack of not tracking'

Re: Show HN: A Chrome extension that will auto-reject non-essential cookies

#105

I don’t get it. All browsers have a “do not track” toggle implemented. And still, we get consent banners. Wasn’t I clear when i said don’t track?

Wilfully ignored because i guess it's not mandated by law.

You need someone powerful like Google to say they will lower Page Rank for sites that don't comply with the Do Not Track flag.

Re: Show HN: A Chrome extension that will auto-reject non-essential cookies

#106

I don’t get it. All browsers have a “do not track” toggle implemented. And still, we get consent banners. Wasn’t I clear when i said don’t track?

when you say 'dont track', it seems like you could really mean 'dont not track', which would make more sense. since thats the safer option, maybe i should assume that. or maybe bring up a dialog that asks 'do you fail to consent to the lack of not tracking'

yes, that’s what i thought. but then, what would be the point of rejecting anything, except to actively consent to something else?

Re: Show HN: A Chrome extension that will auto-reject non-essential cookies

#107

Cookie banners are a bad/wrong solution to the underlying problem, but it's the dark patterns within that really piss me off. I shouldn't have to invest deep cognitive attention to "only accept mandatory" but if you're not careful many dialogs will trick you into clicking accept all after you go to the trouble to untoggle all the optional shit. The answer is to use isolation containers, aggressively reset them and no…

The underlying problem that the cookie banner operators have is there are laws preventing them from abusing the data they collect.

Annoying banners increase pressure on people to contact their representatives to overturn those laws, allowing the operators to abuse the data

Re: Show HN: A Chrome extension that will auto-reject non-essential cookies

#108
Brave does this by default and it works flawlessly apart from on fairly obscure websites (a lot of obscure websites don't have cookie notices anyway).

I don't know why more people don't use Brave - you can turn all the annoying crypto/ad stuff off and it never bothers you about it again.

Re: Show HN: A Chrome extension that will auto-reject non-essential cookies

#110
post #8

uBlock Origin already has this. Enable the "Cookie notices" and "Annoyances" filters in uBlock Origin's settings. Bonus pro-tip: Firefox for Android supports uBlock Origin, which means you can get rid of these godawful banners on mobile, too. Only iOS users are stuck having to put up with them.

Hiding the popup is not the same as clicking reject. It should be but it's not.

This is incorrect. The GDPR requires affirmative consent before processing user information, hiding is not "affirmative." Additionally, there's been increasing litigation via wiretapping statutes (most notably in California where there's statutory minimums for damages) that pose additional legal risk for companies using analytic cookies w/o affirmative consent.
Post reply on HN