Live data from Hacker News

Show HN: Every problem and solution in Beyond Cracking the Coding Interview

news.ycombinator.com

11–20 of 114 posts

Re: Show HN: Every problem and solution in Beyond Cracking the Coding Interview

#11

[flagged]

IMO "easy/medium" coding questions have their place. I run quite a lot of interviews and I have many many "seniors" from known techn companies that can't do exercises that are glorified reverse for loops.

The idea all tech companies require you to know niche data structures is kind of a meme honestly. I'm sure some do but not the ones I've interviewed at at least.

Re: Show HN: Every problem and solution in Beyond Cracking the Coding Interview

#12

[flagged]

No other engineering discipline has such a low barrier to entry where everyone can self tech themselves at home almost everything people that go through the higher education pipeline can, and then extra on top due to how fast the industry evolves, where even having a degree might not make you qualified for a job today. In no other engineering discipline is all the tooling FOSS. So the PRO is that anyone can become a…

How many 100% self taught, no prior experience people are applying to these positions and are accepted for interviews? Obviously that number is extremely low especially given the last couple of years.

Having a process which only exist for the 1% of least likely candidates is absurd. Even if you wanted to give these people w chance, obviously you don't need to subject the 99% of people to the same process. What is the point of asking a CS graduate with 5 years industry experience some brain teaser questions? There is literally no point, it tells you exactly zero about the candidate.

Also, you can self teach everything in most engineering disciplines. What part of Electrical engineering or mechanical engineering requires a substantial financial investment or has things you could only learn in a university?

Re: Show HN: Every problem and solution in Beyond Cracking the Coding Interview

#14
post #3

This sounds like an amazing resource. What’s the rationale for making it all free?

> What’s the rationale for making it all free?

The writing is on the wall for Leetcode-style interviewing. The signal-to-noise ratio is diminishing in the age of AI (cheating). These sorts of puzzle challenges might no longer play a meaningful role going forward.

Re: Show HN: Every problem and solution in Beyond Cracking the Coding Interview

#15

Earlier quoted context omitted.

No other engineering discipline has such a low barrier to entry where everyone can self tech themselves at home almost everything people that go through the higher education pipeline can, and then extra on top due to how fast the industry evolves, where even having a degree might not make you qualified for a job today. In no other engineering discipline is all the tooling FOSS. So the PRO is that anyone can become a…

How many 100% self taught, no prior experience people are applying to these positions and are accepted for interviews? Obviously that number is extremely low especially given the last couple of years. Having a process which only exist for the 1% of least likely candidates is absurd. Even if you wanted to give these people w chance, obviously you don't need to subject the 99% of people to the same process. What is the…

Sir, this is a Show HN.

Re: Show HN: Every problem and solution in Beyond Cracking the Coding Interview

#16
post #11

[flagged]

IMO "easy/medium" coding questions have their place. I run quite a lot of interviews and I have many many "seniors" from known techn companies that can't do exercises that are glorified reverse for loops. The idea all tech companies require you to know niche data structures is kind of a meme honestly. I'm sure some do but not the ones I've interviewed at at least.

Sure, if you think the candidate might actually be lacking basic skills, which wasn't obvious from his resume you obviously ask him some basic trivia. But establishing this as part of a process, including having companies which prepare you for this process is ridiculous.

What is the point of all of this. No other industry has this.

Re: Show HN: Every problem and solution in Beyond Cracking the Coding Interview

#17
post #15

Earlier quoted context omitted.

How many 100% self taught, no prior experience people are applying to these positions and are accepted for interviews? Obviously that number is extremely low especially given the last couple of years. Having a process which only exist for the 1% of least likely candidates is absurd. Even if you wanted to give these people w chance, obviously you don't need to subject the 99% of people to the same process. What is the…

Sir, this is a Show HN.

And therefore you aren't allowed to criticize it?

If what you are making is built upon a joke of a premise that should be criticized.

Re: Show HN: Every problem and solution in Beyond Cracking the Coding Interview

#18
This is awesome. Just for awareness - I started going through the book a few days ago and there's a lot of other useful information outside of the LC style questions (e.g. what's actually important on a resume, how to realistically get your foot in the door with companies, etc.). Very data driven and comprehensive, so for me there's still a lot of value in the non LC parts of the book.

Re: Show HN: Every problem and solution in Beyond Cracking the Coding Interview

#20
post #15

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Sir, this is a Show HN.

And therefore you aren't allowed to criticize it? If what you are making is built upon a joke of a premise that should be criticized.

You are allowed to criticize it but you can't fulminate and you can't go on some generic tangent, just like pretty much always? It's both in the Show HN thing https://news.ycombinator.com/showhn.html and the site thing https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
Post reply on HN