Live data from Hacker News

Show HN: BunkerWeb – the open-source and cloud-native WAF

docs.bunkerweb.io

11–20 of 32 posts

Re: Show HN: BunkerWeb – the open-source and cloud-native WAF

#11
post #5

I'm still strongly suspecting this whole WAF thing is mostly complete bullshit intended for projects doing security works mostly from spreadsheets. Could someone with a proper background in security confirm or invalidate my suspicion ?

In addition to defense-in-depth—simply adding a bunch of imperfect layers and acknowledging that no individual layer like this is all that effective on its own—there’s a component of creating signal: it can be pretty trivial for a motivated attacker to bypass a WAF, however it may not be trivial to do so without creating a paper trail of event logs, which can be used to trigger automated blocks or escalate alarms for a human to intervene.

Re: Show HN: BunkerWeb – the open-source and cloud-native WAF

#12
I just love this project! BunkerWeb was a huge help when I was self-hosting my products with Docker Swarm. It offers tons of configuration options—especially useful for those needing a WAF and dealing with heavy bot traffic.

Since moving to Kubernetes, I haven’t used or evaluated it there yet, but kudos to the team for continuing to update and improve the project. Keep up the great work!

Re: Show HN: BunkerWeb – the open-source and cloud-native WAF

#13

Is there a significant difference between this and nginx proxy manager?

They're both reverse proxies built on nginx, but the whole point of BunkerWeb is that it's a WAF, which NPM is not, so that's a significant difference. In short, NPM doesn't do any of the stuff listed under Security Features here: https://docs.bunkerweb.io/latest/#security-features

NPM will automate Let's Encrypt certificate generation but you're right about the other listed features.

Re: Show HN: BunkerWeb – the open-source and cloud-native WAF

#14
post #5

I'm still strongly suspecting this whole WAF thing is mostly complete bullshit intended for projects doing security works mostly from spreadsheets. Could someone with a proper background in security confirm or invalidate my suspicion ?

I'd generally confirm that suspicion: https://www.macchaffee.com/blog/2023/wafs/

WAFs have a few valid uses in my opinion: "virtual patching" and the ability to create custom rules such as blocking/challenging/rate limiting obviously bad traffic. But the giant rulesets are actively harmful IMO. "Defense in depth" is not a valid justification for doing something actively harmful to both your users and the time budget of your security team.

Re: Show HN: BunkerWeb – the open-source and cloud-native WAF

#16
post #15

What's the benefit of just using plain owasp modsecurity? It also exists as a docker container as an nginx reverse proxy with modsecurity extension. https://coreruleset.org/docs/6-development/6-6-useful_tools/...

ModSecurity doesn't offer antibot, bad behavior, certificate management, ... You can find the full list of features here : https://docs.bunkerweb.io/latest/features/

Re: Show HN: BunkerWeb – the open-source and cloud-native WAF

#17

I just love this project! BunkerWeb was a huge help when I was self-hosting my products with Docker Swarm. It offers tons of configuration options—especially useful for those needing a WAF and dealing with heavy bot traffic. Since moving to Kubernetes, I haven’t used or evaluated it there yet, but kudos to the team for continuing to update and improve the project. Keep up the great work!

Thanks for the kind words!

Kubernetes integration is really awesome, you can use BunkerWeb ingress controller or mix it with an existing ingress controller.

Re: Show HN: BunkerWeb – the open-source and cloud-native WAF

#18

Your site talks of BunkerWeb PRO, which is, by the sound of it, not open source. But I have no idea what is actually different about it: https://panel.bunkerweb.io/knowledgebase/105/What-is-BunkerW... flatly doesn’t answer the question: “additional features and services responding to professional needs” is impressively vague.

Features with a crown icon are PRO, you will find full list of free and PRO features here : https://docs.bunkerweb.io/latest/features/
Post reply on HN