Live data from Hacker News

Show HN: Extracting React apps from Figma Make's undocumented binary format

albertsikkema.com

11–20 of 26 posts

Re: Show HN: Extracting React apps from Figma Make's undocumented binary format

#11

> First thing I did was look at the raw bytes: xxd -l 4 "ClientApp.make" I recommend using the linux "file" command, since it will generally be able to tell you these sorts of things straight away. I've been working on a long-term project to directly import figma design files into Unity, so I've ended up coming across a lot of these things myself

Tell it to Mr. Claude. Who do you think made all these decisions?

This is depressing.

We need different language for describing things AI did for us vs things we figured out ourselves. When a human presents work under their own name, there is an unspoken but widely relied-upon assumption that the presenter has exercised judgment over the space of possible choices and can explain why these ones were taken.

In other words, we naturally assume they engaged with the problem space deeply enough to justify the decisions made.

I think AI-produced code and investigation needs a disclaimer, and I say that as someone who uses vibe coding a lot to produce tooling used in our development process.

If you didn’t do it or write it yourself, you don’t understand it as well as if you had. If you didn’t look at the output in great detail and understand every choice made, you really shouldn’t be putting your name on it — or staking your reputation on it — without a pretty clear disclaimer.

And if you present an investigation done by AI as something done by yourself, you’re not really providing human insights. (Almost) anyone can drive an AI, and there’s not a lot of value there for your audience if you don’t disclose that’s what you did.

If you attach your name to work, you are asserting that you can meaningfully answer “why this and not something else?” across the decisions that matter. Tools that produce answers faster than humans think require new language, because our old words still imply thought occurred.

Re: Show HN: Extracting React apps from Figma Make's undocumented binary format

#13

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Tell it to Mr. Claude. Who do you think made all these decisions?

This is depressing. We need different language for describing things AI did for us vs things we figured out ourselves. When a human presents work under their own name, there is an unspoken but widely relied-upon assumption that the presenter has exercised judgment over the space of possible choices and can explain why these ones were taken. In other words, we naturally assume they engaged with the problem space deepl…

the whole blog post and all the author's replies are authored by an LLM.

Re: Show HN: Extracting React apps from Figma Make's undocumented binary format

#14

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This is depressing. We need different language for describing things AI did for us vs things we figured out ourselves. When a human presents work under their own name, there is an unspoken but widely relied-upon assumption that the presenter has exercised judgment over the space of possible choices and can explain why these ones were taken. In other words, we naturally assume they engaged with the problem space deepl…

the whole blog post and all the author's replies are authored by an LLM.

Seems so. It should be much more explicitly disclaimed.

Re: Show HN: Extracting React apps from Figma Make's undocumented binary format

#15

It's interesting that the AI tool just writes react rather than creating a figma drawing. All that training on writing code has made it easier for AI to just write the app than make an illustration of it.

I mean, it makes sense. In order to sketch out a screen, you need to run (most of) a layout engine in your head. If you're an AI, it's simpler to just... use a layout engine.

Re: Show HN: Extracting React apps from Figma Make's undocumented binary format

#16

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Tell it to Mr. Claude. Who do you think made all these decisions?

This is depressing. We need different language for describing things AI did for us vs things we figured out ourselves. When a human presents work under their own name, there is an unspoken but widely relied-upon assumption that the presenter has exercised judgment over the space of possible choices and can explain why these ones were taken. In other words, we naturally assume they engaged with the problem space deepl…

(To clarify, all the work I did was me-authored, not LLM authored)

Re: Show HN: Extracting React apps from Figma Make's undocumented binary format

#17
post #6

Figma's API returns 400 for .make files, so I dug into the binary. Turns out it's a ZIP with a custom format: Deflate for the schema chunk, Zstandard for the data, then Kiwi binary decoding. Scripts on GitHub if useful: https://github.com/albertsikkema/figma-make-extractor

I'm curious if you tried binwalk? That's usually my goto for mysterious files.

that is a good one. Will try that next time.

Re: Show HN: Extracting React apps from Figma Make's undocumented binary format

#18
post #6

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'm curious if you tried binwalk? That's usually my goto for mysterious files.

I agree. It would likely have identified the separate deflate and zstd chunks automatically.

Never thought about using that, thanks for the tip!

Re: Show HN: Extracting React apps from Figma Make's undocumented binary format

#19

Earlier quoted context omitted.

the whole blog post and all the author's replies are authored by an LLM.

Seems so. It should be much more explicitly disclaimed.

Interesting that you feel this is necessary. Why would a disclaimer be needed? If I read the technical docs for a library and use that in my code, should I explicitly mention that I got this from the docs? I know a lot, but am happy to admit I do not know everything, so I am happy to use tools that help me. And I got what I wanted in the end: being able to continue with my real work: helping a client.

Re: Show HN: Extracting React apps from Figma Make's undocumented binary format

#20

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This is depressing. We need different language for describing things AI did for us vs things we figured out ourselves. When a human presents work under their own name, there is an unspoken but widely relied-upon assumption that the presenter has exercised judgment over the space of possible choices and can explain why these ones were taken. In other words, we naturally assume they engaged with the problem space deepl…

the whole blog post and all the author's replies are authored by an LLM.

Funny, actually not the case. Co-authored partly yes, mainly to compensate for my lack of knowledge of the intricacies of English (not my native language). Anyway: take from it what you want, if it helps you: nice! Else: have fun doing something else.
Post reply on HN