Live data from Hacker News

Show HN: Whittle – A shrinking word game

playwhittle.com

11–20 of 64 posts

Re: Show HN: Whittle – A shrinking word game

#11
post #6

Is it always possible to go all the way down to a single letter? I'm working on August 4, and it's proving challenging

Yes, 1 August and 4 August have me stumped. Interestingly it says I have discovered 100% of words on 1 August, but I wasn't able to whittle it down to 0. I'm not sure if that just means I missed an opportunity to remove the space somewhere.

Re: Show HN: Whittle – A shrinking word game

#12
post #6

Is it always possible to go all the way down to a single letter? I'm working on August 4, and it's proving challenging

I had the same issue. I went back to the calendar and it said I got 100% of the words. So I guess it's not always possible and I spent all that time trying for no reason.

Re: Show HN: Whittle – A shrinking word game

#13
Nice! You definitely have something there.

I would love a dictionary lookup. I'd expect a big part of the strategy to be working backwards from the possible 1/2 letter words, but there's no way to tell how reasonable the dictionary is without testing, and getting the game into the proper state to test would be just as hard as solving the puzzle in the first place.

Having two separate goals (eliminate all letters, find all the words) seems confusing. Honestly I find the latter to be a fairly tedious prospect, but the game really seems to push you toward it especially with the colors on the calendar depending on the % of words found. "Damn it, I got a perfect score with no undos, and all I have to show for it is a red square showing how bad a job I did!"

The UI (on a desktop) felt kind of broken at the start because nothing has hover effects. Anything clickable would benefit from some kind of an effect, but especially the letters on the words. If you don't want color changes or animations, at least set the cursor style.

Re: Show HN: Whittle – A shrinking word game

#14

Fun! I was a bit confused at the end because there's no "victory" state or indication. I think I was expecting it to give me a new word pair once I got to the end, or tell me "come back tomorrow for another round"

You can always get it down to zero letters! The game should remind you how many letters you have left before you can win to make it clear .

I think I've tried every combination herbs possible, you have to whittle to her and the to he, and then there's nothing, what do you mean?

Re: Show HN: Whittle – A shrinking word game

#15

Fun! I was a bit confused at the end because there's no "victory" state or indication. I think I was expecting it to give me a new word pair once I got to the end, or tell me "come back tomorrow for another round"

You can always get it down to zero letters! The game should remind you how many letters you have left before you can win to make it clear .

I didn't understand what you were saying at first, but it turns out that you have to click to remove the final, single letter before the "you won" screen shows.

And I agree it would be nice if the game could detect when you've reached a dead end and notify you somehow.

Re: Show HN: Whittle – A shrinking word game

#16
post #14

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You can always get it down to zero letters! The game should remind you how many letters you have left before you can win to make it clear .

I think I've tried every combination herbs possible, you have to whittle to her and the to he, and then there's nothing, what do you mean?

They are saying "the win screen shows up after you click to remove the final letter", not "it is always possible"

Re: Show HN: Whittle – A shrinking word game

#17
post #6

Is it always possible to go all the way down to a single letter? I'm working on August 4, and it's proving challenging

Yes, 1 August and 4 August have me stumped. Interestingly it says I have discovered 100% of words on 1 August, but I wasn't able to whittle it down to 0. I'm not sure if that just means I missed an opportunity to remove the space somewhere.

Or maybe it depends on the order in which you remove the letters? Just a guess.

Re: Show HN: Whittle – A shrinking word game

#19
post #14

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You can always get it down to zero letters! The game should remind you how many letters you have left before you can win to make it clear .

I think I've tried every combination herbs possible, you have to whittle to her and the to he, and then there's nothing, what do you mean?

It’s solvable if you whittle down to “a”
Post reply on HN