Live data from Hacker News

Show HN: Text editor with inline English-German dictionary

github.com

11–19 of 19 posts

Re: Show HN: Text editor with inline English-German dictionary

#11
post #5

Super cool project!! I can really imagine this being helpful, I love alternative language learning tools, also keen on for e.g., Language Learning with Netflix which lets you see dual subtitles while watching netflix. I will drop my own (very naive, possibly incorrect) side project that I made while learning German myself, always happy for feedback! agol.io/trainer

[deleted]

Re: Show HN: Text editor with inline English-German dictionary

#12
post #10

Neat! Two issues I found: 1) if I type @being I get zero options, even though it's in the dict https://www.wikdict.com/de-en/being . I only get options for expanding @be 2) I can't expand @be/being into a noun ('Beings surrounded our ship'), only into a verb/gerund ('Being John Malkovich')

That is something which could be addressed by stemming or lemmatizing the input before piping it into whatever you use for translation.

Re: Show HN: Text editor with inline English-German dictionary

#13
post #8

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I love the reading and the explanations, it's all very clear, nice work! This trainer is cool, but maybe I'm too ignorant to understand the prompts. For example, "Das Essen … Frau" What case is it looking for? I assume it's nominative, but I don't know what the context is. But "die" is not accepted. Is it implied that "the food is eaten by the woman"?

Nominative? You want to say "the food the woman"? I don't really remember the Life of Brian skit, so I'll just skip ahead and say you may want the genetive case: "Das Essen der Frau," "the woman's food."

[deleted]

Re: Show HN: Text editor with inline English-German dictionary

#14
post #5

Super cool project!! I can really imagine this being helpful, I love alternative language learning tools, also keen on for e.g., Language Learning with Netflix which lets you see dual subtitles while watching netflix. I will drop my own (very naive, possibly incorrect) side project that I made while learning German myself, always happy for feedback! agol.io/trainer

I love the reading and the explanations, it's all very clear, nice work! This trainer is cool, but maybe I'm too ignorant to understand the prompts. For example, "Das Essen … Frau" What case is it looking for? I assume it's nominative, but I don't know what the context is. But "die" is not accepted. Is it implied that "the food is eaten by the woman"?

Genitiv

Re: Show HN: Text editor with inline English-German dictionary

#15
post #9

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I love the reading and the explanations, it's all very clear, nice work! This trainer is cool, but maybe I'm too ignorant to understand the prompts. For example, "Das Essen … Frau" What case is it looking for? I assume it's nominative, but I don't know what the context is. But "die" is not accepted. Is it implied that "the food is eaten by the woman"?

Ah yes, probably needs a bit more explanation there, I wanted to expand that tool with various features like tracking user performance for each case and repeating cases with a low-performance as well, but eventually moved on from the project. I perceive this kind of stuff to be a bit lacking in e.g., Duolingo which is more focussed on phrases (and I found it to be a bit too repetitive with phrases you already know, w…

Ohh...that makes so much more sense now! thanks and well done

Re: Show HN: Text editor with inline English-German dictionary

#18
post #12
post #10

Neat! Two issues I found: 1) if I type @being I get zero options, even though it's in the dict https://www.wikdict.com/de-en/being . I only get options for expanding @be 2) I can't expand @be/being into a noun ('Beings surrounded our ship'), only into a verb/gerund ('Being John Malkovich')

That is something which could be addressed by stemming or lemmatizing the input before piping it into whatever you use for translation.

That's something I will have to look into. Thank you for the suggestions.

Re: Show HN: Text editor with inline English-German dictionary

#19
post #6

Makes me wonder if you could reasonably write an LSP server for text and then plug it into your editor for on-the-fly autocomplete, translations etc?

Definitely something I want to explore later on, if I can make the individual prototypes work well by themselves.
Post reply on HN