I think both of these projects miss what makes TikTok (and reels in general) so effective. A good TikTok video gets "injected into your brain". You have zero effort to provide and suddenly this stuff is in your mind. I'm not saying it's a good thing, I realize the danger, but that's the core mechanism. A friend in marketing describes this in terms of "brain calories". Eg if people have to think in order to understand…
> "A good TikTok video gets "injected into your brain"" I worked in marketing, so I'm generally immune to outrageous metaphor, such as "injected" into your brain. That said, I just want to point out the irony we're still using phrases like this after 20+ years of research on networked media and user interaction, and soft science research into cognitive psychology and behavioral psychology, as well as research into hu…
Show HN: HN as TikTok, welcome to HN hell
11–20 of 66 posts
Re: Show HN: HN as TikTok, welcome to HN hell
#12I think both of these projects miss what makes TikTok (and reels in general) so effective. A good TikTok video gets "injected into your brain". You have zero effort to provide and suddenly this stuff is in your mind. I'm not saying it's a good thing, I realize the danger, but that's the core mechanism. A friend in marketing describes this in terms of "brain calories". Eg if people have to think in order to understand…
> "A good TikTok video gets "injected into your brain"" I worked in marketing, so I'm generally immune to outrageous metaphor, such as "injected" into your brain. That said, I just want to point out the irony we're still using phrases like this after 20+ years of research on networked media and user interaction, and soft science research into cognitive psychology and behavioral psychology, as well as research into hu…
Re: Show HN: HN as TikTok, welcome to HN hell
#13Oh, thanks! That was such a quick implementation—and a nice addition to the Show HN gallery, especially for HN-related projects. When I came across WikiTok yesterday, the first thought that popped into my mind was how this format could work for HN. And here we are! With the abundance of AI coding assistants available today, creating prototypes, demos, or MVPs can now be done in just a few hours instead of taking days…
I made a prototype template for a site and had it exactly how I wanted in about an hour. I mocked it up in Photopea, gave Claude an image, and told it to generate HTML that would make a page with those qualities. A few tweaks and a couple more prompts later and I had all the main elements I wanted in place, and just need to fill content which I won't use AI for. Probably saved me several hours because I suck at front…
Re: Show HN: HN as TikTok, welcome to HN hell
#14Earlier quoted context omitted.
> "A good TikTok video gets "injected into your brain"" I worked in marketing, so I'm generally immune to outrageous metaphor, such as "injected" into your brain. That said, I just want to point out the irony we're still using phrases like this after 20+ years of research on networked media and user interaction, and soft science research into cognitive psychology and behavioral psychology, as well as research into hu…
I'd be curious to hear how you'd express these notions in more scientific terms?
?? Did you read past the second paragraph? My lament is that neither of us have this language. And after 20 years very little to nothing has percolated up from research to provide it.
Re: Show HN: HN as TikTok, welcome to HN hell
#15Earlier quoted context omitted.
> "A good TikTok video gets "injected into your brain"" I worked in marketing, so I'm generally immune to outrageous metaphor, such as "injected" into your brain. That said, I just want to point out the irony we're still using phrases like this after 20+ years of research on networked media and user interaction, and soft science research into cognitive psychology and behavioral psychology, as well as research into hu…
It requires too many brain calories.
Re: Show HN: HN as TikTok, welcome to HN hell
#16Re: Show HN: HN as TikTok, welcome to HN hell
#17Re: Show HN: HN as TikTok, welcome to HN hell
#18It's still an aggregator of links though.
You're missing the "zero effort" factor, which could be achieved by summarizing the content and generating some AI cartoon or video based on it. It would be somewhat costly but much more fun to browse.
Re: Show HN: HN as TikTok, welcome to HN hell
#19Use an LLM to summarize each page in one sentence. This takes too much effort to feel like TikTok.
Re: Show HN: HN as TikTok, welcome to HN hell
#20Use an LLM to summarize each page in one sentence. This takes too much effort to feel like TikTok.
Or the entire comments section. That could be some good comedy.