Hacker News Board Hacker News, browsed like a classic message board
Live data from Hacker News

Show HN: GPT-4-Vision UX audit for your landing page (relaunch)

flawless.is

Post reply on HN
Print view View original

11–17 of 17 posts

Re: Show HN: GPT-4-Vision UX audit for your landing page (relaunch)

#11

Post by liorgrossman »

Broiling3167 wrote: post #10
liorgrossman wrote: post #8

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That's great to hear. I think now I better understand your original question. Yeah, to run an audit again on that same site, you'd need to pay again. Otherwise, I'll have to put in place user management & user rate limits to avoid abuse, since someone could run this 50 times on their website within a given day, and currently OpenAI limits us to 100 queries per day.

I understand clearly now, thank you very much for your detailed responses and an inspiring tool you shared with us! As a solo full-stack web dev from Turkey, I will be closely following this tool's future, and looking forward to your continued development of it. For an audience like me (solo developers) this is potentially incredibly useful, and at worst a nice heuristic apparatus that’s worth paying, so thank you ag…

Of course, thank you for the kind words!

Re: Show HN: GPT-4-Vision UX audit for your landing page (relaunch)

#14

Post by user_named »

I paid for this and tried it on one of our main pages.

It did identify one point that is correct and that I have brought up with the team previously, and we are currently fixing it.

So either points like fine print being too small I think we're not correct and it doesn't understand the use of such a section.

Also the screenshot is of the page not loaded correctly.

Re: Show HN: GPT-4-Vision UX audit for your landing page (relaunch)

#15

Post by potatosalad21 »

artur_makly wrote: post #7

Any Senior UX folks here that can review the quality recommendations shown on the audit results posted on this site? A quick glance shows some dubious suggestions. Still better than no UX audit.

UX here with 10 years experience. It's... not great. Mostly suggestions to fix things that are fine with made up reasons, but some advice that's actively bad. For example:

Problem:The FAQ section requires users to click to view answers, which may reduce engagement

Suggestion:Use an accordion with the first item expanded by default to encourage interaction

Re: Show HN: GPT-4-Vision UX audit for your landing page (relaunch)

#16

Post by liorgrossman »

user_named wrote: post #14

I paid for this and tried it on one of our main pages. It did identify one point that is correct and that I have brought up with the team previously, and we are currently fixing it. So either points like fine print being too small I think we're not correct and it doesn't understand the use of such a section. Also the screenshot is of the page not loaded correctly.

Thanks for being one of our early adopters!

Glad to hear it did find something that you can correct.

Regarding the points about fine print (and the screenshot not loaded correctly) - would you kindly reply with the URL of the website you audited here, or email it to me to feedback at flawless.is ?

I'd love to take a look and see if these issues could be fixed or improved.

Re: Show HN: GPT-4-Vision UX audit for your landing page (relaunch)

#17

Post by liorgrossman »

11217mackem wrote: post #13

is the prompt any more sophisticated than? "do a ux audit on this page with the format "problem" and "solution" with tags messaging, cro, usability, marketing, etc" or rather, significantly more? this seems super, super simple.

Well, it started off this way, but I went through several iterations with the audit prompt and the system prompt to improve the issue detection, the solutions suggested, tag them, reduce hallucinations, provide approximate image coordinates, provide examples to the model, etc. It's currently at over 20 lines of prompting and I guess this will grow over time.
Post reply on HN