Live data from Hacker News

Show HN: Container-compose – A Docker-compose like tool for Apple containers

github.com

11–17 of 17 posts

Re: Show HN: Container-compose – A Docker-compose like tool for Apple containers

#11
post #6
post #2

Any thoughts or insights into why Apple didn't ship docker-compose support?

It took Podman a good 2 or so years to develop a good docker compatible http api. I presume that's why. There's no point in coming out with all of the features when they can release with some support, and add on top of it.

Even today, some docker-compose features still don’t work with podman. There’s just an absurd amount of subtleties and edge cases, but pretty much all my usages hit one of these or another.

Re: Show HN: Container-compose – A Docker-compose like tool for Apple containers

#14

Hoping that VSCode supports Apple Containers in a similar way to it supporting Docker Containers. I’ve tried Podman to use less resources on my Mac, but found that the developer tooling in things like VSCode makes Docker a bit sticky.

Looking at the ecosystem between docker and podman/oci, I hope the OCI tooling gets better.

I know docker is easier to dev on for many currently, it's also been around longer, but there is a widening gap between docker deployments in production and podman deployments in production and it isn't nearly as smooth or secure as either should be.

Re: Show HN: Container-compose – A Docker-compose like tool for Apple containers

#15
post #6

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It took Podman a good 2 or so years to develop a good docker compatible http api. I presume that's why. There's no point in coming out with all of the features when they can release with some support, and add on top of it.

Even today, some docker-compose features still don’t work with podman. There’s just an absurd amount of subtleties and edge cases, but pretty much all my usages hit one of these or another.

Biggest reason is that docker / podman/OCI are very different architectures and security models.

I hope there is something new. The tooling and deployment fragmentation is a nightmare.

From a security and open standards pov, we maybe should be moving to podman/OCI.

The docker tooling was often focused on the dev experience and it showed, but it wasn't a system with a good security model and this transition is a large part of that pain.

Re: Show HN: Container-compose – A Docker-compose like tool for Apple containers

#17

Hoping that VSCode supports Apple Containers in a similar way to it supporting Docker Containers. I’ve tried Podman to use less resources on my Mac, but found that the developer tooling in things like VSCode makes Docker a bit sticky.

Does anything still break in that Docker tooling if you use it with the podman socket via DOCKER_HOST?
Post reply on HN